Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-12-1995 City Council Minutes MIIJUTES REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING CITY OP LAKE ELSIBORE 183 NORTH HAIN STREET LAKE ELSINORB, CALIPORHIA TUESDAY, DBCEMBER 12, 1995 ***************************************************************** CALL TO ORDER The Regular City Council Meeting was called to order by Mayor Pape at 7:01 p.m. PLEDGE OP ALLEGIANCE The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Mayor Pro Tem Kelley. Mayor Pape stated that he had received a number of requests to speak on Agenda items and Non-Agenda items and if anyone else in the audience wished to address Council, he asked that requests be filled out and submitted to the City Clerk immediately, since he would not receive "Requests to speak" later on. ROLL CALL PRESENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: BRINLEY, KELLEY, METZE, PAPE ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: ALONGI Also present were: city Manager Molendyk, Assistant city Manager Watenpaugh, city Attorney Harper, Administrative Services Director Boone, Community Development Director Leslie, Community Services Director Sapp, Public Services Director Tecca, Manager of Special Projects Best, Special projects Coordinator Wood and City Clerk Kasad. PRESENTATIONS/CEREMONIALS A. Presentation - Temescal Canyon High school. (F:142.1) Mayor Pape commended the character of the Temescal Canyon High School Football Team and stated his appreciation for their concern and care for his family. Mayor Pape presented the Temescal Canyon High School "Titans" a proclamation honoring their win of the CIF Southern Division VIII Title win. Coach Bob Burt accepted the proclamation on behalf of the student athletes and coaches. He commended his team as outstanding students and people and thanked Council for the honor. Mayor Pape made note of the fact that the entire community was proud of the team both as football players and as students in the community. B. Presentation - Air SDorts. (F:14.1) Mayor Pape stated that there would be three presentations regarding Air Sports; John pitt on Hang Gliding; Mike u""u........^.... ^.... r!1~N........ nl"'....oC!. "'1"'lN rron1"'lU R't"'nrrNn1"'l n1"'l ~1ru niui1"'lrr_ PAGE TWO - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - DECEMBER 12, 1995 park setting since people from allover the world come to Lake Elsinore to Hang Glide. City Manager Molendyk pointed out that the purpose of this presentation is to provide some of the history of these sports. John Pitt, Chairman of the site Committee of the Hang Gliding Association of Lake Elsinore stated that he was present to explain the economic benefits and number of tourists that visit Lake Elsinore and will visit Lake Elsinore in the future. He presented a video of Hang Gliding which gave an overview of the sport. Mr. pitt stressed the importance of the landing site and gave an overview of the reasons why people come from allover the world to fly here. He stated that the climate and wind conditions are unique to the area and this is one of the major draws. ..... Eric RaYmond, National Hang Gliding Champion, spoke in support of the sport of Hang Gliding in Lake Elsinore. He also expressed support for the airport and the possibility of permanent hangars, at the airport. Tony Brogdon, President of Skydive, California and Manager of Skylark Airport, promoted the sport of Sky Diving, gave an overview of the sport in Lake Elsinore and the safety methods used. He introduced the people involved in the management of the Airport and Sky Diving and stated that he would like to see Council support Sky Diving and allow night jumps. He stated that his organization is not opposed to Mentor Airport, but would like to have the ability to give input to prevent conflict, since they are the airport referred to in the Master Plan for that area. City Manager Molendyk explained that in regard to Skylark Airport, the purpose of this discussion was to introduce night jumping and to have the airport recognized as a recreational airport. ..... Mayor Pape explained that there was a Study Session held in November, regarding the Hang Gliding, Sky Diving and Gliding and he thanked the people giving their presentations for their participation at tonight's Meeting. Mike Havenor, President of the Lake Elsinore Soaring Club, spoke in support of a recreational airport, being Skylark Airport. C. Holiday Patrol - Lieutenant John Bovd. (F:127.2) Captain Boyd reminded the audience that this is the Holiday Season and that the public should take proper safety precautions. He stated that next week there will be a Crime Sweep Show which will discuss various aspects of Holiday safety and give tips on how to implement them. He made note of the fact that up to and through the Holidays there will be additional bicycle patrols in the various retail areas, the Outlet Center and Downtown as well as extra vehicle n~+rnl_ T.i~l+~n~n+ Rnvrl wiqh~rl ~v~rvnn~ ~ q~~~ ~nrl h~nnv fi'" PAGE THREB - CITY COUNCIL KIBUTBS- DBCEMBER 12, 1"5 CONSENT CALENDAR The following items were pulled from the Consent Calendar for further discussion and consideration: Item Nos. la, 1b, 4, 5, 6, 10, 12, and 14. - MOVED BY BRINLBY, SBCONDBD BY MBTZB AND CARRIBD BY UHABIMOUS VOTE OF THOSE PRBSENT TO APPROVE THB BALANCB OF THB CONSENT CALENDAR AS PRESENTBD. 1. The following Minutes were approved: c. special City Council Meeting for December 5, 1995. (F:44.4) The following Minutes were received and filed. d. Planning commission Meeting for November 1, 1995. (F:60.3) e. Planning Commission Meeting for November 15, 1995. f. Design Review Committee Meeting for November 1, 1995. (F:60.4) g. Design Review Committee Meeting for November 15, 1995. 2. Ratified the Warrant List for November 30, 1995. (F:12.3) 3. Rejected and referred to Claims Administrator for handling the Claims Submitted by: I. Gilbert Logg (CL #95-22); Michael Hartgraves (CL #95-24); and James Garvin (CL #95- 25). (F:52.2) - 7. Approved community Facilities District 95-1 (City Center) and adopted Resolution No. 95-79 as follows: (F:22.3) RESOLUTION NO. '5-7' A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORB, CALIFORNIA, AUTHORIZING THB ISSUANCE OF SPECIAL TAX BONDS OF THE CITY OF LAKB ELSINORB FOR CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE COKHUNITY FACILITIBS DISTRICT NO. '5-1 (LAKE ELSINORB CITY CENTER PUBLIC IMPROVEMENTS), APPROVING AND DIRECTING THB BXBCUTION OF A FISCAL AGENT AGRBEKBNT, AND APPROVING OTHBR RBLATBD DOCUKBNTS AND ACTIONS. 8. Approved and adopted Resolution 95-30 regarding stop sign controlled intersections at pottery/Ellis, Pottery/Lookout, Flint/Ellis, Flint/Lookout as following: (F:162.2) RBSOLUTION NO. '5-80 A RBSOLUTION OF THB CITY COUNCIL OF THB CITY OF LAKB BLSINORE, DESIGNATING THB LOCATION OF CERTAIN STOP INTERSECTIONS. Q ]\.nn........u...~ 2n~ 2~....n+-...~ +-h... .......U; !I::...n ("nnnr.; 1 1)n1; I"!V r...n"rn; nn 'Tt ,'>.',,;~ ;f'i\I'h;'Ji.~ PAGE FOUR - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - DECEMBER 12, 1995 13. Approved and adopted Resolution 95-81 in support of the sport of Hang Gliding. (F:14.1) RESOLUTION NO. 95-81 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE CALIFORNIA, IN SUPPORT OF PRESERVATION OF THE SPORT OF BAHG GLIDING. 15. Approved cancellation of the City Council Meeting of December 26, 1995. (F:44.1) ITEMS PULLED FROM CONSENT CALENDAR 1. a. City Council study Session - November 21. 1995. b. Reqular city Council Meetinq - November 28. 1995 (F:44.4) Councilman Metze stated that he wished to abstain on these items. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY PAPE AND CARRIED BY A 3 TO 0 VOTE OF THOSE PRESENT WITH METZE ABSTAINING FROM THE VOTE, AND ALONGI ABSENT. 4. Support for Park Bond Act Funds - Resolution No. 95-76. (F:92.1) (X:36.1) city Manager Molendyk gave an overview of this item and stated that the object of this resolution is to try to recover the 3 and 1/2 Million dollars that the State took to balance their budget. He explained that some of the money would fund an aeration system to relieve some of the algae problems and fish kills. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY KELLEY AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE OF THOSE PRESENT TO APPROVE RESOLUTION NO. 95-76. RESOLUTION NO. 95-76 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE, CALIFORNIA, SUPPORTING THB BFFORT TO OBTAIN THB 3.5 MILLION DOLLARS RAIDED FROM THE 1976 PARK BOND ACT FUNDS. 5. SUDDort for city's SDhere of Influence - Resolution No. 95- 77. (F:154.1) City Manager Molendyk stated that 1986 five cities went together to establish a Sphere of Influence which is determined by LAFCO and is used for planning purposes so that streets and standards are consistent. He explained that since the adoption of the Sphere of Influence there have been a number of Communities of Interest formed which affect our City's Sphere of Influence. He further explained that this resolution is a reminder to LAFCO that we do have a plan that they approved in 1986 and that the City would like them to adhere to the approved City'S Sphere of TnflllAnt'!A_ PAGB PIVB - CITY COUMCIL KlBUTBS - DBCBNBER 12, 1995 Mayor Pro Tem Kelley stated that she attended a LAFCO meeting this week and she has some concerns regarding this issue and spoke with Mr. Spiliotis. She noted that the Resolution states that the Sphere of Interest has been chipped away and in fact she feels that the Community of Interest was formed to work with the City to allow a study time of two years and was told that although LAFCO does not encourage annexation, they do not prohibit it. She explained that her other concern was that this is an after the fact issue and that in effect the cows have already left the barn. COUNCILMAN ALONGI ARRIVED AT 7:50 P.M. MOVED BY BRINLBY, SBCONDED BY MBTZB AND CARRIBD BY A 4 TO 1 VOTB WITH KELLBY CASTING THB DISSBNTING VOTB TO ADOPT RBSOLUTION NO. 95-77: RESOLUTION NO. 95-77 A RESOLUTION OF THB CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORB, CALIFORNIA, IN SUPPORT OF THE SPHERB OF INFLUENCE FOR THB CITIES OP RIVERSIDB, MORENO VALLBY, PERRIS AND CORONA, AS ADOPTED IN 1985 BY THB RIVERSIDE COUNTY LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSION (LAFCO). 6. Bond Refinancing - Series A & Series B - Resolution No. 95- 78. (F:126.5) - Special Projects Coordinator Wood explained that the Staff Report indicates that the bonds were ready to be sold, and in fact the bonds have been sold, and the interests rates are better than anticipated. He further explained that the bonds were issued primarily to refund the two previous bond anticipation notes which were issued in 1993 and 1995. He stated that one of the bonds would be maturing on January 1, for $8,000,000 and the other in the summer for $10,000,000. Mr. Wood explained that the amount of the new bonds cover these two debts and additional Redevelopment projects. Mayor Pape stated that it is his understanding that the Series A Bonds were "AAA" rated for $13,000,000 with an interest rate of 5.85%. Mr. Wood stated that they are indeed at 5.85% interest and insured. Chris Hyland, 15191 Wavecrest, asked for a copy of all of the documents which give the financial delineation of the bonds and the inclusion of the yearly escalation of interest of the bonds. city Attorney Harper stated that he does not respond to questions of the Public Information Act, but she should submit her request to the City Clerk's Office for response. He further explained that if Mrs. Hyland would like to wait, his office would provide the Preliminary Official Statement and the Official Statement when they are printed which answers all the questions she was asking. PAGE SIX - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - DECEMBER 12, 1995 10. Allocation of Funds- Traffic Sianals at Lincoln street/ Machado street and Lakeshore Drive/Chanev street. (F:162.4) Councilwoman Brinley asked when the traffic signals will be in operation. City Manager Molendyk stated that these are projects that Council has worked with the residents on. He stated that this item will allow for the award of the contracts for approximately $100,000 each and will be operating by March of this year. .... MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY PAPE TO APPROVE THE ALLOCATION OF FUNDS FOR TRAFFIC SIGNALS AT LINCOLN STREET/MACHADO STREET AND LAKESHORE DRIVE/CHANEY STREET. Councilman Alongi asked why a signal is being placed at Lakeshore and Chaney since the area has not been developed as planned at this time; and since traffic seems to be moving quite well at this time. Public Services Director Tecca stated that both locations meet Nationally accepted warrants for traffic signal control, which means that the City has reached the level of traffic whereby putting in a traffic signal makes the intersection safer. He explained that the City has been very fortunate that there have been no right-Of-way accidents at those locations since the stop signs were installed, but those two intersections have enough traffic to be subject to major accidents and this action will prevent that from happening. councilman Alongi stated that he does not agree with this since there are many other intersections which need signalization more than those two intersections. He explained that he goes through the Chaney/Lakeshore intersection several times a day and he feels that it is the best controlled corner in the city. __ Mayor Pro Tem Kelley stated that she had received a call regarding a traffic signal at Riverside Drive and Lincoln and asked if there were plans to place a signal there. Public Services Director Tecca stated that Cal-Trans is funding a traffic signal at Riverside Drive and Lincoln street. He explained that the City had requested traffic signals at all the major intersections some time ago and all of the requests were denied except Riverside Drive and Lincoln. He stated that they will be funding it late in 1996. THE FOREGOING MOTION WAS APPROVED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE. 12. National Speedboat and Water Ski Association Request for Use of Lake Elsinore. (F:151.1) City Manager stated that this is a request for several boat races for 1996. Ron Swanson, President of the National Speed Boat and Water Ski Association, presented a plaque to the Council. He gave PAGE SEVEN - CITY COUBCIL KIKUTES - DBCBKBBR 12, 1995 Belgium and Australia. He stated that they are working with the Lake Elsinore storm for promotion and will place boats on display. He stated that they plan on a vendors row to allow business for the local businessmen. Mayor Pape then called upon those persons who had requested to speak as follows: Bob Schiffner, 33450 Welham Place, stated that he was selected by the Chamber of Commerce Support the Lake Committee to represent them and state their views in regard to the total closure of the Lake. He explained that they do endorse this type of operation on the Lake, but they do oppose total closure of the Lake. He further explained that it creates a loss of revenue since it discourages people who come here to use the Lake and don't know that it is closed for this type of events. He stated that they leave and do not come back. He asked that the problem with sending people away from the Lake be considered and stated that there could be some type of solution to answer this issue. .... Peter Dawson, 18010 Grand Avenue, stated that his company Pro Marine, sponsors the Ski Races for the last two years and will continue to do so. He explained the expenses that they have faced in regard to the boat and ski races. He proposed the following: 1) That there be partial Lake closure, unless the event is large enough to close the Lake and will compensate the business around the Lake. He reminded Council that the City launch ramp is one of the businesses sUffering when the Lake is closed; 2) That as an alternate, consideration could be given to smaller operations being moved to the Levee area and then the north, west and south shores would be open to the general public; 3) Conditioning the Boat and Ski Races as well as other events to advertise extensively outside the area, so that Orange, L.A. and San Diego Counties know of our events and will attend as spectators and will leave some of their dollars in our town; and 4) The city of Lake Elsinore expend the funds to provide buoys to properly mark off the race areas for a safe partial Lake closure. Mr. Dawson stated that he wishes to promote water sports and recreational and professional racers alike. Councilwoman Kelley stated that she is concerned about total lake closure and asked if there was any way that the races could be reconfigured to allow for a partial Lake closure. Mr. Swanson stated that with the Circle Races there is only a partial Lake Closure. He stated that the Marathon Race is to be held in April, and during that time of year there is not a lot of Lake activity, but the August date ,could affect the Lake and stated that his organization would be willing to work with the local people to make the event a win/win situation. Mr. Molendyk stated that the boats that will be racing in April and August will be going 90 miles an hour and the PAGE EIGHT - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - DECEMBER 12,1995 has been a great help to their organization. He also stated that the Youth programs have been the winners. He further stated that they are in agreement with Condition No.6, which shows his organization that the city is serious and he feels that it is a good thing. Mr. Swanson stated that moving the venue would hurt the event. He stated that the residents along Lakeshore Drive seem to support the events and he stated that if they were present, then there would be a problem. Councilwoman Brinley asked how long the Marathon event will run. Mr. Swanson stated that on Saturday they are off the water by 2:30 or 3:00 p.m. and on Sunday they are off the water by 1:00 p.m. Councilwoman Brinley asked if the closure needs to be the entire time or can the general public use the Lake before and after the event. Mr. Swanson stated that the Lake would have to be closed until the race was complete and then they could radio the Sheriff's Department and notify them that the Lake was open to the public. He stated that they might be able to change it to a morning venue to be off the water by noon. Councilwoman Brinley asked if it was because of insurance liabilities that they are asking for the City to close the Lake. Mr. Swanson stated that when 35 to 50 boats running at speed ranges of up to 90 miles per hour and the skier is up to 210 feet behind the boat it does constitute a danger. ..... Mayor Pro Tem Kelley questioned the fees the organization pays and asked if it is $1200 with approximately $1000 refundable after all of the expenses are paid. Mr. Swanson confirmed that amount. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley asked if they pay a launch fee per boat. Mr. Swanson stated that when the ramp is operational, then they pay a ramp fee. He explained that generally they go off the beach, and if it is -- available, then they go off the beach, but if the ramp is available, then it would be no problem to use that and pay a day use fee. Councilman Alongi asked how much room a boat needs to make a safe turn going 90 miles an hour. Mr. Swanson explained the boat path for the race and the need for safety. Councilman Alongi asked if there was any way to reconfigure the race to allow for people to be on the Lake. He explained that he has received calls regarding the Lake closure in the past from persons who buy an annual permit. He pointed out that last year there was no opposition to Lake closure and this year there is and he questioned why. He stated that he is concerned with the total Lake closure. Mr. Swanson asked if it was a concern for the April or August closure. Councilman Alongi stated that he had concerns with both. He explained that there are enough problems with the Lake without a Public Relations problem; and asked if there was some way not to close the Lake. Mr. Swanson explained that the Lake gets shallow the more south they go and this would constitute a real danger. Councilman Alongi stated that he does understand, but it is an issue of trying to please the PAGE NINB - CITY COUNCIL MINUTBS - DBCBKBBR 12, 1995 - Councilman Pape referred to the map that shows the circle Race, and asked if the marathon race could use the same configuration. Mr. Swanson explained the difficulties of using the circle tract since the length of the skiers from the boat make the buoys a real hazard in the turns and a triangle is safer for a marathon race. Councilman Metze asked about the speed of the circle boat races. Mr. Swanson stated that a 0-9 boy can go 35 miles an hour and an open race can run at 90 miles per hour. Councilwoman Brinley stated that she agreed with City Manager Molendyk that Council has gone out of their way to attract tourism to the city and she feels that the races are a good event and as long as they are open to giving the different organizations the opportunity to participate, she would not like to see this postponed. She explained that as long as the events are well noticed and advertised she would like to see them proceed. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY PAPE TO APPROVE THB NATIONAL SPEEDBOAT AND WATER SKI ASSOCIATION RBQUEST FOR USE OF LAKE ELSINORE. Councilman Metze stated that he felt that the Council should weigh the benefits that the National Speedboat and Water Ski Association bring to the community. He pointed out that Lake Elsinore appears in the National publications and provides a good promotion for the Lake. - Councilwoman Brinley stated that Mr. Swanson agreed that they did not have a problem with "Day-Use" fees and she would like to-see this added into the conditions. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY PAPB TO AMEND MOTION TO INCLUDE A CONDITION THAT THB PERSONS THAT LAUNCH BOATS FOR THB RACES PAY A DAY-USE LAUNCH FEE. Councilman Alongi stated that he does not feel that it is a matter of a good event or not, but rather the City has citizens who live on the Lake who pay for season passes and Council must address their concerns as well. He explained that he feels that he has a responsibility to the residents and businesses in this community and Council should reconsider if this event is taking something from the residents or not contributing to the local businesses. He stated that he does not want to postpone this item. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley asked how many people were in attendance last year. Mr. Swanson stated that on a race weekend there are in excess of 300 to 325 people on the beach which are the participants an even greater for a marathon race. - Councilman Alongi asked what would happen if Council did postpone for two weeks. Mr. Swanson stated that it would . . . . . .. ~ - ___ ~ - - __ - __ _.. _~ - - ~ __ ..I.... ..! __ __ PAGE TEN - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - DECEMBER 12, 1995 THE FOREGOING MOTION WAS APPROVED BY UKANIMOOS VOTB WITH THB FOLLOWING SCHEDOLB AND CONDITIONS: 1. Total Lake closure for the Marathon Race dates of April 20-21 and Auqust 18, 1996; 2. Partial Lake closure for the Circle Race dates of May 18-19, and September 21-22, 1996; waive the boat speed liaits as defined in the Lake Elsinore Municipal Code Section 9.96.120; 4. Waive the ski two rope length as defined in the Lake Elsinore Municipal Code Section 9.96.090; - 3. 5. Require the applicant to complete all special Event processing requirements to include all fees; 6. Prepare a defined promotional package to advertise per event throughout the entire valley which will include proper notification of all launch facilities and residents encompassing the Lake; and 7. Participants will pay "Day-Ose" fee for launching of each boat that enters the Lake. 14. Elsinore Vallev Artist's Societv Reauest/Waiver of Fees. (F:151.1) city Manager Molendyk stated that this is a request for a waiver of fees for the Elsinore Valley Artist's Society's Art Show at the Cultural Center. He further stated that in the event that Council prefers to waive the fees, it would be appropriate to be reimbursed for staff costs of $300. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley stated that she feels that the Elsinore Valley Artist's Society is made up of people who live in Lake Elsinore and do business here. She noted that Council has just approved closure of the Lake for outside people and she feels that it would be appropriate to waive the facility rental costs. - Mayor Pape clarified that the Society would still pay $300. for Staff Costs; $50. for Cleaning Fee; $500. for Damage Deposit; $115.56 for Insurance; but waive the Facility Rental Cost. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley agreed. MOVED BY KELLEY, SECONDED BY PAPE TO WAIVE THB PEE OP $1,650. FOR FACILITY RENTAL COSTS, BOT CHARGE THE $300 POR STAFP COSTS; $50. FOR CLEANING FEE; $500. FOR DAMAGE DEPOSIT; AND $115.56 FOR INSURANCE. Councilman Alongi asked if someone from the Art Society was present. Hearing no one he asked why they were aSking for the Cultural Center and not the Community Center. Community services Director Sapp explained that this event . "'__..1...- ...&.-.___ _______ PAGE ELBVEB - CITY COUBCIL MINOT.. - DECBKBBR 12, 1"5 Community services Director Sapp stated that the costs were basically the same. Councilman Alongi asked why. Community services Director Sapp explained the fee structure. Councilman Alongi stated that he does agree with Mayor Pro Tem Kelley, but he does feel that the City can afford to donate the $300 for the staff costs. He explained that he does have a problem with charging organizations that service our community and contribute to the community. He pointed out that we seem to find the money to give to someone else, but not for our own. He asked that the motion be amended to include deleting staff costs. Councilwoman Brinley stated that the City does Co-Sponsor in another event and she feels that by allowing the use of the building without charge is aiding them. Councilman Alongi stated that the City has waived all the fees for other organizations in the past and this organization is no different. He pointed out that if we do it for one, we should do it for all. THE FOREGOING KOTION WAS APPROVED WITH A 4 TO 1 VOTE WITH ALONGI CASTING THE DISSENTING VOTE. PUBLIC HEARING 21. Animal Control Ordinance Revisions - Ordinance No. 1003 - continued from November 14. 1995. (F:18.1) City Manager Molendyk explained that there has been a study Session with L.E.A.F. in regard to the issues and the recommendations which are a Revised fee schedule; Mandatory spay/neuter program; cat licensing; and Breeding permit program. ..... Mayor Pape opened the pUblic hearing at 8:25 p.m. The following persons addressed Council: Ann Washington, Director of L.E.A.F., stated that it costs the California tax payers $100,000,000 a year to operate animal control services. She explained that 90% of the animals that bite people, run as strays, and are killed on roadways are unsterilized. She further explained that it costs $200 a day to euthanaize animals which covers all the related expenses. Ms. Washington stated that the reason L.E.A.F. came into being is to provide a pro-active animal control program and the results have been successful, but the number of people turning in their own pets have drastically increased. She read a portion of a resolution from the League of California cities which addresses cat and dog overpopulation and pointed out that there should be an end to pet over population. Frank Thomas, a representative of the Lake Mathews Kennel Club, asked if he might have an opportunity to review the City ordinance and h~ve an oppo~tu~ity to address Council PAGE TWELVE - CITY COUNCIL KINUTES - DECEMBER 12, 1995 Mariana Mohylyn, 305 W. Sumner, spoke in opposition to mandatory spay/neutering. She stated that it is the right of the animals to not be altered. She stated that money should be spent on the shelter to provide better housing. Gene Richeland, Lake Mathews Kennel Club, stated that there was no public announcement in the paper that this issue was to be heard. She explained that she had requested information regarding this Ordinance and felt that she did not get adequate response. She asked that Council table this issue and readvertise the hearing. L.E.A.F. presented a video. ..... Leslie Rice, L.E.U.S.D. instructional Aid, spoke in support of mandatory spay/neuter program program. Mayor Pape asked if anyone wished to speak further on the item. Hearing no one the public hearing was closed at 9:00 p.m. Councilwoman Kelley stated that she read through the packet and the proposed ordinance and explained that she spent a day at L.E.A.F. and is in support of the mandatory spay/neuter. Councilman Alongi stated that it is a difficult decision to make when a life is taken, either man or animal. He explained that there are many accidents on the highways caused from drinking, but we do not demand that the liquor stores be closed down, because adults must take responsibility for their own actions. Councilman Alongi stated that he has great respect for the people at L.E.A.F. and the tough job that they do, but he feels that this -- ordinance is stepping on peoples' rights. He stated that it is the responsibility of the pet owner to make the decision. He stated that if a pet owner does not want to alter their dogs, and they should run loose, then there should be a stiff fine. He explained that he does not believe in forcing decisions on someone else. Councilman Alongi stated that if Council wishes to pass this ordinance, then he would vote in favor, but he did want to express his opinion. Councilwoman Brinley stated that she respects the people of L.E.A.F. and stated that they have a tough job. She questioned how many of the 488 cats in L.E.A.F.'s facility in the last six months, as cited in the report, had to be euthanized. Ms. Washington stated that the 488 cats constituted 62 litters from the City of Lake Elsinore. She stated that most were euthanized. Councilwoman Brinley asked about the 6 month re-education program. Ms. Washington gave an overview of the program and explained that the ordinance will be enforced when the public bring their animals in; when complaints from the public are received; and when animals are picked up. She further explained that a fair number of people will follow the law PAGE THIRTBBH - CITY COUNCIL KIBUTBS - DBCBKBBR 12, 1995 - Councilman Alongi stated that this is where discrimination enters into this situation. He stated that he feels that it is the responsibility of the owner. He stated that there are a lot of owners who do not believe in spaying or neutering their animals and he feels that it is their right to choose. Councilman Alongi pointed out that we also have the right to enforce the law and if they do not respond to the requirements, then they should pay a heavy fine or fee for not having the animal altered. Ms. Washington explained that it is a misdemeanor for a female in season to be at large because of the problems that it creates. Councilman Alongi stated that it is a difficult issue, but it is the responsibility of the pet owner to properly secure his animal and if the dog gets loose then the owner should assume responsibility. He explained that if a person has a female dog and it comes in season, then it is that owner's responsibility to make sure that no dogs come near it. Ms. washington stated that the $100,000,000 annually that the state of California spends, is caused by 90% of the animals which are unaltered and that is where our tax dollars are going. Councilman Alongi stated that he agrees with a higher fee if the animal is not altered, but he has a problem with the mandatory spay or neuter. He feels that it is the owner's decision. - Councilman Metze stated that when he had heard this item the first time that it was presented to Council he was in agreement with Councilman Alongi, but after a visit with Ms. Washington, he changed his mind in regard to mandatory neutering. He explained that mandatory is misleading, since a person can choose to not alter his or her pet, but a higher fee will be charged. He further stated that irresponsible people are affecting responsible people. Councilman Metze stated that irresponsible people place a tax burden on the public due to the cost of animal control and if there is a need for an aggressive stand, then he feels that Council should take that stand. He explained that he would like a six month lead-in and verbiage in the ordinance to define the ordinance. He noted that there is no mention regarding cats and he would like to have the exact verbiage by second reading. Councilwoman Brinley stated that there is a professional staff which has presented the fact that there is a population problem and has presented a solution. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY METZE TO APPROVE ORDINANCE NO. 1003 UPON FIRST READING BY TITLE ONLY WHICH WILL INCLUDE: A. REVISED FEE SCHEDULE; B. MANDATORY SPAY/NEUTER PROGRAM; C. CAT LICENSING; D. BREEDING PERMIT PROGRAM; TO INCLUDE A SIX MONTH LEAD-IN PROGRAM FOR THE PUBLIC; AND A REVIEW TO BE DONE BY COUNCIL IN EIGHTEEN MONTHS. City Attorney Harper pointed out that there is no amendment - - .. ~ - - - ~ .... .. PAGE FOURTEEN- CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - DECBHBER 12, 1995 then the owner must have both licenses. He pointed out that he does not have a problem with cat licensing, but that he is uncomfortable with the verbiage regarding mandatory spay/neutering. He explained that he does not feel that the city wishes to give the pUblic the impression that they will alter their pet "or else", but rather it will be less expensive to have their animals altered rather than to pay the higher fee year after year. Mayor Pape pointed out that there are programs, through L.E.A.F., for persons who cannot afford the necessary operations to insure that they can alter their pets. Councilman Alongi stated that he agrees with Councilman Metze that if there is not going to be a mandatory spay/neuter program, then he felt that this should be removed from the verbiage of the Ordinance, since a higher fee will be in place for unaltered animals. - THE FOREGOING MOTION FAILED UPON THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE: ORDINANCE NO. 1003 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE, CALIFORNIA, REPEALING CHAPTER 6.04 "ANIMAL AND ANIMAL CONTROL OFFICERS" OF THE LAKE ELSINORE MUNICIPAL CODE AND ADDING SECTIONS 6.04.000 THROUGH 6.04.2700 AYES: COUNCILKEKBERS: BRINLEY, KELLEY NOES: COUNCILKBHBERS: ALONG, METZE, PAPE ABSENT: COUNCILKEKBERS: NONE ABSTAIN: COUNCILKBHBERS: NONE - MOVED BY ALONGI, SECONDED BY METZE TO APPROVE ORDINANCE NO. 1003 UPON FIRST READING BY TITLE ONLY WHICH WILL INCLUDE: A. REVISED FEE SCHEDULE; B. SPAY/NEUTER PROGRAM; C. CAT LICENSING; D. BREEDING PERMIT PROGRAM; TO INCLUDE A SIX MONTH LEAD-IN PROGRAM FOR THE PUBLIC; AND A REVIEW TO BE DONE BY COUNCIL IN EIGHTEEN MONTHS, DELETING THE WORD MANDATORY WITHIN THB TITLE AND BODY OF THE ORDINANCE REGARDING SPAY/NEUTERING OF ANIMALS AND A HIGHER FEE TO BE CHARGED FOR UNALTERED ANIMALS. UPON THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES: COUNCILKEKBERS: ALONGI, BRINLEY, KELLEY, METZB, PAPE NOES: COUNCILKEKBERS: NONE ABSENT: COUNCILKEKBERS: NONE ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEKBERS: NONE BUSINESS ITEMS 31. Consideration o~ a Request to Initi~te a General Plan PAGE PIPTBBB - CITY COUNCIL KIBUTBS - DBCBKBBR 12, 1995 has been a good and cooperative neighbor and has cooperated with the City by maintaining his property and by placing storm drains and asks that Council consider this amendment so that he might market and develop his property properly. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley stated that in researching this project she noted that several years ago this issue came before the homeowners and they were unhappy, and asked if this issue had been brought before the homeowners this time. community Development Director Leslie stated that the request is for the City to initiate a General Plan Amendment and Zone Change and if Council chooses to initiate this request there would be full public hearings with full noticing and as part of that process there could also be a notification to the homeowners including study sessions and meetings with staff. He explained that the issue is not whether the Council is making the amendment or zone change, but whether the Council wishes to initiate this process and begin discussion. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley stated that in her campaign she affirmed that she would be going toward more single family residences and readdress of the General Plan. She stated that this proposal is for a medium high density which she is opposed to at this time. - Councilwoman Brinley concurred with Mayor Pro Tem Kelley and stated that when she sat on Planning Commission this issue was heard and there was concern stated by the homeowners and direction was given to the property owner to meet with the homeowners. She stated that this project is located in a sensitive residential area and the concerns at that time were the type and height of the roof-tops, the density and traffic circulation. She further explained that she has opposition to this as well. Councilwoman Brinley stated that if the property owner wishes to bring this request forward, then the property owner should fund the change and not the City. Councilman Alongi asked how many General Plan Amendments will this make if this goes through. Community Development Director Leslie stated that there are four cycles for General Plan Amendments, and this would not be heard until next year in the first of the Amendment requests. Councilman Alongi stated that he would like to hear from the property owner representative regarding why they wish to change the zoning. Charles Legeman, 3454 E. Anaheim st., Long Beach, representative of the owner, stated that the problem they have experienced in looking for a joint venture partner is that in this economic time no one is willing to put up the money to do plans and studies since there is no specific zoning to give direction for development. He addressed Councilwoman Brinley'S remark regarding the funding, and why _~..L__ _A___ .L!!-_____"I ...a....'--~_ __..I......!__ ,e.!oL.., h..!l<, ,;,~ ~(': \~. PAGE SIXTEEN - CITY COUNCIL MINUTBS - DBCBKBBR. 12, 1995 C-2 and R-3 zoning. He stated that he does not think that the applicant would want Council to hear this request, since he will not be given what he is requesting. Community Development Director Leslie stated that initiation of the General Plan and Zone Change Amendment at this time is not a commitment on the part of the city to make any change, it is only to consider the possibility. Councilman Metze commented that when the residents came out to hear this issue the City would be the applicant, and he feels that the owner of the property should address the residents in regard to what he wants to do with the project. Councilman Alongi asked if the city is bringing this issue forward or the property owner. community Development Director Leslie stated that the property owner has requested that the City consider initiating this amendment, and if the city does then the City is bringing this forward. Councilman Alongi stated that if the City does not, then the applicant can bring it forward. Community Development Director Leslie confirmed. MOVED BY MBTZB, SBCONDED BY ALONGI AND CARRIBD BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO DENY THB RBQUEST TO INITIATB A GENERAL PLAN AMBNDMBNT CHANGING THE LAND USE DBSIGNATION AND CHANGING THB ZONING OF A PROPBRTY LOCATED AT THB INTBRSECTION OF GRAND AVBNUB AND HIGHWAY 74 FROM FUTURE SPECIFIC PLAN AREA "u" TO GENERAL COMMBRCIAL AND MBDIUM HIGH DENSITY LAND USE DESIGNATION AND FROM NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL (C-l) AND COMMERCIAL PARK (C-P) ZONING TO GBNERAL COMMERCIAL (C-2) AND MEDIUM DENSITY RBSIDENTIAL ZONING. 32. Award of Bid for Weed Abatement Proqram. (F:166.1) City Manager Molendyk explained that this item was continued for clarification of the bids. - Building and Safety Manager Russell explained the Weed Abatement Program, and stated that for the last four years there has been a contract with a specific contractor and that contract is now at an end, and has gone out for competitive bid. He noted that six contractors bid on the project, three were accepted and are included in the staff report. Councilman Alongi asked if this contract had to go to bid. Building and Safety Manager Russell stated that by law it did not. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley stated that there is only $22 difference between the bids, and Council does not need to take the lowest bid. She asked if the performance has been satisfactory. Building and Safety Manager Russell stated that it has. She stated that she cannot understand why the city would switch experience for $22. Councilwoman Brinley asked if Mr. Smith owns his own equipment. Building and Safety Manager Russell stated that _____~.._________ ___J1__..___ __,_~_. ~~ __~~...L....___ ______ '-.!_ PAGE SBVBRTBBH - CITY COUBCIL KIBUTES - DBCBKBBR 12, 1"5 would take steps to insure that the level of service is consistent with the specifications of the contract. Councilman Metze asked if we know anything about the other businesses. Building and Safety Manager Russell stated that the contractors must provide references. - Mayor Pro Tem Kelley asked if Mr. Bentley's references were in weed abatement or nuisance abatement from other cities. Building and Safety Manager Russell stated that his references were in both. Councilman Metze asked if the City has been satisfied with Mr. smith. Building and Safety Manager Russell stated that we have. - Mayor Pape asked if disking and mowing is the most used category of the contract. Building and Safety Manager Russell stated that it is. Mayor Pape pointed out the difference in the costs per each contractor and the fact that Bentley's was the highest in this category. Building and safety Manager explained the difference in the calculations in the bid process and how staff averaged this. Mayor Pape pointed out that there is only $6 difference between Boyco and smith in cost and asked if this is that much different. Building and Safety Manager Russell made note of the difference between the different categories and how that would affect the cost per percentage. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley stated that for the difference of $22 she felt that it would be better to stay with the contractor with experience that the City knows. MOVED BY KELLEY, SECONDED BY BRINLEY TO AWARD THE CONTRACT TO SMITH'S TRACTOR SERVICES. Councilman Alongi stated that he feels that this is fair, since Mr. smith has proven himself to be a reliable person to deal with the city and has added to his equipment to provide service to the City. He further stated that he feels that the City should set up their own costs and hire anyone of the three to do the job in the future. Mayor Pape stated that it is the contractor's responsibility to fulfill the contract and perform the work in a timely fashion and he would like to see the costs kept to a minimum; and it is up to staff to insure that the contractor performs in that manner. THE FOREGOING MOTION WAS APPROVED BY A 4 TO 1 VOTE WITH PAPE CASTING THE DISSENTING VOTE. 33. Reauest for Addition to Aaenda Format - Requested bv Mayor Pro Tem Kelley. (F:120.1) (X:44.1) - 5\ PAGE EIGHTEEN - CITY COUNCIL KlHUTES - DBCBllBBR 12, 1995 Councilwoman Brinley concurred with Mayor Pro Tem Kelley and stated that she had been contacted by some pastors in the community and explained that the pastors felt that it would be a nice way to start the Council Meetings. He stated that she would like to see that the City Clerk is in charge of the rotation and keeps a calendar on a yearly basis. She stated that the City Attorney could give us direction in regard to public notice. Councilwoman Brinley stated that she feels that this is moving in a positive direction and pointed out that although people have a problem with Church and state, our currency states "In God We Trust". - City Attorney Harper stated that a year and one-half ago, the Supreme Court decided that a prayer prior to a City council Meeting was Constitutionally permitted. He pointed out that in cities that do this, the set-up for rotation is generally a staff function. He stated that he felt that the City Manager's Office or the City Clerk's Office would be delighted to perform this function. Mayor Pape stated that he felt that the city Clerk should perform this duty and that he has also been thinking about this issue and feels that it is a good idea. He further stated that there should be plenty of volunteers, so that there should be no problem with scheduling. Mayor Pape called upon Lila Cardoza to speak. Lila Cardoza, 300 Ellis, spoke in opposition to the request for an Invocation at Council Meetings. She pointed out that this is against the Constitution of the united States; and noted that the building in which the Council Meetings are held is paid for by the tax payer and is no longer a place of worship and should be protected by the 1st Amendment of -- the Constitution, which requires a separation of Church and State. She explained that she has a right to attend Council Meetings which are free of religious sYmbols and prayers, and if prayers are allowed at Council Meetings then she would be a captive audience and the Council would be infringing upon her Constitutional Rights. She stated that she is but one, but as one she can do something to protect her rights. She asked that Council uphold and respect her Constitutional Rights. She asked what was more important, to adhere to the Constitution as drafted by the founders of this nation, or by an inexperienced City Councilmember which has chosen to place the Constitution on a back burner. Councilman Metze stated that he also has a problem with this issue and does believe in the separation of Church and State. He asked if Council would want to get deciding into what is a religion and what is not. He suggested that this would put staff in the position of deciding what is O.K. and what is not for who does and does not give the Invocation. He stated that there are various radical religions and sects and that this should be taken into account. Councilman Metze stated that he has a real problem with putting the PAGE NXNETEBH - CXTY COUNCXL KXNUTES - DBCBKBBR 12, 1"5 last 1 to 1 1/2 minutes and this would not be enough time to stand on a soap box. She explained that she feels that this is a positive approach. Councilman Metze stated that each of Council brings some of their faith with them and it would not surprise him if every member of Council says a prayer before entering the building; however this could be putting the city into a situation where they would have to vote to say that it is O.K. for someone to do the Invocation. He questioned who he is to decide what is a religion and what is not. - Councilman Alongi commented "Render Unto Caesar what is Caesar's and Render Unto God what is God's". He stated that Council could not allow prayer and then take a discriminatory action to say what is religion. He explained that he feels that this is no place for this type of action. He pointed out that he is a strong believer of the separation of Church and State and feels that he will not take it lightly when he faces his God, and he does not think that he will take it lightly when he faces hearing a prayer while he is sitting on Council. Councilman Alongi explained that there are two lives in this country: one is the Christian Life; and the other is Government Life. He pointed out that one has nothing to do with the other and that is why the constitution is in place and guarantees those rights for all. He noted that he has a strong religious belief and that God does supply all of his needs all of the time, he does not wish to impose that belief on anyone else. He explained that many religions do not believe in Jesus and what should be done with those who do not believe in him. He pointed out that this does infringe on the rights of others. He further explained that for that reason he does not wish to see Invocations in this building. Councilman Alongi pointed out that he does not like to meet in this building, since it was previously a House of God and feels that Council is meeting in violation of God's Law when Council uses this building. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley asked that the City Attorney repeat what he had said previously. City Attorney Harper stated approximately 1 1/2 years ago the united States Supreme Court decided that non- denominational or denominational prayer prior to a Council Meeting is Constitutional. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY KELLEY TO APPROVE THE ADDITION ON AN INVOCATION TO THE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA PORHAT; AUTHORIZE THE COORDXNATION OF THB ROTATION TO BB HANDLED BY THB CXTY CLBRK'S OFPICE WITH A YEARLY CALENDAR TO BB KEPT; AND THB CITY COUNCIL TO REVIEW THIS ISSUE IN ONE YEAR WITH ROLL CALL VOTE AS POLLOWS: AYES: COUNCILKEKBBRS: BRINLEY, KELLEY, PAPE NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS: ALONG, METZE PAGE TWENTY - CITY COUNCIL MINUTBS - DBCBKBBR 12, 1995 34. citv Council Committee Assianments. (F:44.1) Mayor Pape stated that he wished to propose appointments to facilitate the upcoming meetings of the different agencies. The recommendations were as follows: Lake Elsinore Management Authority - Representative - Pape, Alternate Metze. R.T.A. - Representative - Brinley, Alternate - Metze. Riverside County Habitat Conservation Agency - Representative - Alongi, Alternate - Metze. Riverside Transit Authority - Representative - Brinley, Alternate - Metze. Western Riverside Council of Governments - Representative - Kelley, Alternate - Brinley. city Clerk Kasad stated that she has the packets for these meetings available after tonights meeting. 35. Planning Commission Resianation. (F:60.2) Mayor Pape stated that he had received a Letter of Resignation from Mr. Metze regarding his position on the Planning Commission. He asked the following persons who submitted requests to speak: Lila Cardoza, 300 Ellis street, stated that she would like to nominate Edith Stafford, who has been a long time member of the community and is very knowledgeable. She commented that it would be nice to have someone on the Commission who does not belong to the dominate group for a change. Chris Hyland, 15191 Wavecrest Drive, stated that she had not seen anything in the paper regarding the resignation and stated that it is the first time that she has seen an appointment come before a resignation. She explained that Edith Stafford is a tax payer as well as a knowledgeable person in the community and would represent the minorities and recommended that she be considered for the post of Planning Commissioner. .... Mayor Pape stated that traditionally the post of Planning Commissioner is appointed by the Mayor and ratified by the Council. MOVED BY PAPE, SECONDBD BY BRINLEY TO ACCBPT THB RBSIGNATION OF COMMISSIONER METZB AND APPOINT BOB SCHIFFNBR AS A NEW PLANNING COMMISSIONER. Councilman Alongi asked when Mr. Metze term expires. Councilman Metze stated that it expires on June 30, 1998. ~~y~ ~~~~ft~y~~ ~~~7~~ ~.ft .~~ft~~8~ ft~ ~y.~Y~~~n ~~m_ PAGE TWENTY ORB - CITY COUNCIL KIMUTBS - DBCBKBBR 12, 1995 Marji Hunnewell, 320 Avenue 9, spoke in opposition to the apartment complex on the corner of Franklin and Casino and stated that their packets have been submitted to Council stating their opposition to this low income project since it is not in the right percentages. She pointed out the safety hazards regarding the lack of street lighting and sidewalks. She stated that she felt that this complex would increase the crime rate and diminish the current property value. city Attorney Harper reminded the Council that the Brown Act provides that Council is obligated to hear public comments on items which are in the jurisdiction of the Council, however the Brown Act does exclude items on which there is going to be or has been a public hearing. He explained that although he is sure that Council appreciates what Ms. Hunnewell has to say, it taints the public hearing if there is one in the future and gives the applicant grounds to attempt to set it aside. He stated that he strongly discouraged council from making any comments on the subject except in the public hearing format where the Council can receive comment legally. - Mayor Pape stated that the remaining three requests are on the same subject, therefore he felt it best to follow the city Attorney's advise and confine all comments to the public hearing format. He pointed out that there will be an opportunity for the public to address the issue in January at Planning Commission level and probably in February with the city Council. City Attorney Harper explained that the law requires that input on something which is legally required to be a public hearing, occur in the public hearing, not prior to or outside the public hearing. He further explained that comments received or outside of the public hearing give the potential for an applicant to file a law suit to set aside the city Council's decision because they prejudged the issue. CITY MAHAGER COMMENTS City Manager Molendyk presented a picture from L.E.A.F. to City Council, of a child with a dog and stated that it is presented in appreciation of Council's support of L.E.A.F. CITY COUNCIL COMMENTS Mayor Pro Tem Kelley commented on the following: 1. Congratulated the Titans on their victory at the Diamond Stadium. 2. Addressed the concerns of the Soccer people regarding lighting fees. She explained that staff is looking into the fee schedule so that it does not conflict with the Lighting and Landscaping Fees. PAGE TWENTY TWO - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - DECEMBER 12, 1995 2. Thanked Mr. Pete Dawson for hosting his boat for the Parade of Lights. they acted as judges for the Parade enjoyed it very much. Councilmembers on She explained that of Lights and 3. Thanked staff for the Christmas Tree Lighting Ceremony on Main Street, and stated that it was a positive experience. 4. Congratulated the team from Temescal High and commended them for a job well done. ..... 5. Thanked and honored the four team members who visited Tim Pape at the hospital and commended their parents for a job well done. 6. Wished everyone a Merry Christmas and Happy New Year. She thanked staff for the help and support. councilman Alongi commented on the following: 1. Stated that when his father came to this country that he did not experience the problem with people thinking that just because there was Mafia in this country that they did not want any more Italians. He pointed out that this is what we are doing to different people with different incomes. He stated that it is a sad state of affairs. He pointed out that people want to remove the blight in this community, but they don't want to do anything about it by providing the opportunity for a different type of housing to allow the people to move from those dwellings and force the landlords to do something about them. Stated that he has received an envelope and has read everyone of them and stated that ignorance is the mother of bigotry and not just of race or religion. This goes far beyond that. ..... 2. Apologized for being late and explained that he had a previous commitment and witnessed 400 children receive toy and goodies for the holidays that they would not normally have. 3. Wished everyone Happy Holidays. 4. Congratulated Mr. Schiffner for his appointment to Planning Commission. councilman Ketze commented on the following: 1. Congratulated Mr. Schiffner for his appointment to Planning commission and stated that he knows that he will do a good job for the community. 2. Congratulated the Titans Football Team for their CIF win. ~ ~~_~_~ ~~_~ ~_ Y.'__ ~_______~ ~7~~~ ~h_ ~~~ ~~~~~~ PAGE TWENTY THREE - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - DECEMBER 12, 1995 6. Explained that he had forgotten to thank his three strongest supporters at the December 5, Meeting. He thanked his daughter Mary; his daughter Blair and his son Mikey. Mayor Papa commented on the following: 1. Expressed pride in the accomplishments of the Titans and congratulated the Coach and stated that we expect the same next year. 2. Noted that he has received the letters from the residents of the Ayers Tract and stated that Council will read the entire packet, but this issue will be heard at Public Hearing so there will be no comment at this time. 3. Expressed his appreciation for staff and Council. CLOSED SESSION a. Lake Elsinore Associates vs. city of Lake Elsinore/ Redevelopment Agency. THE REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING WAS ADJOURNED TO A JOINT CLOSED SESSION WITH THE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY TO DISCUSS THE ABOVE MENTIONED LITIGATION AT 10:25 P.M. THE REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING WAS RECONVENED AT 10:44 P.M. NO ACTION WAS TAKEN. - ADJOURNMENT MOVED BY PAPE, SECONDED BY KELLEY AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO ADJOURN THE REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING AT 10:44 P.M. , /) ;r:~",~c~ I '~~~a&~y CLERK ~I~Y OF ~J: ~LSINORE ;;' '- .l- _...._