Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout09-10-1996 City Council MinutesNIINUTES REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE 183 NORTH MAIN STREET LAKE ELSINORE, CALIFO1iNIA TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 10,1996 a:c*axzxaaaxxwx~*axn*~rza*~a*~*a~cfe*~cfc*xxxax~xxxxx~xx*xxx*awx**xxx*xx*rwxxxwx*nxx, CALL TO ORDER The Regular City Council Meeting was called to order by Mayor Pape at 7:02 p.m. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE The Pledge of Allegiance was led by City Manager Molendyk. INVOCATION The Invocation was provided by Pastor Joe Rivera, representing Pressing On Faith Ministries. ROLL CALL PRESENT: COUNCILMEMBER5: ALONGI, BRINLEY, KELLEY, METZE, PAPE ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBER5: NONE Also present were: City Manager Molendyk, Assistant City Manager Watenpaugh, City Attorney _ Harper, Administrative Services Director Boone, Community Development Director Leslie, Community Services Director Sapp, Manager of Special Projects Best, City Engineer ODonnell and City Clerk Kasad. A. ~resentation - Art in Public Transit Pro,gram - R.T.A. (F:140.12) Councilwoman Brinley introduced R.T.A. General Manager Susan Hafner, and noted that September is Lake Elsinore Month, with a Lake Elsinore bus pass designed for the City. Ms. Hafner presented the City with a framed version of the bus pass and explained the Art in Public Transit Program. She detailed the routes serving the City of Lake Elsinore, and innovations being reviewed to be used in the future. She also noted that discussions are underway with the School District to provide services fro the secondary school students. Ms. Hafner expressed appreciation to the Council for their support and to Councilmember Brinley and Metze for their participation on the R.T.A. Board. Mrs. Brinley thanked Ms. Hafner and introduced the Transportation Now Coalition members present in the audience and thanked them for their participation. Ms. Hafner noted the benefits of the input by the Transportation Now Coalition, and presented copies of the September Bus Passes to the City Council. B. Proclamation - National Pollution Prevention Week. (F:122.1) Mayor Pape read and presented the National Pollution Prevention Week proclamaton to Ben Irwin of Oricom. Mr. Irwin presented the Council with gifts from ORICOM, being a bottle of refined waste oil which has been refined into "America's Choice" oil. PAGE TWO - CITY COUNCIL NIINUTES - SEPTEMBER 10, 1996 C. Presentation - CAP Committee Re~ort. (F:142.1) Mayor Pro Tem Kelley introduced Steve Wallace for this presentation. Mr. Wallace commented on his participation in the Community Action Planning Conference. He detailed the conference attendees, the sponsorship of the conference, and the purpose of the conference to improve the image of the community. He detailed the FIT program Fix it Together which is fashioned after a similar program in Anaheim. He explained that the objective is to give facelifts to houses in Lake Elsinore, owned by senior citizens unable to make the improvements. He explained that the program is intended to improve the image and develop understanding. He detailed the requirements for participation in the program, and presented a brief video on the Anaheim program. He detailed the need for volunteers. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley noted the similarity to the Paint Your Heart Out Program in Anaheim. Mr. Wallace indicated that interested parties can contact him at 244-3252 for information and applications. Setting up the application and liability processes. Mrs. Kelley clarified that the intent for the first year is to work on 1 to 3 houses. D. Presentation - Su~port the Lake Committee Project. (F:92.1)(X:108.4) Bob Schiffner, explained the fund raising campaign he has undertaken on behalf of the Chamber of Commerce, for the sunset lake cruises. Ae presented a packet of information and detailed the Sunset Cruise which are intended to turn around the negative attitude about the Lake, and improve its nnage. He detailed the cost of this area which is being borne by Pro Marine and area marinas. He noted that the waiting list for the cruises is now ten weeks. He advised that more information can be obtained by calling 678-4028. He commented that there are businesses that will benefit from the improved image of the lake and the City. Mr. Schiffner introduced Pete Dawson ofPro Marine. Mr. Dawson stressed the contributions of the marinas who are assisting in making the cruises a success. E. Presentation - AQMD Projects. (F:36.2) Larry Rhinehart, SCAQMD, indicated that he was present as part of the local government outreach program. He commended the Council on their recognition of Pollution Prevention Week. He noted the launch of a regulatory reform initiative to reduce staff, and an on-line computer pernutting program. He indicated that the District's most significant current activity is updating the 1994 Air Quality Management Plan. He detailed the review process underway and the dates of the upcoming public hearings. He commented on the availability of his office to assist with the requirements of AB2766, and noted the potential for financial benefit of this program for the City. PUBLIC COMMENTS - AGENDIZED I7'EMS Requests were received to address the following items and deferred to those discussions: Item Nos. 5 and 7. CONSENT CALENDAR The following items were pulled from the Consent Calendar for further discussion and consideration: ItemNos. 4, 5, 6 and 7. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY METZE AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO APPROVE THE BALANCE OF THE CONSENT CALENDAR AS PRESENTED. PAGE THREE - CITY COUNCIL 1VIIl~TUTES - SEPTEMBER 10,1996 The following Minutes were approved: a. Regular City Council Meeting - August 27, 1996. (F:44.4) 2. Ratified Warrant List for August 29, 1996. (F:12.3) Received and ordered filed the Investment Report for July 31, 1996. (F:12.5) BU5INESS ITEMS 31. Withdrawal from the Lake Elsinore Management Authority - Resolution No. 96-52. (F:92.3) City Manager Molendyk provided a brief history of the City's participation in the Authority; and explained the plan to withdraw from the Authority. He noted that this would include both the City and RDA representation on the Authority. Mayor Pape noted that he is the City representative, explained that the Authority is now down to three agencies and it is only logical that with the completion of the initial goals, it should be dissolved for now. He furhter noted that it is possible to form another organization later, but suggessted that it is best to conserve funds at this time. Councilwoman Brinley concurred with Mayor Pape and noted the potential for a newer more current program in the future. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY METZE TO ADOPT RESOLUTION NO. 96- 52: Councilman Alongi questioned the pending lawsuits and whether they would continue. City Attorney Harper indicated that it would now be a moot point. THE FOREGOING MOTION CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE. RESOLUTION NO. 96-52 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE, AUTHORIZING TH~ WITHDRAWAL OF ITS MEMBERSHIP IN THE LAKE ELSINORE MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY AND THE DISSOLUTION THEREOF. 32. Four Corners Storm Drain at Lakeshore Drive and Riverside Drive.(F:155.1) City Manager Molendyk provided an overview of the original Four Corners Storm Drain project and the related delays. He detailed the recent discussions and the proposed agreement for the City to participate in the amount of $7,800 and noted that it is a fair and equitable arrangement. He noted that the City funds would come from Gas Taxes. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY ALONGI AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO APPROVE THE PROPOSED AGREEMENT. Councilman Alongi noted that this was a very good job of negotiation by staff. 33. Visions & Views/T.V. Program.(F:102.1) City Manager Molendyk explained that this item came out of a Study Session as a means to provide more information to the general public. He recommended approval of the Community TV program which would give an overview of the Community far the residents, and noted the potential for more in-depth information to be provided. He PAGE FOUR - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - SEPTEMBER 10,1996 suggested that this would be a way to provide a more positive outlook and image for the residents, and serve as a vehicle for acknowledging accomplishments in the Community. Councilwoman Brinley explained that she and Mayor Pro Tem Kelley met with Cheryl Smith from Continental Cablevision to develop the format for the program. She noted that the proposed logo and program title were developed by Kazen Snyder. She further noted that the TV moderator and host will be Tom Thomas, who was chosen for his well rounded working knowledge of the Commuinty. She advised that the program is being provided at no cost to the Community, but by Mr. Thomas and Continental Cable are providing the program. She detailed the programs being planned for the first few months; including a preview of the open air market, a tour of City Aall and introduction of the City staff, a series on the boat launch constructioq and a program regarding the possible tri- city trolley car under discussion. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley introduced Tom Thomas and Cheryl Smith and commended their efforts and thanked them for their assistance. She explained that the program is being designed to highlight and update the community on on-going projects, and suggested that anyone with ideas can contact she or Councilwoman Brinley. She looked forwazd to first airing on October 7th. Councilwoman Brinley added that they will be going in to homes and holding discussions with home owners regarding the City, and stressed that the program is intended to be done on a positive note. She thanked Mr. Thomas, Mrs. Snyder and Ms. Smith for their contributions. Councilman Alongi expressed respect for Iv1r. Thomas, but suggested that because of his political involvement in the Community, he would like to see someone non-political, and suggested Allen Baldwin as an alternate. Ae noted that the City is entering a difficult financial period and quesitoned the amount oftime that staffwill be asked to spend on this project. He expresssed support of the program, but questioned the time commitment. He suggested that if staffis being asked to do things for the program, it should be live with the calls not being censored. He stressed that all residents should have a right to call in. He expressed hope that this program would have no conflict with his which will be starting in November. He requested that the Council consider this item further and not approve it yet. Councilwoman Brinley commented on Mr. Thomas and noted his expertise in Cable Television, and stressed that it is difficult to find someone in the community who is non- political. She indicated that the City is fortunate to have Mr. Thomas's participation. She indicated that some of the shows will be live shows with call ins by residents and panel members to respond. She indicated tha the only staff time will be for a once a month meeting in which Mr. Sapp would be participating, with the exception of the tour of City Hall, during which staffwould be interviewed. Mrs. Kelley noted that the taped shows will be so that events can be covered live for later broadcast. Ms. Smith indicated that this would be primarily an in field production with little input from staff, and stressed that there is no cost to the City. She stressed that the purpose of doing the show in the Commuinty is to address what is happening in the Community and what it has to offer. She noted the difficulty of doing so within the confines of the studio. Councilman Alongi noted out of the four times the Open Air Market he understands, the tour of City Hall o.k., but questioned the location for the Trolley & the intent in showing the Boat Launch Facility. Councilwoman Brinley explained the trolley concept which would include a ride on the trolley and interviews of those involved in the trolley. Councilman Alongi questioned where the information will come from for the program, and stressed that he does not want to overload the staffwith the program. Councilwoman Brinley explained that it would be information provided by herself and RTA representatives. Ms. Smith indicated that the production staff and Mr. Thomas will be PAGE FIVE - CITY COUNCIL MIlVUTES - SEPTEMBER 10,1996. coordinating the information and go into the community to find the information. She stressed the work to be done, would be done by the production staff. Councilman Alongi noted the potential for a need to meet with staffto get the information. Ms. 5mith reiterated that there would be a meeting once a month. Councilman Alongi stressed the need for staff input on the topics. Ms. Smith noted the that this would be assisted by the participation of the Councilmembers. Mayor Pape questioned the potential problem of producers approaching staff before air time. City Manager Molendyk indicated that it was his understanding that Continental would be an extension of City Staff. He indicated that with only periodic shows, there would be a minimal amount of time commitment by staff. He suggested that if that coxnmitment become overburdening, he would share that information with the committee. Councilman Alongi questioned page 4 of 4, and the discussion of the format. He noted a statement with regard to "taping for control purposes and the potential for editing the phone calls which are received". Councilwoman Brinley stressed the, format as proposed, and noted the potential for calls at some of the later programs. Mayor Pape noted that this was intended to be a positive effort to keep the public informed, and different formats may occur. MOVED BY PAPE, SECONDED BY BRINLEY AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO APPROVE THE FORMAT AND PROGRAMMING A5 PRESENTED. ITEMS PULLED FROM CONSENT CALENDAR 4. Claims Against the City submitted by Robert Smith~Kathleen Smith & 7uanita Collins (CL #96-15a-cl. Billie B. Hobart {;CL #96-17~ Frank Vasquez (CL #96-181 Joseph N. Grasso (CL #96-191. (F:52.2) Councilman Alongi indicated that he pulled this item because he would like the Council to remove this and add the 7oseph N. Grasso Claim to the Closed Session discussion. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY METZE AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO DEFER THE GRASSO CLAIM TO CLOSED SESSION FOR DISCUS5ION. MOVED BY ALONGI, SECONDED BY BRIlVLEY AND CARRIED BY UANIMOUS VOTE TO REJECT AND REFER TO THE CLAIMS ADMINISTRATOR FOR HANDLING, THE CLAIMS SUBNIITTED BY ROBERT SNIITH, KATHLEEN SNIITH, JUAIVITA COLLINS, BILLIE B. HOBART AND FRANK VASQUEZ. Adoption of a Resolution Ugdating the Disadvantaged Business Enterprise Program BE . (F:84.3) City Manager Molendyk explained this item and the prior consideration. Mariana Mohylyn, 305 W. Sumner, questioned the funding of this program and the intent of the program. She questioned the minority groups involved, noted special considerations given to certain groups and suggested equal treatment for all. She stressed the need for consideration to be given to women. Chris Hyland, 15191 Wavecrest, noted a recent article in the newspaper and indicated that it was disgusting that the Mayor indicated that he would vote against the program. She noted businesses owned by women, which are not used by the City. She noted that there are parties available to do landscaping int he City, who employ minorities. She noted that the Chamber of Commerce even has their printing done in Mumeta, when there are several printers in the community. She indicated that she could care less about the Mayor's Republican stance on Affirmative Action. She indicated that she hoped that the PAGE SIX - CITY COUNCIL NIINUTES - SEPTEMBER 10, 1996 Federal Goverment would place sanctions against the City to prevent it receiving the money. Mary Venerable, 29400 3rd 5treet, requested pernussion to speak beyond the limit of time, as her presentation was approximately seven minutes. Mayor Pape indicated that she would need to scale down her comments to three minutes. Mrs. Venerable indicated that she is a business woman in the Lake Elsinore Area and a retired federal worker, and detailed her employment history in affirmative action and federal compliance. She expressed concern with the Council's failure to pass the updates to this program; and stressed that this is merely an update of the regulations in place since 1991. Councilman Alongi indicated that he has always fought for the small businesses, minority or otherwise. He clarified his beliefthat all businesses should be on an even plane in applying for the projects; and indicated that this was a discriminatory act of tying the governments hands. He stressed that he does not like the requirement which causes an unfair or special treatment in the competitions for jobs. He indicated that it was a disgrace to say that small businesses cannot exist without government aid. He explained his reason for voting no at the last meeting, but stressed that Council cannot jeopardize the funds available to the community. Mayor Pape concurred with Councilman Alongi, and noted his understanding of the law, the requirements and the strings attached. He commented that the Council needs to do what is best for the community; and if the Council plans to continue accepting fiznds, they will need to play by their rules. Councilman Metze indicated that he would not vote against this item, but questioned whether the program would work. He noted the problems he encountered as a disabled person; and expressed concern that the program is not working. He indicated that he would not take the funds away from the Community. MOVED BY METZE, SECONDED BY KELLEY AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO ADOPT RESOLUTION NO. 96-50: RESOLUTION NO. 96-50 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE UPDATING THE DISADVANTAGED BUSINESS ENTERPRISE (DBE) PROGRAM AND APPOINTING A DBE LLAISON OFFICER AND ESTABLISHING DBE GOALS. 6. 1996/97 M.O.U. (F:116.2) City Manager Molendyk explained that this this item has been negotiated with the United Public Employees of California. He explained the role of the Union and the discussions which occuned at budget time. He further explained that the document reflects a 3% cost of living for this budget year and the funds have been set aside, pursuant to Council guidelines. Councilman Alongi noted that this is one of those items which is distasteful to discuss as it relates to the employees. He indicated that all of the employees are at the top of the list, but Council is still dealing with the budget. He further indicated that while he does not oppose the M.O.U., he does question the future plans for the finances of the City. He noted that the air conditioning units at the Community Center are broken, and it is difficult to keep equipment working properly. He suggested that this item be postponed until after the financing has been discussed. He detailed his concerns and indicated that this matter should be postponed until after the Council discussion on September 12th. PAGE SEVEN - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - SEPTEMBER 10, 1996 Councilwoman Brinley reiterated that the funds were allocated in the approved budget, and stressed taht the staff is doing double duty. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY METZE AND CARRIED BY A VOTE OF 4 TO 1 WTTH ALONGI CASTING THE DISSENTING VOTE TO APPROVE THE MEMORANDUM WTTH THE UIVITED PUBLIC EMPLOYEES OF CALIFORN7A, LIUNA LOCAL 777 AS PRESENTED. Councilman Alongi expressed apologies to the employees. C,~gnlemental Agreement - 22nd Year C.D.B.G.(F:84.2) MarianaMohylyn, 305 W. Sumner, questioned how much money the City will be getting and for what purpose it will be used. She noted previous approvals and quesitoned why work has not yet been completed. She expressed concem with the funds being used for Code Enforcement. Councilman Alongi indicated that he pulled this item because of the way the money is being allocated, and expressed concern with amount for Swick Pazk vs. Code Enforcement. He suggested shifting the fixnds to better address Code Enforcement. He wished for more for the Senior Center and e~cpressed concern with the amount allocated to Crune Prevention. He questioned how a pazk can be put ahead of the code enforcement and crime prevention; and how to clean up the town if the money is a11 spent for parks. Mayor Pape noted earlier discussions of this item; and explained that this was the best matching between what was wanted and what was available. He concurred with need to fix the air conditioning at the Community Center, but clarified that it does not qualify for use of these funds. He stressed the parameters of the funding eligibility. Community Services Director Sapp concurred with Mayor and detailed the limitations and guidelines of the program. He indicated that the only funds which could be transfemed for Code Enforcement would be those allocated to HOPE. Councilman Alongi questioned how the staff arrived at the numbers for Swick Pazk and Code Enforcement. Community Services Director Sapp clarified the funding for a public works project vs. public service project dollazs. Councilman Alongi further questioned the percentages and suggested that the Council could increase code enforcement and crime prevention. He stressed that a park is not important, but Code Enforcement is important. He stressed the need to remove crime and problems from the Community. MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY KELLEY AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO APPROVE THE SUPPLEMENTAL AGREEMENT FOR THE 22ND YEAR C.D.B.G. FUNDS FOR SWICK/MATICH PARK EXPANSION PROJECT/ PHASE II ($149,100), CODE ENFORCEMENT ($14,000), LAKE ELSINORE SEIVIOR SERVICES ($40,784), CRIME PREVENTION ($6,564) AND H.O.P.E. ($5,000); AND AUTHORiZED THE MAYOR AND CTTY CLERK TO SIGN THE AGREEMENT. THE CITY COUNCIL MEETIlVG WAS RECESSED AT 8:30 P.M. THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING RECONVENED AT 8:32 P.M. PUBLIC COMMENTS - NON-AGENDIZED TTEMS Mariana Mohylyn, 305 W. Sumner, expressed concern for Lake Elsinore. She expressed sorrow that most of the people don't come and listen to the meeting. She expressed concern with the lack of sidewalks and Sunday bus transportation. She requested the opportunity to participate in the PAGE EIGHT - CTTY COUNCIL MINUTES - SEPTEMBER 10, 1996 RTA meetings to which Councilwoman Brinley is the liaison. Mary Venerable, 29400 3rd Street, further addressed the DBE Program Resolution. She expressed concern that with what she perceived as difficiencies int eh program and suggested that the appointment of the City Engineer as the liaison is a conflict of interest. She noted the list of contractors provided by CALTRANS, and questioned how often the Council is made aware of the number of contractors contacted. She further questioned the provision of periodic reports on program compliance. She requested that the Council investigate the requests for bids and noted that there are a number of hispanic business owners in the area who do landscaping. She suggested that the Council form a committe of minority individuals to review this program and others. Chris Hyland, 15191 Wavecrest, reiterated the concerns of Ms. Venerable; and concurred that the appointment of the City Engineer is a conflict. She requested a list from the City of all businesses owned by women who could be contracting for work, and a list of minorities in City Hall and those contacted for bids. Peter Dawson, Pro Marine, noted that additional water ski races will be held on September 21 st and 22nd. He noted the need for patrol boats to assist during the event, and requested that interested parties call Pro Marine. He encouraged spectators to attend on Poe Street at Lakeshore. He noted that the Lake has been especially nice this year, most people have left and the conditions are still ideal. CITY MANAGER COMMENTS City Manager Molendyk noted that the Do It Center announced that it will be opening on November lst. He recognized Chief Seabert for her efforts on fires throughout the State. ~ITY COUNCIL COMMENTS Mayor Pape called upon Councilman Alongi to make his comments. Councilman Alongi declined and stated that he was not ready to comment. Mayor Pape stated that if he did not speak now he would pass his chance to make comment. Councilman Alongi continued to decline to speak. Councilman Metze commented on the following: 1. Commented that for quite some time he has had some personal feelings, and noted that the article that was printed in the San Diego Union Tribune last Sunday and brought all his feeling into focus. He stated that he felt that Councilman Alongi and Chris Hyland are working against the City in regard to bonding . He quoted a portion of the paper and pointed out that he did not understand what they wanted through printing this type of negativity. He stated that this article was probably fa~ced to the Bank of Sumitomo the next day. He pointed out that just because they happened to find a reporter in San Diego who was ignorant and gullible enough to print this without talking to the Mayor or staff. Councilman Metze noted that we need to keep an eye on this type of situation. He pointed out that the City is being sabotaged and he does not know why. He asked if it were an issue of a couple of Council seats or so you can say "I told you so". He pointed out that the article was full of lies and amazes him that this would happen. He pointed out that this just firrns the feelings that he has had. Councilman Alongi stated that this was the purpose of him being asked to go first so he cannot rebut. Councilwoman Brinley commented on the following: PAGE NINE - CITY COUNCIL 1VIII~TUTES - SEPTEMBER 10,1996 She explained that Sunday started out to be a good and positive day until she received a disturbing phone call from the City Manager about an article in the San Diego Union Tribune which appeared on the front page. She noted that what bothered her the most was that the staffwriter Mr. Bloom, appazently made no effort to contact her. She stated that as Chairman of the Redevelopment Agency and a Council person she should have been contacted or the Mayor should have been contacted to gain their input regarding the Stadium and the efforts that they aze making to work toward a positive resolution of the Stadium. She pointed out that in the news article it quotes Councilman Alongi stating that he was censured and barred from City Hall because of the way he voted on the Stadium. He stated that it is an untruth and misleading. She noted that in 7une,1995, Mayor Pape and herself wrote the censure procedure to address Councilman Alongi and it had nothing to do with his vote. Councilwoman Brinley pointed out that the censure was in support of the employees of the City of Lake Elsinore to confirm their trust in Council giving them the right to work in a harassment free environment; to send a message to the Employee's Association of Riverside County that the Council did not condone abusive behavior upon the employees; and finally to reduce the liability of the City being sued by separating the actions of one Councilmember from the body as a whole; to censure Councilman Alongi's activities to reduce the chance of an attack on any employee of occurring again; and City Council giving the City Manager the authority to remove Councilman Alongi from City Hall for any of the above mentioned actions, violations or foregoing which would constitute a trespass and may be enforced, if necessary through the Riverside County Sheriffs Department. She noted that the censure had nothing to do with his vote regarding the Stadium, however, his comment in the paper stated that City Council censured him for his vote. Councilwoman Brinley stated that these are misleading falsehoods. She stated that she takes afl'ront to another statement which was: "the lack of response does not surprise Councilman Alongi, Ms. Mayhall, Ms. Lovett or Mrs. Hyland who says City officials do not want people to know the truth about their City Government" Councilman Alongi stated that the statement was true. Councflwoman Brinley stated that this new City Council has been forthright in providing information. She noted that everything is public record For public knowledge. She pointed out that the public has the freedom to walk down to City Hall, between the hours of 9:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. on any given day, Monday through Thursday and pick up a copy of the budget and anything thing else you would wish to see. She noted that there is not anything hidden from the public. She further pointed out that Lake Elsinore is not the only City experiencing money problems. She noted that Lake Elsinore is not the only city experiencing money problems. Councilwoman Brinley pointed out that the City of Moreno Valley, ~ City of Perris, Riverside County, City of Murrieta aze experiencing money ~ problems and they don't have a Stadium to blame it on. She explained that no one on City Council when they had to make the drastic cuts in the budget, that the City was not having problems, no one has said that the Stadium did not have problems. She pointed out that hind site is 20/20, Council knows what is wrong and it is Council's resolution to be part of the solution; to save the Stadium; to work toward a positive production. She noted that another untruth that is in the article is the fact that the Wynona 7udd Special was placed before the Kids-On- Track program. She pointed out that the Wynona 7udd Special was a 4th of 7uly Concert that was presented in 1994 and $100,000 was set aside in the budget to promote the show and had nothing to do with the Kids-On-Track program. She noted that when the Kids-On-Track program came up in 1995 for cuts, she had approached Council for $35,000 one time seed money to save the program. She noted ihat to this time she and Mayor Pro Tem Kelley are working with the school PAGE TEN - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - SEPTEMBER 10, 1996 to acquire grants to help continue the program. Councilwoman Brinley addressed Mrs. Lovett, owner of Granny's Kitchen, statements regarding her statements and pointed out that she is open for breal~'ast and lunch and explained that there is no way that the Stadium could affect her business, since she doesn't serve dinner. She noted that she and her husband eat at the different restaurants around the Stadium and observed that they aze busy, and that the Stadium has not hurt their business. Mrs. Lovett who is also the President of the D.B.A. stated that the Stadium has done nothing except cost them a ton a money. Councilwoman Brinley disagreed and stated that the Stadium had iYs 1,000,000 fan on July 24. Councilman Alongi interrupted and asked how much the City has lost. He pointed out that if the Mayor won't allow him to speak he will interrupt. Mayor Pape called Councilman Alongi to order, and stated that Councilman Alongi needed to control himself. Councilman Alongi continued to disrupt the meeting. Mayor Pape stated that Councilman Alongi had a choice; he could either sit quietly and act like a professional or he can get up and leave on his own, or the deputy would be instructed to remove him. He stated that those are the choices and he can choose. Councilman Alongi stated that the Mayor would have to have the Deputy come up and remove him because he was not going. Mayor Pape stated that Councilwoman Brinley had the floor and asked that Councilman Alongi allow her to continue. Councilman Alongi stated that the Mayor refused him the right to comment and the reason that he was refused the right was because of what was being said. He noted that the Mayor could have allowed him to speak after everyone spoke, because he knew exactly what was going to happen this evening. He further stated that they do not have the backbone to have Councilman Alongi rebut what was being said, because Council is still lying to the people of the City of Lake Elsinore. Mayor Pape stated that he feels that what was occurring was a rebuttal to what had already been said. Councilman Alongi agreed and stated that what they are telling the people is a lie. He stated that what he has told the people is the truth. Councilwoman Brinley commented that if only one third of the people that have used that Stadium stopped and used a restaurant, gas station, one of the local grocery stores, or one ofthe local service stores then it represents tu~ dollazs that were spent in the City. She addressed Ms. Lovett and pointed out how important the tax dollar is to the City. She noted 7ane and Howazd Barnes of the Lakeview Inn have informed her of the occupancy of their Inn which has occuned because of the Stadium as well as what the restaurant owners in town say about the stadium and the business it has generated for them. Councilwoman Brinley addressed the statement by Mrs. Mayhall that the City stopped giving her business three years ago because she opposed the project and explained that she has known Mrs. Mayhall for appro~cimately 18 years and noted that Mrs. Mayhall has been an outspoken person in the community whether she is for or against an issue and she does not feel that any member of Council has anything against Mrs. Mayhall. She noted that anyone can get up to the podium and express their opinion and felt that PAGE ELEVEN - C1TY COUNCIL MIl~TUTES - 5EPTEMBER 10,1996 the City has gone from one extreme to the other with Mrs. Mayhall accusing us of this type of action. Mrs. Brinley stated that she can remember people going to previous Councilmembers and questioned Mrs. Mayhall getting all the printing jobs because Linda Strigotte, a former Mayor and Councilmembers wife, worked for Mrs. Mayhall. Councilwoman Brinley stated that Council knows that just because Linda Strigotte worked for her was not the reason why she got the print jobs. She again addressed Mrs. Lovett concem that the local politicians will boycott her restaurant and noted that as far as she knew Councilman Alongi is the only Councilmember who frequents her restaurant and since she shares his views, she felt that Mrs. LovetYs fears are pointless. Councilwoman Brinley speaking for the RDA pointed out that the 5tadium did not cost $25,000,000 but rather $22,000,000 and it is not a$25,000,000 loan to the Bank of Sumitomo, but rather $10,000,000. She pointed out that the City pays $1,000,000 a yeaz, with an annual operations and maintenance costs are $750,000 a year without Spectrum. She addressed the audience and stated that there is nothing that the public does not haue the right to see and know and there is nothing that the City Council has ever kept from the public. Councilwoman Brinley stated that she is getting tired of ~ reading articles about her City, the Stadium and sitting on Council and having to ~ defend it to a person who didn't do his homework and did not take the time to i seek out staff and make the effort to go 100% of the way to talk to other Councilmembers. She noted that the reporter took the opinion of a few negative people within our community. Councilwoman Brinley stated that it is her obligation and professional duty to conduct herself in a professional manner. She further stated that she does not go out in the community and talk down or bash her City. She explained that there have been mistakes and errors, but it is things that Council can correct and resolve and there is not one person of the four on the City Council that isn't working daily to help the Stadium. Councilwoman Brinley stated that she had lunch with Mr. Zed Buffman, who is the developer who is doing a major development of approximately $140,000,000 in Temecula. She explained that she had met with Mr. Buffman to ask for help and direction for the City and came away from the meeting with a positive feeling about what can be done and Mr. Buffrnan's vision of two cities working together to allow both to prosper, and then she picks up something like this article which shows her that there is a Councilman sitting on this board trying to work against a Council that is trying to deal with the cunent problems. She noted that it is sad that Councilman Alongi's obsessive vindictiveness for the past Council, because he wants to be able to say "I told you so" will bring the City down at any cost. Councilwoman Brinley stated that Council cannot allow that to happen. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley commented on the following: Stated that she had read the news article also, and she was very saddened by it. She explained that what saddens her in reading this article is not the specifics, but rather the fact that at the beginning of this new Council it was agreed that what is the past is the past; and that we need to put our heads together to solve problems and get solutions. She asked when are we going to start solving problems and not creating them. She further explained that Council agreed to cooperate with each other; work hazd with each other; we need to look to our financial advisors; and we needed to come up with solutions and not keep beating a dead horse, especially with misinformation. She noted that Council agreed that the budget with both the long term and short term solutions were their major goals. She stated that she thought all of Council agreed that was what they were going to work on, now an article like this divides and prevents cooperative solutions. 5he noted that it creates problems where there shouldn't have been a problem created; it creates animosity where we don't need it; it alienates people on the Council where we don't need to be alienated. She stated that the Diamond is here and we need to PAGE TWELVE - CITY COUNCIL MINUTE5 - SEPTEMBER 10,1996. make it work. Mayor Pro Tem Kelley stated Yhat the only way that Council can make it work is to work together and articles like this do nothing but create problems that we don't need. She stated that it is even more appalling when it comes from one ofyour own. Mayor Pape commented on the following: 1. Stated that he always felt that a City Councilman should be an ambassador for the City, out in the public promoting the benefits of the City, not only to iYs residents, but to people outside the area. He noted that especially with Lake Elsinore where a major element of our revenue comes from tourism. He pointed out that to the communities to the south of us who saw this article, I think that we have been damaged. He noted that they will have a very different opinion of what they haue had of Lake Elsinore than what they haue had previously. He further noted that the efforts of the member of the community to promote the Lake and tourism in the City could be affected by the general opinion of the people who read this piece of yellow journalism done by a lazy reporter who didn't make any real effort to get the full story. Mayor Pape stated that going through the article there were so many lies and misinformation that it is hard to point them all out, but a few of the key ones can be pointed out. He noted that the numbers used for the Stadium were incorrect. He further noted the part the addressed the Downtown is inconect and slanted. E~Ie stated that he doesn't know if our powntown is different from anyone else, but he does feel that the downtown has improve quite a bit in the last year, with less vacancies and stores and restaurants expanding. He pointed out that the City spent $6,000,000 fixing up the downtown area, to make it look nicer to attract people into the area. He pointed out that there is a major hotel that is planning to develop at the end of Main Street. Mayor Pape noted the statement by Pat Lovett about local politicians boycotting her restaurant, and yet there is only one Councilman, Mr. Alongi, that eats there regularly and maybe she was concerned that if she didn't speak up on his behalf that he would end up boycotting her restaurant, since not of the others go there. Mayor Pape pointed out the section of the article that states that Councilman Alongi was censured and batted from City Ha11 for voting against financing the Baseball Park. He stated that a censure is an official reprimand, and was issued because of an assault on a City staff member. Councilman Alongi stated that allegation has not been proven yet. Mayor Pape cautioned Councilman Alongi that he has been spoken to. CounciLnan Alongi stated that he doesn't caze if he has been spoken to or not, that Mayor Pape should state the truth or don't say anything. Mayor Pape asked Councilman Alongi if he was ready to leave. Councilman Alongi stated that no he was not, but to get his Sheriff ready. Mayor Pape continued and stated that the censure occurred because of an attack on a staff member Councilman Alongi interrupted and stated that it is alleged. Mayor Pape went on to say that Council had a concern that it might occur again and so Council took action to prevent that to other staff members. Councilman Alongi interrupted and stated that this is without due process. PAGE THIliTEEN - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - SEPTEMBER 10,1996 Mayor Pape stated that there is no possible way a reporter could even confuse it. He stated that he is the first one to give the benefit of the doubt on a quote in the news paper. He explained that he has been quoted enough times that he knows that things can be taken out of contea~t, things can be changed and not necessarily by the reporter, but by the editor, so that what is said is not exactly what is printed. He noted however, if there is a discussion about the Stadium and discussion regarding a censure which occurred in City Hall relates to the Stadium discussion, leads to the conclusion that it would not be reported unless it was brought up. Councilman Alongi stated that this should tell you that he would not say that. Mayor Pape noted that in the article it states that "These people should be lined up against the wa11 and shot for what they did". CouncIlman Alongi interrupted and stated that was right and Mr. Winkler and Mr. Washburn should haue gone to jail. Mayor Pape asked for the Sheriffs Officer to remove Councilman Alongi since he was tired of being interrupted. Mayor Pape called for a two minute recess. THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING WAS RECESSED AT 9:04 P.M. THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING RECONVENED AT 9:05 P.M. Mayor Pape stated that Councilman Alongi's conduct was absolutely rude continually interrupted. He noted the statement in the article that states that the people should be lined up against the wall and shot for what they did, somebody needs to go to jail. He further noted that he did not know who he wants to shoot, but there have been allegations in the past and a report was filed with the Sheriff s Office by former Mayor Strigotte because Councilman Alongi threatened to shoot him in the head. Fie noted that there was also a threat against Charlie Hand. He explained that he does not know if the reference was in regard to one of these gentlemen or one of the past Councilmembers. Mayor Pape pointed out that he is the only one cunently on Council that had anything to do with the construction on ~ the Stadium and voting of the financing of the Stadium. Mayor Pape stated that he hopes that he is not talking about shooting anyone that is currently on the Council since they did not have anything to do with the financing of the Stadium. Mayor Pape commented on the cost to operate the Stadium and noted that there was no mention that the City is negotiating a new contract with the Team to raise the revenue to the City to pay for the Maintenance. He explained that Council has taken action to handle the Stadium ourselves. He commented on Councilman Alongi's response on how the City will get out of the situation, and Councilman Alongi stated that we would not. Mayor Pape stated that it is clear to him that Councilman Alongi does not want to be a part of the solution, but rather contribute to the problem. He pointed out that there is five people on Council who are suppose to be working together as a team to solve the problem. He made note of the comments on the City's Lighting and Landscaping District comments made by Councilman Alongi and stated that the information was incorrect. He further noted the difference in information regarding the cost to convert the Stadium for special events, cost of concerts, funding for the Stadium, the Kids-on-Track Program, and commented on Councilman Alongi's remark about the fact that Council would not talk to the reporter because the Council wants to calm down the bankers and the bond-holders and they want to stop the negative publicity. Mayor Pape asked who "they" was since he thought we were all suppose to help solve the problems. He noted that Council should be focusing on tomorrow and trying to make the future better, instead of continuing to dig up the past. He asked PAGE FOURTEEN - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - SEPTEMBER 10, 1996 if anything in the article contributed to the solution. He pointed out that the Stadium is there and the challenge before us now is to make it work. Mayor Pape pointed out that continuing to try and degrade the Stadium, financing and previous Council is non-productive and sad. He made note of the letter in the Californian by Mr. 7acobs that Councilman Alongi criticize for being negative about the City of Lake Elsinore and then turned around and did just the same thing. Mayor Pape stated that he felt that it was important to address this news article because ofthe misinformation and lies that appeared in this article and wished to see them corrected. CLOSED SESSION Potential Litigation - L.E.R.A., Inc. 2. Potential Litigation - Lou°s Lakeshore Lounge. Pending Litigation - USA Properties. 4. Potential Litigation - Tattoo Parlor. THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING WAS ADJOURNED TO CLOSED SESSION AT 9:11 P.M. TO DI5CUSS THE ABOVE LISTED TTEMS AND THE CLAIM OF JOSEPH GRAS50. THE CITY COUNCILMEETING RECONVENED AT 10:15 P.M. MOVED BY PAPE, SECONDED BY BRINLEY AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO REJECT AND REFER TO CLAIMS ADMIlVISTRATOR THE CLAIM SUBMITTED BY JOSEPH N. GRASSO, AND DIl2ECTED THE CITY CLERK TO SEND A LETTER INFORNIING MR. GRASSO OF TffiS ACTION. ADJOURNMENT MOVED BY BRINLEY, SECONDED BY PAPE AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE TO ADJOURN THE REGULAR CLPYF CIL MEETING AT 10:16 P.M. ,f~ ; Y~ ~l~~t~'~ ~ ~ /KEVIN W. FAPE, MAYOR / CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE CY CLERK CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE