HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem No.1DMINUTES
REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING.
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
31315 CHANEY STREET
LAKE ELSINORE, CALIFORNIA
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 23,".1993
ttttttt tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt *ttttttttttttttttttt
CALL TO ORDER.'
The Regular City Council Meeting was called to order by Mayor
Washburn at 7:02 p.m.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Mayor. Washburn.
ROLL CALL
PRESENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: ALONGI, CHERVENY, DOMINGUEZ, WINKLER,
WASHBURN
ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: NONE
Also present were: City Manager Molendyk, Assistant City Manager
Rogers, City Attorney Harper., Administrative. Services Director
Boone, Community Development Manager Shear, City Planner Leslie,
Community Services Manager Best,- Public Services Director-Tecca,
Manager of Special Projects Watenpaugh, City Treasurer Pape and
City Clerk Kasad..
PRESENTATIONS/CEREMONIALS-
a. Update on Baseball Club: _
Kevin.Haughian, General Manager, Lake Elsinore Baseball Club,
announced that to date 1,326 season tickets and all of the
luxury suites have been sold. He noted that the club's
initial: goal was for ;1,.000 season tickets, but based on
response this has been revised to 2,000. He also noted that
of those tickets sold, nearly 1,000 were purchased by Lake
Elsinore residents. He presented the proposed "home" and
"away" -team jerseys, and noted that the game hat is being
reworked.
b. Update on Outflow Channel Proiect.
James Lowe, 3 B's Construction, detailed the progress to date
on this project. He noted that 75,000 cubic yards of dirt
will be trucked to the stadium site for that project. He
detailed the upcoming road closures and alternate solutions,
should the rains or flooding become a problem. He also noted
that all is progressing.well and they are currently awaiting
approval from Caltrans for the bridge on Highway 74. He
reminded the community that the:project' administrator for this
job is the Riverside County Flood Control. District. He
further noted value engineering efforts to find ways to reduce
the cost of this project.
AGENDA ITEM NO. /l/l.
PAGE / 0, — / 7
PAGE TWO - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993
C. Winterfest, 1993.
Mayor Washburn announced that Winterfest will run from 4 p.m.
to 9 p.m. with the Christmas Tree Lighting at 5:00 p.m. and
Santa's arrival at 5:30 p.m. He detailed the proposed
activities for this event. '
PUBLIC COMMENTS - AGENDIZED ITEMS
Requests were received to address the following items and deferred
to those discussions:
Item Nos. 32 and 34.
CONSENT CALENDAR
The following items were pulled from the. Consent Calendar for
further discussion and consideration:
Item Nos. 3, 4, 6, 10, 11, 13, 14 and 15.
MOVED BY ALONGI, SECONDED BY CHERVENY AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE
TO APPROVE THE BALANCE OF THE CONSENT CALENDAR AS PRESENTED.
1. The following Minutes were approved:
a.
City Council
Study Session -
October 21;
1993.
b.
Regular City
Council Meeting
- November
9, 1993.
- The following Minutes were received and ordered filed:
c. Planning Commission Meeting - October.21,;1993.
d. Planning Commission Meeting - November 3, 1993.
2. . Received and ordered filed the Investment Report 'for October,
1993.
5. — Approve Agreement for Administration of the General
Maintenance for the Library Facility.
7. Approved Change Order No. 3 - Country Club Heights Trunk Sewer
By -Pass Phase .II Sewer Improvements in Community Facilities
District No. 88 -3 for Riverside Pipeline Inc. for a reduction
of $36,239.43.
8. Adopted Resolution of Intention to Change the Street Name of
Sylvester Street to Malaga Road — Resolution No. 93 -69.
RESOLUTION NO. 93 -69,
A RESOLUTION OF INTENTION OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE,
CALIFORNIA, CHANGING THE NAME OF SYLVESTER STREET. '
9. Adopted Resolution No. 93 -70 Establishing:Additional Parking
- Citation Enforcement. Penalties ;.
RESOLUTION NO. 93 -70
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE,
CALIFORNIA, AMENDING THE ESTABLISHED PARKING ENFORCEMEN4
SCHEDULES AND PENALTIES.
AGENDA ITEM NO.
PAGE Or ^-!
PAGE THREE - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993..
12. - Accepted Grant Deeds for the Purpose'of Easement
Dedications for Various -City Projects at the following
locations:
Lot -125, Unit B of Country.'Club Heights for a.10' Slope
Easement.
Lots "95 & 97 in'Book 16," Pages 59 to-61-for a 101
..Slope
Easement.
`',_:Lot 20 in Block 2 of Elsinore Heights Unit #1 for a'7.5'
Right -of -Way.
Lot 17 in Block 2 of Elsinore Heights.Unit #1 for a .5'
Right -of -Way.
Outlet-Center Phase II for a Drainage Easement..,
ITEMS PULLED`FROM CONSENT CALENDAR
3. Warrant List - November 15, 1993.
Councilman Alongi requested that' :items. on the .Warrant ,List
such as weed abatement rebates be designated as such. He
suggested that the entry for Rasmussen's should be noted as an
expense for "Halloween.` He noted that the_.check '.for the Great
Main Street - Antique Store was for a chair for' Santa- at, the
Winterfest; he questioned why the equipment for Santa was ;not
requested from the Downtown Business Association.
MOVED BY ALONGI, SECONDED BY CHERVENY AND CARRIED BY= UNANIMOUS VOTE
TO RATIFY THE WARRANT LIST AS PRESENTED.
4. Claims Aaainst the City -`BSI Consultants- (CL: #93 -17) and
•I LCVCII VVL11lG1 \l.L TJJ -1J j
City Manager Molendyk requested deferral of the claim, from BSI
Consultants and recommended that the.Claim of- Steven Dobihal
be rejected and referred to claims administrator for handling.
MOVED BY ALONGI;`SECONDED BY "CHERVENY AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE
TO DEFER THE CLAIM SUBMITTED BY BSI CONSULTANTS AND�TO:REJECT.AND
REFER TO CLAIMS ADMINISTRATOR THE CLAIM SUBMITTED BY STEVEN
DOBIHAL.
6. Award of Contract - Senior Center Projects (Outdoor
ncMlcda.lyuQa L141lLVYGIOpu VO) l.v.a.a ua..,
Councilman Alongi inquired what workawill -be done as.part of
this project. He indicated that he did not believe it would
include the horseshoe pits and questioned why they were not
'being done at this time. Community Services Manager I Best
advised that the horseshoe pit is include - as - are all - other
alternatives. I `'Councilman .Alongi: expressed concern that there
=is nor mention• of the horseshoe pits, only grading and
retaining walls. Ms. Best indicated that the bids received
did include the horseshoe -pits and detailed the specifics.
included `in this bid package: ' Councilman Alongi indicated
-that he a till did not .see that mentioned in the staff,report
AGENDA ITEM NO. / �✓
PF,G�CF �7_
PAGE FOUR - CITY COUNCIL'MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993 ._:
and inquired whether it would be
Best indicated it would be only=
explained -that the low bid was
compliance.
one contract or two. Ms.
one contract., She further
rejected - because. of non-
MOVED BY ALONGI, SECONDED BY CHERVENY TO POSTPONE THIS_ITEM UNTIL
ALL INFORMATION IS RECEIVED.
Councilwoman Cherveny requested clarification of a "non-
responsive" bid. Community Services Manager Best deferred to
the City Attorney for this clarification. She noted that
Kevin 'Palmer_ of the Community- Development Agency concurred
with the reasons for rejecting the low bidder, -in compliance
with the C.D.B.G. regulations, as well as approving the
contractor proposed as eligible for- C.D'.B.G. funds.,
Mayor Washburn indicated that he would not be against this
award of contract because he has adequate information.
THE FOREGOING MOTION FAILED TO CARRY BY 'A :VOTE OF 2 TO- 3 WITH
DOMINGUEZ, WASHBURN AND WINKLER CASTING THE - DISSENTING VOTES.
MOVED BY WASHBURN, SECONDED BY DOMINGUEZ TO AWARD THIS CONTRACT TO
MODCRAFT,'INC. IN THE AMOUNT OF $89,386.00.
Mayor Washburn announced that the Senior Center has developed
a cookbook for sale at a cost of $8 for the first copy =and $5
for each additional • copy. He commended staff for this effort
and a nice finished product.
THE FOREGOING MOTION CARRIED BY A VOTE OF 4 TO 1 WITH ALONGI
CASTING THE DISSENTING.VOTE. "
10. Authorization for CR & R to
LaAC 8u4c l.lcaaa 4,J V+a a.crcu+u cr_ s,
Councilman Alongi indicated that he would
date moved later in the month to allow for
Christmas tree disposal..
like to see this
holidaytrash.and
Mayor Washburn indicated that while he understood the request,
he would question it because CR & iR picks up trees anyway. He
explained that it, is felt that a, stand alone event would be ,
more successful.
Mayor Pro Tem Dominguez indicated that several days had been
considered.
MOVED BY WASHBURN, SECONDED BY DOMINGUEZ TO AUTHORIZE CR & R TO
PLACE TRASH RECEPTACLES FOR THE LAKE EDGE CLEAN UP ON DECEMBER 11,
1993.
Councilwoman Cherveny inquired whether this.would include the
County side of the Lake. City Manager Molendyk indicated that
they would only -,be.. placed in the City; but anyone could
utilize the bins.. He explained that" -the City can only
authorize use within the City limits pursuant to the contract.
Councilwoman Cherveny further questioned the access for County
residents. Mayor Washburn indicated that with legitimate,lake
clean up items there would probably be no problem. City
Attorney Harper further clarified that the City can only
address City uses under the contract.
PAGE FIVE - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 23, 1993
THE FOREGOING MOTION CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE.
11. Acceptance of Quit Claim Deeds for the Purpose or water 1c1y1160
Dedications for Various City`Projects•.-'
Councilman Alongi stated his ongoing opposition to•this type .'
of action.
MOVED BY WASHBURN, SECONDED BY CHERVENY AND CARRIED BY A` VOTE 'OF 4
TO 1 WITH ALONGI CASTING THE DISSENTING VOTE TO ACCEPT THE QUIT
CLAIM DEEDS FOR WATER RIGHTS FOR VARIOUS CITY PROJECTS AT THE
FOLLOWING LOCATIONS:
Southwest one -half of lots 95 &.97 , Unit A of Country
Club Heights.
Lot 20 in Block 2 of Elsinore Heights Unit #1.
Lot 34 in Block 12 of Elsinore Heights Tract Unit #2.
Lot 17 in Block 2 of Elsinore Heights Tract Unit #1
13. Demolition of-103 North Scrivener Street'.,
Councilman Alongi reiterated his previous concerns with this
expenditure of -funds without any time element for repayment:
He stressed that he has no problem with tearing -the buildings
down, but he does have a problem with the unlimited period for
reimbursement. He further addressed this site with regard to
a trash bin on site for over a year, without being addressed
by Code Enforcement.
MOVED BY DOMINGUEZ, SECONDED BY ALONGI TO APPROVE THIS DEMOLITION
AND THAT•IN ITEM #14 WITH REPAYMENT To OCCUR WITHIN 24 MONTHS.'
'City Attorney Harper noted that if the property changes hands
in the meantime'repayment would occur at that time.
Councilman Winkler noted that it might not be beneficial to
sue for. the 'money at 23 'months, and suggested that this
evaluation be left up to the City Attorney; Mayor Washburn
indicated that it was possible to approve the demolitions and
condition them,to' meet the cost recovery - policy in place at,
that time. City Attorney Harper Indicated that this could be
reviewed and he would not interpret this motion as direction
'to- foreclose.
THE FOREGOING MOTION CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE.
14. Demolition of 207 East Pottery Street.
MOVED BY DOMINGUEZ, SECONDED BY " ALONGI AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS
VOTE TO APPROVE THIS DEMOLITION WITH REPAYMENT TO OCCUR WITHIN 24
MONTHS.
15. Phase II Clean Lakes 314 Grant.
Councilwoman Cherveny noted comments in the report that the
there is no notable change in the water- quality since the
aqua -treat program. She suggested that this program should be
r .-:_ _ ar -2-
PAGE SIX - CITY COUNCIL "MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993
halted to allow LEMA to do their part and if possible find a
solution. She expressed concern with the money.spent to date
on treatment.
MOVED BY CHERVENY, SECONDED BY ALONGI AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE
TO ENDORSE THE PHASE II PROJECT AND DESIGNATE $25,000 IN THE CITY'S
1994 -95 FISCAL YEAR.'BUDGET FOR THE PROPOSED PHASE 3I CLEAN LAKES
314 PROGRAM.
BUSINESS "ITEMS
Councilman Winkler requested that item #37 be considered at this.
time. Mayor Washburn indicated that with unanimous consent it-
would be moved. Councilman Alongi questioned this action.
Councilman Winkler explained that he would request that this item
be heard next following a quick closed., session regarding
acquisition of property.
THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING WAS ADJOURNED TO CLOSED SESSION AT 7:40
P.M.
THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING WAS RECONVENED AT 7;:- 50 -P.M._
37. Methodist Church Parking Lot - Verbal Report - Requested by
Councilman Winkler.
MOVED .BY WINKLER, SECONDED BY WASHBURN TO ACQUIRE THE BUILDINGS
BEHIND.THE METHODIST CHURCH AT 110, 118 AND 126 W. HEALD; FIRST
THROUGH A GOOD FAITH EFFORT TO PURCHASE., THEM OR. SUBSEQUENTLY
EMINENT DOMAIN.
Councilwoman Cherveny clarified that this, money_, would be from
the General Fund Reserves.
Councilman Winkler indicated that,he would next pursue action, -
on the next RDA agenda to authorize the purchase of this
.. property from the, City, because the Redevelopment Agency
cannot use eminent domain. He, noted that in the long term,the
reserves would be maintained.
THE FOREGOING MOTION CARRIED BY A VOTE OF,3 TO 2 WITH ALONGI AND
CHERVENY CASTING THE DISSENTING VOTES.
31. Second Reading - Ordinance No..967,- Zone Change 93 -4 - The
Western Company /Laguna Heights.
MOVED BY WASHBURN, SECONDED BY ALONGI TO ADOPT ORDINANCE _NO.
967:
c
ORDINANCE NO. 967
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE,
,CALIFORNIA, PREZONING 199 ACRES TO RURAL RESIDENTIAL AND OPEN
SPACE (ZONE CHANGE 93 -4), LOCATED ROUGHLY SOUTHWEST .OF THE
INTERSECTION OF TOFT DRIVE AND GRAND AVENUE: THE WESTERN
COMPANY /LAGUNA HEIGHTS.
UPON THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE:
AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS: ALONGI, CHERVENY, DOMINGUEZ, WASHBURN
NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS: NONE
PAGE SEVEN - CITY`COUNCIL MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993
ABSENT:' 'COUNCILMEMBERS: NONE .
ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBERS:- WINKLER,
32.
City Manager Molendyk explained that,on August 24, 1993, the
Council considered the userof private.security,to supplement
the services of the Sheriff's Department., Councilwoman
Cherveny has.requested reconsideration of this matter...
Councilwoman Cherveny stated that. Proposition 172 was approved
by the voters on the. November<.ballot and there' is
approximately $108,000 for public services,.
MOVED BY CHERVENY,'SECONDED BY ALONGI TO.APPROVE THE.ALLOCATION OF
THE APPROXIMATELY $106,000 FOR SECURITY OFFICERS TO SUPPLEMENT THE
SHERIFF'S SERVICES.
Mayor Washburn then called upon the persons who - requested to
speak on this item:
Leon Strigotte, 216 Chaney Street,, stated that the voters
passed Proposition172 specifically for Law Enforcement and
Public Safety Officers as defined under Penal Code 830 and
Private Security does not qualify. -.He explained that
'Proposition 172 not only deals with police, but also fire
services. Mr. Strigotte quoted, an article from the Press
Enterprise, November -21, 1993, which is,entitled."Take.Back
Your Neighborhood He explained that solving. the crime
problem is not done just -by hiring more police, officers, it is
the 'responsibility of the citizens as .well. He. further
'explained that the taxpayer will not receive.the same-level of
service from a security officer.- - Mr. Strigotte,,stated that
he felt that the'$108,000 should be spent to open up a fire
station at the west end--of the City, and encouraged the
Council to promote a City Reserve Force which.would not cost
$108,000 and would.get people out who.really: want to make a
difference -in the community.. ' He explained that this would
have an immediate impact in the community and would aid law
enforcement in, a positive way. He stated that at next year's
budget is when the- increase in. law. enforcement should be
considered,-. but not private security. He commented on,the
fact that he has not seen the two bicycle patrol, officers
patrol more than the outlet center and there is a need -,for
them in other areas.
Chris Hyland, 15191 Wavecrest, stated that;the $108,000,needs
to be used to put more law enforcement on-the streets. She
commented on a recent- incident which -occurred in her
neighborhood and stated that . she welcomes more law
enforcement.
Councilman Dominguez indicated that he'feels that the Council
needs the recommendation of professional staff to allow
Council to make an informed decision.
Councilman" Winkler, commented on article in the Press
Enterprise in regard to "How To Take Back Your Neighborhood"
AGE14OA ITEM NO. /
PA3E
OF
PAGE EIGHT - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993
and he explained that it was through Neighborhood Watch, Crime
Watch and caring citizens that this effort succeeded. He
indicated that it must be - approached neighborhood- by-
neighborhood, block by block and child by child. He stated
that with dwindling resources it is necessary "for.the. citizens
to take control. He explained the problems within the
judicial system and suggested that there should be a City
staff ' position, such 'as a liaison to work-in the . judicial
system and follow up on all arrests and repeat. offenders. He
further suggested the same position could be present at the
arraignment level to confirm the City's position and follow -up
on the trials. He stated that a list of all arrests, criminal
convictions and housing evictions should be available to the
Council, Crime Watch Committee, Apartment Owners and Managers
to aid in their effectiveness to keep out the criminal element
and prevent problems before they begin. He also indicated
'that the local cable channel can be used to aid in the control.
of crime and he suggested that .the City continue. to pursue
drug abatement litigation.
MOVED BY WINKLER, SECONDED BY'WASHBURN A SUBSIDIARY MOTION TO
DIRECT STAFF TO REORGANIZE AND CONSIDER ALTERNATIVES; SUCH OVERTIME
FOR SWORN OFFICERS, MORE AID TO PATROL, A LIAISON OFFICER FOR CRIME
PREVENTION AND COORDINATION WITH THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM;:;AND REQUESTED
THAT THIS ITEM RETURN TO COUNCIL IN TWO WEEKS.
Mayor Washburn stated that to address crime there is a need
for manpower and to have manpower there is a•need for - money.
He explained that there is an Anti -Crime Bill which is in
progress and he has been in contact with Congressman.Calvert
to-work on this issue to support more funds for the City's
needs. He commented that it doesn't matter who you are in the
community. Hispanic or- other, crime.is crime and-no one in
any walk of life wants crime in their neighborhood. Mayor
Washburn explained that every year.the Council has increased
the'law enforcement manpower and will continue to do so.. He
commented that the FBI Crime Report is incorrect and it is not
151 crimes per thousand, but rather 93.crimes per 1000. He
stated that there is still a crime problem and it, must be
.addressed, but it -is -not as bad.as what the report stated.
Councilman Winkler explained that:there are high crime areas
" in the'City and one of them is behind the Methodist Church in
the downtown area. He stated that abatement is one-way to
address this and aggressive action in following up. on
incidents.
Councilman Alongi commented that crime is crime and in the
City of Lake Elsinore crime is increasing. He stated in the
State Constitution, Amendment No. 1, .Chapter No. 41, does not
indicate that armed and sworn officers are required; it states
that the protection of Public Safety. is -the , first
responsibility of the local government or local, officials and
they have an obligation to 'give priority to the provisions of
adequate public safety service: He - explained that this
affects all areas of public safety. He stated that- he,_agreed
with Councilman Winkler, but that he is addressing crimes
already committed and he would like to see crime prevented.
Councilman Alongi asked Captain Daniel if the.officers did not
PAGE NINE - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993
have to write reports on the recent 52 cars that were stolen,
how much sworn officer time would be saved: He stated that he
is,not opposed to Mr. Winkler's ideas, but he feels that the_
needs of the community are more immediate.. He emphasized
crime is .crime and -defined that .responsibilities'; of the
homeowner, in regard to who rents and lives"in :their homes.
He further explained that it does not matter where the City is
on the list of crime, -it is just not acceptable.. Councilman
Alongi stated that he wants to see the crime ratio back to
what it was in 1968 and 1969. There were no drive -by
shootings or violent crimes dike there are today and the City
was safe then. He stated that 93 crimes per 1000 is still too,
much and he wants to see it reduced.
.Councilwoman Cherveny questioned the program that Councilman
Winkler is proposing, and asked if' it was meant to be done
instead of :adding officers._ She explained that crime -watch is
necessary . but the City needs more sworn;offi'cers.,She pointed
out that when security - officers,. were used in the downtown
area;-and there was a major decline in crime.. She concurred
that the Crime -watch is an aid to the community, but' that
security officers would offer a deterrent to crime. She
explained that the sworn officers,are going call.to call.and .
do not have the time to patrol.. She stated,it would be pro-
active and not reactive. Councilwoman Cherveny explained that
the security officers can be placed.in.neighborhoods and in
high crime areas to help to prevent crime.
City Manager Molendyk explained that, he has heard ,several
different ways to address the crime in the community, and he
-had just.received a memo from, Captain. Daniel of a fax from the.
Department .of, Justice; that, President, Clinton has 'Just
announced that $150 Billion Dollars be available for
-assistance to law enforcement agencies. He explained that it
is- broken down into increments and - would .supplement.up.to 758
for salary and benefits for each .pollbe officer.. These
figures can be utilized by staff for further suggestions to
the Council by the next meeting. He will distribute this-to
Council.
Councilman, Alongi asked that staff consider security.guards,in
their evaluation and,suggestions..,
Mr. Strigotie explained that Riverside Police Department has
a full time grant.writer and stated that this would expand „the
ability to acquire more funds and equipment. It is their job
to research and apply for monies available for'more and better
programs.and would benefit the program.
THE FOREGOING SUBSIDIARY MOTION WAS APPROVED BY A 3 -2 VOTE WITH
ALONGI AND CHERVENY CASTING -THE DISSENTING VOTES. . .
Councilwoman.Cherveny called.for a -.vote on the first motion.
Mayor Washburn explained that a vote on the first motion was
a moot point since the subsidiary motion took precedence.
33. Use of Community Center - Non- Profit Organizations - Requested
by Councilman Alongi.
Councilman Alongi indicated that he would like this to address
ITEM NO. �_=
or _L7
PAGE TEN - CITY COUNCIL,MINUTES - "NOVEMBER 23, 1993
organizations which benefit the total community and would like
to use the Community Center, but find it cost prohibitive.'
MOVED BY ALONGI TO OFFER THE COMMUNITY CENTER ONE TIME PER YEAR FOR
NON- PROFIT GROUPS LOCATED IN THE CITY LIMITS, WITH THE CITY MANAGER
AUTHORIZED TO DETERMINE WHICH GROUPS ARE QUALIFIED. MOTION DIED
FOR LACK OF A SECOND.
Mayor Washburn noted that.a cooperative program is already in
existence.
MOVED BY WASHBURN, SECONDED BY WINKLER TO TABLE THIS' 'ITEM
INDEFINITELY.
Councilman Alongi noted that groups are still asked to pay a
deposit, and indi "cated. that this is not uniformly carried out.
MOVED BY, CHERVENY, SECONDED BY ALONGI AND FAILED TO CARRY BY A VOTE
OF 2 TO 3 WITH DOMINGUEZ, WASHBURN AND WINKLER 'CASTING THE
DISSENTING VOTES FOR A SUBSIDIARY MOTION TO OFFER THE NON - PROFIT
GROUPS THE OPPORTUNITY TO USE THE 'COMMUNITY CENTER ONE TIME PER
YEAR.
THE FOREGOING MAIN MOTION TO TABLE THIS ITEM CARRIED BY A VOTE OF
3 TO 2 WITH ALONGI AND CHERVENY CASTING THE DISSENTING VOTES.
34. Proposed Cardroom Ordinance No. 969.
Mayor Washburn commented on the fact that he had received
several phone calls and letters regarding this ordinance.-'
MOVED BY WASHBURN, SECONDED BY WINKLER TO RETAIN THE EXISTING
ORDINANCE AND APPROVE ONLY-THE FEE SECTION OF ORDINANCE N0: 969.
MOVED,BY CHERVENY A SUBSIDIARY MOTION TO SEPARATE THE ORDINANCE AND
CREATE TWO ORDINANCES TO ADDRESS THE FEE,STRUCTURE AS 'A SEPARATE
ISSUE. MOTION DIED FOR LACK OF A SECOND.
Mayor Washburn explained that his motion is doing what
Councilwoman Cherveny is suggesting.
City Attorney Harper clarified the motion and stated that the
Original Cardroom Ordinance would remain in effect and the'new
ordinance would amend fees only. Mayor Washburn concurred.
Councilman' Alongi asked if this would 'increase the fees.
Mayor_Washburn stated that it would.
Mayor Washburn called on those persons who?had submitted a
request to speak as "follows:
Jack McColley, 29072 Palm View" his opposition to more
card rooms in the City. He explained that he felt that it
would place a strain on public services and'that he is not
opposed to gambling, but he is opposed to what more card rooms
can create.
Chris McColley,. 29072 Palm View, stated her opposition to an
increase in gambling facilities. . She stated -that it would
create problems for public safety and she felt that the monies
made in revenue would have to pay for the increase in law
enforcement for the casino's and would-'not truly benefit the
public.
11-EN1 NO. __Zk
. _ -�° C-
- .1--
PAGE ELEVEN - CITY COUNCIL MI I NUTES NOVEMBER 23 i 1993
Jeannine Martineau, 29042 Mango Court, stated her opposition
to more cardrooms inthe City and explained that , she felt that
it would be 6 bad image for the community as well as create
stress on Public Safety.'
Jeanie Corral, 16410 W.,Lake.shore'Dr.,,' stated' her "opposition
to an increase in cardrooms and stated' that a potential. of
more problems I in-the community were not needed.- She-stated
that the current casino is an eyesore.-' ; -1 . % 7
Raymond Corral, 16410 W., 'Lakeshore Dr.1
,opposition in regard to the-.cardroom;
stated her opposition
Sue Bowen, 167 N. Torn Ranch Road,
more cardrooms.
s*ubmitted,a letter of
to
Denise Tompkins, 218 Chaney Street, thanked Couficil-for their
.efforts in the community and'stated opposition to the proposed
increase in cardrooms. She, thanked- Council for their
cooperation and the improvements on Chaney Street.,
Leon Strigotte, 216 Chaney Street, spoke in opposition to
cardrooms and stated that he felt that the newspapers did not
do, a good job of reporting the bast history of the casino and
the problems they have had. He stated that he felt that
gambling casino's affect the quality of life in the community
and that the public should vote in a public election to decide
if they wish to have gambling in Lake Elsinore. He called for
proper policing on the existing casino..
Charles Cook, 16282 Grand Avenue,°spoke 'in opposition to an
increase in cardrooms and stated' that he felt that'it-would
create an undesirable, environment. He commented that the City
should encourage developers to do more things for the kids as
they should be the City's primary priority.
Will Buck, 29610 Hague, spoke in favor of more cardrooms in
the City and gave a brief history of the existing cakdroom and
the increase in fees. He explained the reasons why it would
profit the City and stated that the City,of Bell Gardens has
its entire budget for. police and public works supported by the
cardrooms.- He' asked that Council. -consider passage of the
existing Ordinance No. 969_
Larry Regis, 20930 Malaga Road,'explained that the-casino'iB
not- owned by, prof essional,'caBino owners, and that the new
owners are in the I process Of improving'the existing cardroom,
hotel, restaurant and party -cefiter, but it will take time. He
explained that they are not trying to avoid paying their fair
share but the new fees would stress the owners and'he asked
that,Council consider - graduating the fees-.
Councilman'Alongi stated that he felt that the card room is a
quality facility and that the new owner and management' is
Improving the existing facility to the highest quality and he
stated 'that ,Council might want to contact Captain Daniel and
check to see how many call's the Sheriff's Department receives
from the casino. Mr. Alongi commented that he enjoys the
rsportl-pf cards'and feels there is' nothing wrong with it. He
explained that the owners are, working 16n the interior and will
1-7 NO.
PAGE TWELVE - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES -,NOVEMBER 23, 1993
address improvements for the exterior next.
Councilman Dominguez stated that the casino,is good recreation
and there have been very few problems. He commented that when
he moved to Lake Elsinore there were three cardrooms and that
it was his choice to live here. He felt that it was the same
for anyone else, they,had the right to move here or not, since
there was a cardroom in existence when they bought. He stated
that in 1960 the issue was taken to the voters and they choose
to keep the cardrooms.
Councilwoman Cherveny stated her concern in regard to the fees
and explained that the owners of the casino, are investing a
lot of money to make improvements and have a quality business
in the City and she would like to see Council graduate the
fees and not create a burden on the owner.
Councilman Winkler pointed out that Council has set high
standards on any business who builds in the City and he felt
that it was only fair that this apply to all businesses. If
the Council made an exception for one, then the other
businesses would have the right to expect the same.
City Attorney Harper explained that _the motion was to exclude
everything but the fee structure.
THE FOREGOING MOTION WAS APPROVED BY THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE
ORDINANCE NO. 969
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE,
CALIFORNIA, AMENDING CHAPTER 5.28.060 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE
REGARDING FEES FOR CARD ROOMS.
AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS: ALONGI, CHERVENY, DOMINGUEZ, WINKLER,
WASHBURN
NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS: NONE
ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: NONE
ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBERS: -NONE
35. Discussion of City Election Data & Ballot Measures -
Councilwoman Cherveny. commented on the prior approval to move
the Municipal Election dates, based on the projection that it
would be a better turnout. She inquired whether the Board of
Supervisors had yet approved this change. '
City Clerk Kasad reported that based on a conversation this
date, the matter would be going before the Board of
Supervisors in approximately two weeks. She further noted
that the consensus of April Election cities appeared to be.to
accept this change.
MOVED BY CHERVENY, SECONDED IBY ALONGI TO_TABLE THIS ITEM FOR TWO
WEEKS.
Mayor Washburn offered the floor to City Treasurer Pape, who
initiated this change. Mr. Pape .deferred to the next
discussion in two weeks.
lid,
AG=hDA ITE'.ti ND.
0
PAGE THIRTEEN:- .CITY'.COUNCIL 'MINUTES.- NOVEMBER 23, 1993',
THE FOREGOING MOTION CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE
36.
_ Ocm.ectnA by
Councilman Alongi expressed concern with the recent actions to
defer Council Comments until the end of the Redevelopment
Agency Meeting, denying the Council "t.v. time. He indicated
11 j that - he would -like to see the Council !comments, remain as
i scheduled on the agenda so the Council can.get important items
out to the viewing audience. He indicated that this shift,
causes an unfair balance of Council time: He stressed. that he .
does not like to see Council Comments put - off until after the
t.v. shuts off.: He suggested that if all Councilmembers limit
!j their comments, they can all get their points across..
'I - 'Mayor Washburn indicated that this discussion has. no substance
in that it is a' procedural matter detailed in Roberts Rules of
i Order. He. clarified that movement ,of items is acceptable with.
no objections being stated. He noted-.that any Councilmember.,
has the ability to object such a shift. He stressed that
I;
Roberts-Rules is clear on this issue.
Councilman Alongi indicated that the Council does not follow
Roberts Rules because they are.not, required to.. He stressed
the Council's right-to discussion:
Mayor, Washburn. stressed :the N: procedure, apologized, for
Councilman Alongi-and declared him-to be out' of order.
I 38. Urgency- Ordinance,No. '970.°
Mayor Washburn proposed additional of Urgency Ordinance No.
970 relating to fire clearance.:in spite'of K -Rat habitat, be `r
added to this agenda,
MOVED BY DOMINGUEZ,`SECONDED BY WASHBURN'AND;CARRIED,BY UNANIMOUS
VOTE` -TO ADD THIS ITEM TO THE AGENDA.. _.
Mayor Washburn indicated that the Riverside County Habitat
Conservation Agency had requested .that- this ordinance be
brought :forward to all impacted agencies for approval.: .He.._
explained, that it., would allow'_for fire clearance around
structures to prevent concerns which arose during the recent..
I fires:
j MOVED BY CHERVENY, SECONDED BY, ALONGI TO .'ADOPT ORDINANCE NO. 970
AND'DIRECT,THE CITY CLERK TO TRANSMIT.TO.BRIAN LOEW AT THE.RCHCA:
ORDINANCE NO. 970
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL` OF THE. CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE,.
CALIFORNIA, PERMITTING CLEARING OF BRUSH FOR FIRE PROTECTION,
PURPOSES.
UPON THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE:
AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS:. ALONGI; CHERVENY, DOMINGUEZ WINKLER,
WASHBURN
pGERDA ITEM', t:0._ -= �-�y-
PA_=la OF1-Y
PAGE FOURTEEN - CITY COUNCIL.MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993
NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS': NONE
ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: NONE
ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBERS: NONE
PUBLIC COMMENTS - NON - AGENDIZED ITEMS
Catherine-Creech, 29880 Hursh, commented on law enforcement and a
recent occurrence of shots being fired at her home. She expressed
concern with the response time of approximately 20 minutes, and
noted a previous occurrence, for which the response time was one
hour and 40 minutes. She indicated that she was pleased with the
passage of Proposition 172 and supported its use of additional law
enforcement.
Ray Creech; 29880 Hursh, further commented on the incident which
occurred at his home and stressed the importance of residents being
aware of and prepared for this type of incident. He stressed the
need for a few more officers.
Mayor Washburn expressed his condolences and understanding of this
situation.
Chris Hyland, 15191 Wavecrest; indicated that while she is happy
the Stadium has sold over 1,000 seats, but questioned why the City
had reserved 100 seats and other comments relating to the sale of
tickets. She indicated that based on the.comments she has heard,
she would be expecting her two front row, team side tickets for the
cost of sales tax only. She indicated that based on the responses
she has received from the Baseball Team General Manager and the
City Manager, someone is lying.
Nido Ryal, 223 Chaney Street, commented on the proposed Chaney
Street improvements. He expressed concern that they are being done
based on cost rather than safety. He further expressed concern
with the proposed removal of the guard rail adjacent to his home
and reminded the Council of the accident that occurred.there in
1989.
Richard Bullard, representing Classic Western Productions,
commented on the recent Sierra Circuit Rodeo presented by .that
organization. He thanked the City, the Chamber of Commerce, the
Fire Department, the School District, the Elks and all other
volunteers for their support of this event. He noted the increased
revenues the event drew to the community through its restaurants,
hotels and stores. He stressed the organizations efforts to bring
a positive name to the community and expressed concern that not
more of the community was present to support the event.
CITY MANAGER COMMENTS
City Manager Molendyk commented on pending workshop topics and
indicated that the School District would also like a joint workshop
to look at goals and projects.
CITY COUNCIL COMMENTS
Councilwoman Cherveny commented on the following:
1) Announced that S.S. Burger Basket would again be serving
AGENDA ITEM NO. �
PAu OF_Z_Z_
PAGE FIFTEEN CITY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 23, 1993
Turkey Dinner for the needy bn Thanksgiving Day from 11
a.m.,to 4 p.m.
2) 'Would like more information'on'the Citizen's Crime Watch
Committee; is curious based on t.v. advertisement.
3) Winterfest event, children will have an opportunity to
see Santa at this event as well as at AlbertsonB1 Stater
Bros., etc r'
4) Receipt of copy of M.R.C. report on*the sales tax audit;
they found $11,865 in new taxes,, projected to reach
$41,250 next quarter.
s) Attendance at Senior Center Bazaar; many' groups were
participating.. Advised that despite a flier distributed
the Golden Spectrum organization is alive and well.
A.
6) Noted letter from Debbie Kramer regarding Little League
boundaries•. Suggested that the issue be researched to
prevent children being.excluded.
7) Received a call from a gentleman furious with City Hall,
because the parents of soccer players at Terra Cotta'Paik
_received parking tickets. Need to look at providing
adequate parking. "Councilman Winkle�i stressed the danger
of parking on,the street in this area.
8) Noted letter from Debbie Renfrow regarding cancellation
of the Christmas Parade She indicated that she ',would
like to Bee this budgeted and scheduled again next year.
9) Announced the H.O.P.E. food and toy drive for Christmas,
as well as the Christmas party scheduled for December
17th.
10) Delinquent trash bills" expressed4conceirn with the letter
sent.out - through the City.. CR & R, should be handling
billing... She expressed concern with the City harassing
the residents for payment and indicated that CR & R
should be obligated--Ito-handle it.
JI) Not6d'that she attended the Sierra Circuit Rodeo.
Councilman Winkler commented on the following:
1) So ccer field use and'parkingat Terra Cotta; noting that
there is additional adequate 'parking JW the school
parking lot. He stressed the danger caused by limited
visibility for cars turning left on to Grand Avenue and
children in the area of the cars parked along the curb.
He requested that the City-Manager contact the School
Board representatives to address thi's issue.' noting that
informal discussions , have already occurred with
Boardmembers.
2) McVicker Park, when will construction be City
,gin?
I Manager- Molendyk indicated that the- Council would be
receiving a memo ' on this item, but the project is
underway.
let,
AGENDA ITEW. 1,40—
PA OF-L2—
PAGE SIXTEEN - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993
3) Amber Ridge is close to receiving sewers. Bids are out
and expected to be opened soon.
4) Noted that he bought season tickets for the Stadium at
full price. Questioned the comments about special deals
being given.
Councilman Alongi commented on the following:
1) Will reserve some comments for Councilman Winkler, the
Sun Tribune and the Chamber of Commerce because the
meeting is not being televised.
2) Sierra Circuit Rodeo, stressed the importance of non-
profit organizations working together. He stressed the
existence of. Rodeo Grounds and expressed concern with the
non - cooperation of the chamber.. He noted that this Rodeo
could have made a.profit if the Rodeo Grounds had been
made available.
3) Mr. Creech, indicated that this incident possibly could
have been prevented. He stressed the need to listen to
the experts and go forward.
Mayor Pro Tem Dominguez commented on the following:
1) Reminded the Community.to participate in Winterfest.
2) Noted that he also bought season tickets.
Mayor Washburn commented on the following:,
1) Efforts of S.S. Burger Basket to serve Thanksgiving
Dinner. Requested recognition, of. -them at the next
meeting.
2) Announced that Miss Lake Elsinore, Shannon Hughes was
named Princess at the.Indio Date Festival.
3) Concerns with -the media. Indicated that he is disturbed
with Councilman Alongi's. press conference. Mr. Alongi
indicated that this was an' interview requested -by the
press. Mayor Washburn expressed further concern with
the press, and their comments regarding the locations
where crimes occur. He' stressed that many incidents
reported in the City actually occur in. Sedco Hills,
Wildomar or other unincorporated areas. He expressed
concern with the impact of these items on the economics
of the community.
4). Classic Western Productions; Rodeo, concurred it is an
important event to draw people to the community, but
expressed concern with the comments that it was the
Chamber' s, fault they lost money. He stated that Classic
Western was offered the use of the facility for $5,000.
He suggested that possibly a compromise could have been
reached.
5) Requested that the City Attorney .draft a policy 'for
agendizing items. He indicated that he feels 'a misuse is
occurring and the existing policy is not sufficient.
AQEtZA ITEM NO /�
PAGE SEVENTEEN - CITY COUNCIL MINUTES - NOVEMBER 23, 1993
CLOSED SESSION
None.
MOVED BY WASHBURN, SECONDED BY ALONGI AND CARRIED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE
TO ADJOURN THE REGULAR CITY COUNCIL MEETING AT 10:09 P.M.
ATTEST:
VICKI KASAD, CITY CLERK
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
GARY M. WASHBURN, MAYOR
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
AGENDA IiE;.' I /�
I I