HomeMy WebLinkAbout04/11/2007 PSAC Reports
~
-0
"
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION
AGENDA
RON HEWJSON, CHAIRMAN
RAY KNIGHT, VICE CHAIRMAN
DR. SHAWN BHUTTA, COMMISSIONER
VALERIE SUND, COMMISSIONER
MIKE NORKIN, COMMISSIONER
ROBERT BRADY, CITY MANAGER
WWW.LAKE.ELSINORE.ORG
(951) 674.3124 PHONE
(951)674.2392 FAX
LAKE ELSINORE CULTURAL CENTER
183 NORTH MAIN STREET
LAKE ELSINORE, CA 92530
APRIL 11,2007
6:00 PM
If you are attending this Public Safety Advisory Commission Meeting, please
park in the Parking Lot across the streetfrom the Cultural Center. This will
assist us in limiting the impact of meetings on the Downtown Business District.
Thank you for your cooperation!
CALL TO ORDER
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
ROLL CALL
PUBLIC COMMENTS
Any person wishing to address the Public Safety Advisory Commission on any
matter must complete a request form prior to commencement of the meeting.
(Comments limited to 3 minutes).
CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS
All matters on the Consent Calendar are approved in one motion, unless a
Commissioner or any member of the public requests separate action on a
specific action.
"
~
PAGE 2
PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION AGENDA
APRIL 11, 2007
1. Minutes
a. Wednesday, March 14,2007 Regular Meeting
BUSINESS ITEMS
21. Presentation: Anti-Gang Task Force (LEPD)
RECOMMENDATION: Information for PSAC discussion.
22. Presentation: Lake Patrol Update (LEPD)
RECOMMENDATION: Information for PSAC discussion.
23. Status Report for Shoreline Zone Identification Signage and Channeling
of Visitors to Controlled Access Points
RECOMMENDATION: Receive and File.
24. Public Outreach Schedule: PSAC Recommended Activities
RECOMMENDATION: Receive and File.
PUBLIC SAFETY SUBCOMMITTEE REPORTS
CITY STAFF COMMENTS
PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS
ADJOURNMENT
~
MINUTES
PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION
MEETING
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
183 NORTH MAIN STREET
LAKE ELSINORE, CALIFORNIA
WEDNESDAY, MARCH 14,2007
****************************************************************
CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Hewison called the Public Safety Advisory Commission Meeting
to order at 6:00 p.m.
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Vice Chairman Knight.
ROLL CALL
PRESENT:
COMMISSIONERS: KNIGHT, NORKIN, SUND,
BHUTT A, HEWISON
ABSENT:
COMMISSIONERS: NONE
Also present were: Information/Communications Manager Dennis, Legal
Counsel Mann, Code Enforcement Supervisor Romero, Sergeant Yates,
Fire Chief Hendershot and Office Specialist Herrington.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
None
CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS
1. February 14,2007 Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes.
-Page 2 - Public Safety Advisory Commission - March 14,2007
MOVED BY NORKIN SECONDED BY KNIGHT AND CARRIED BY A
UNANIMOUS VOTE TO APPROVE THE CONSENT CALENDAR AS
PRESENTED.
BUSINESS ITEMS
21. Graffiti Ordinance L.E.M.C. Chapter 9.52 amendments.
Information/Communications Manager Dennis indicated that the item
was a request to review the draft graffiti ordinance and to address
Commission's issues and concerns.
Chairman Hewison stated that he would like to recommend a sub-
committee to work with staff. He reviewed and discussed the changes
that have been made and requested comments from the other
departments.
Code Enforcement Supervisor Romero discussed the fines for
administrative and nuisance and suggested amending Section 8.18 of
the ordinance.
Commissioner Bhutta discussed the use of a graffiti camp where they
educate the youth on graffiti and how everyone can do their part. He
also discussed the use of a paint bank and art competition for the
youth artist.
Commissioner Norkin requested clarification on how many businesses
there are in the area that sells paint products.
Information/Communications Manager Dennis indicated that staff had
not conducted a survey for the area, but it could be added that into the
Commission's recommendations.
MOVED BY NORKIN, SECONDED BY KNIGHT AND CARRIED BY A
UNANIMOUS VOTE TO APPROVE THE GRAFFITI ORDINANCE
L.E.M.C. CHAPTER 9.52 AMENDMENTS.
22. Fireworks Ordinance (LEMC 8.52) with final proposed amendment
incorporating County Ordinance No. 858.
"Page 3 - Public Safety Advisory Commission - March 14,2007
Chairman Hewison requested that Legal Counsel Mann review his
suggestions with the Commission.
Legal Counsel Mann indicated that the ordinance was very well
written. He recommended adopting with the exception of a few
changes to the liability language.
Commissioner Norkin requested an example of what would be a more
strict liability.
Legal Counsel Mann indicated that strict liability requires the law
enforcement agency to use judgment.
Commissioner Bhutta inquired how the public could be educated on
the amended ordinance.
Information/Communications Manager Dennis suggested printing up
a marketing brochure.
Commissioner Sund suggested advertising on billboards to educate
the public.
Chairman Hewison asked Legal Counsel Mann if we want to show the
changes to a specific year.
Legal Counsel Mann suggested using the wording to state "recently".
Commissioner Norkin asked Information/Communications Manager
Dennis if the information would be published in the quarterly City
Outlook.
Information/Communications Manager Dennis indicated that in order
for the information to get out to the public in an efficient and timely
manner, the amended graffiti ordinance and fire works ordinance
would be printed in the City Outlook as well as direct mail.
'Page 4 - Public Safety Advisory Commission - March 14,2007
MOVED BY BHUTT A, SECOND BY KNIGHT AND APPROVED BY A
UNANIMOUS VOTE TO DIRECT LEGAL COUNSEL TO FINALIZE
THE CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT TO INCLUDE THE
COMMENTS FROM THIS MEETING AND PROPOSED ORDINANCE
AMENDMENT, L.E.M.C. CHAPTER 8.52.010, FIREWORKS, FOR
CITY COUNCIL CONSIDERATION AT THE REGULAR MEETING
OF MARCH 27, 2007.
23. Preparation of the PSAC Annual Report for year 2006.
Information/Communications Manager Dennis stated that it was the
Public Safety Advisory Commissions practice to provide to the City
Council a summary of the actions of taken for the calendar year. He
indicated that a draft of the summary had been prepared and would be
presented to the Council on March 27, 2007. He asked the
Commission if they had any comments.
Vice Chairman Knight indicated that the Commission had done a
good job.
Chairman Hewison suggested adding the joint study session count to
the report, and to provide Commissioner Bhutta copies of reports on
public safety on the lake and shoreline.
MOVED BY NORKIN, SECONDED BY KNIGHT AND CARRIED BY A
UNANIMOUS VOTE TO DIRECT STAFF TO FINALIZE ANNUAL
PSAC REPORT FOR CITY COUNCIL CONSIDERATION AT THE
REGULAR MEETING OF MARCH 27, 2007.
INFORMATIONAL ITEMS
None.
SUBCOMMITTEE REPORTS
None.
"Page 5 - Public Safety Advisory Commission - March 14,2007
CITY STAFF COMMENTS
Information/Communications Manager Dennis commented on the
following:
1) Advised the Commission on the upcoming schedule for the Sub-
Committee.
2) The upcoming PSAC recruiting in July 2007.
3) Live-Scan forms for the Commission.
4) March 27,2007 regular City Council Meeting.
5) Welcomed Dr. Bhutta to the Commission.
COMMISSIONER COMMENTS
Commissioner Norkin commented on the following:
1) Pleased with the amended graffiti ordinance.
2) Spoke on educating the citizens of the new and revised ordinances.
3) Recommended to put on the April PSAC Agenda a presentation of the
lake patrol.
Commissioner Sund commented on the following:
1) Welcomed Dr. Bhutta to the Commission.
2) Requested information on when the new shirts with the new City logo
would be available.
3) Requested information on when the new City brochures would be
available.
4) Spoke of the dedication of Serenity Park.
5) Spokeofthe PT A talent show and would be raffling off an electric
guitar.
Vice-Chairman Knight commented on the following:
1) Spoke of the good work on the ordinances.
Commissioner Bhutta commented on the following:
1) Looking forward to working with the PSAC.
'-,
'Page 6 - Public Safety Advisory Commission - March 14,2007
Chairman Hewison commented on the following:
1) Spoke of the recruitment of the new PSAC members.
2) Indicated that he reduced the minutes of the meeting on the Lake
Safety to bullet points.
3) Would like a lake briefing at the next PSAC Meeting.
4) Would like the Commission to think about other safety issues for the
next month.
ADJOURNMENT
THE PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION MEETING WAS
ADJOURNED AT 7:05 P.M.
RON HEWISON, CHAIRMAN
PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION
Respectfully submitted,
DANA PORCHE', OFFICE SPECIALIST
Attest:
MICHELLE SOTO, DEPUTY CLERK OF THE BOARD
-,
,
Editions of the North County Times Serving San Diego and Riverside Counties
Thursday, March 29, 2007 Contact Us
om
~o@e.QC
Scmd News . 1lIog. AN Modln Subscribe Calcn<lar Hom.. Job
News Search
Home News
Subscribe
Web Search Classified Search Advertising Home Delivery
Sports Business Opinion Entertainment
Previous Issues Letters Obituaries
Reader Services Traffic Stockl
Features Columnists Cor
Place An Ad Send Feet
I... print page ... 1
Thursday, March 29, 2007
Last modified Wednesday, March 28, 2007 11:23 PM PDT
City adopts new graffiti ordinance
By: The Californian -
LAKE ELSINORE ---- City officials have a new tool in dealing with graffiti.
The City Council voted unanimously Tuesday to adopt a far-reaching graffiti ordinance that
increases penalties on vandals, ups the reward for tipsters and sets strict requirements for
businesses that sell items commonly used by vandals.
The harsher punishments included in the ordinance include making vandals ._-. or their parents, in the case of
minors ---- liable for up to $25,000 in penalties and calis for the possible suspension of their driver's licenses.
It also raises to $1,000 the amount tipsters could be rewarded for providing information that leads to the arrest
and successful prosecution of vandals and requires the city to set up a graffiti hotline for residents to call and
report graffiti.
On the retail end, the ordinance also places a higher burden on businesses to make sure they aren't selling
vandals the materials they use. The ordinance forces businesses to record the names, addresses and driver's
license numbers of anyone who buys three or more cans of spray paint.
Approval of the ordinance was recommended by the Public Safety Advisory Commission, which crafted the new
set of laws over the last eight months. The commission took up the cause shortly after vandals went on a graffiti
spree and plastered hate symbols throughout a south Lake Elsinore neighborhood.
The ordinance won't go into effect until 30 days after a second reading occurs at a council meeting. That reading
is tentatively scheduled for the April 10 meeting.
http://www.nctimes.com/artic1es/2007 /03/29/news/califomianllake _ elsinore/28 _ 54 _ 283_2... 3/29/2007
.: Print Version:.
Page 1 of2
Editions of the North County Times Serving San Diego and Riverside Counties
Thursday, March 15, 2007 Contact Us
~
.om
~oom(Ol';:r\ 'i1'll:S'
-- ~
~O@)av.~C
Sone! Howl Blogl AN Modia Subocrlbo Calendar HOI1le1; Job
~W,~\lIHl!i~I!~'-: ~
News Search
Home News
Subscribe
Web Search Classified Search Advertising Home Delivery
Sports Business Opinion Entertainment
Previous Issues Letters Obituaries
Reader Services Traffic Stock.
Features Columnists Cor
Place An Ad Send Feec
I. Print Page I
Thursday, March 15,2007
Last modified Wednesday, March 14,20079:43 PM PDT
Commission approves graffiti ordinance
By: JOSE CARVAJAL - Staff Writer
LAKE ELSINORE -- Vandals would face far stiffer penalties, including fines as high as
$25,000 and the possible suspension of their driver's licenses, under a beefed-up graffiti
ordinance approved Wednesday by the city's Public Safety Advisory Commission.
The commission voted unanimously to approve the ordinance, which goes to the City Council
for final approval. The council is likely to take up the matter March 27, city officials said.
Approval of the graffiti laws marks the third time in the last 14 months the commission has forwarded to the City
Council recommendations on updating and strengthening sections of the city's Municipal Code. Last year, the
council adopted new ordinances governing large parties and oversized vehicle parking.
The commission's effort to update the graffiti laws began in July, shortly after vandals went on a spree and left
Nazi-style swastikas and other hate symbols painted throughout a south Lake Elsinore neighborhood.
Throughout the eight-month process, city officials have tried to paint a picture of the extent of the graffiti problem,
for which Lake Elsinore budgets $90,000 a year to address. Last week alone, a city crew removed graffiti from
83 locations.
"I think it's a wonderful thing that we just accomplished," commission member Ray Knight said after the panel's
vote on the ordinance.
I
I
.1
Ii
"
The proposed laws increase financial penalties to as much as $25,000 for vandals and provide the possibility of
their driver's licenses being suspended. They also call for community service as another punishment and allow
the city to hold parents responsible for the actions of their children.
"I'm particularly pleased with the punishments," commission Chairman Ron Hewison said before the vote. "If I
was a kid, I wouldn't want to be doing any of it."
Along with increasing penalties, the ordinance raises to $1,000 the amount tipsters could be rewarded for
providing information that leads to the arrest and successful prosecution of vandals and requires the city to set
up a graffiti hotline for residents to call and report graffiti.
The ordinance also places a higher burden on businesses to make sure they aren't selling vandals the materials
they use. The ordinance would force businesses to record the names, addresses and driver's license numbers of
anybody who buys three or more cans of spray paint.
While commission members said they were proud of the ordinance they were forwarding to the council, they also
said that the city has to go on an education campaign once the council adopts it. The city has to get the word out
that penalties have been increased to deter people from vandalizing, members said.
http://www.nctimes.com/articles!2007 /03/15/news/californian/4 _03_323_14_07 .prt
3/15/2007
.: Print Version:.
Page 2 of2
"Whatever it takes, we have to get it out there," Commissioner Mike Norkin said. "We can do all this stuff, but it
won't matter if nobody knows about i!."
- Contact staff writer Jose Carvajal at (951) 676-4315, Ex!. 2624, or jcarvajal@californian.com.
http://www.nctimes.comlarticles/2007/03/15/news/califomian/4_ 03 _ 323 _14 _07 .prt
3/1512007
Editorials I PE.com I Southern California News I News for Inland Southern California
Page I of I
PEo'c~~llll'.l\\I'\
E,~'CJIoria",,1Il 'I'"
, , S
",..... , ...., ." "....
~.' .." ... ......:." -. -.- -" ... -. ""."
, ,
Thwarting taggers
10:00 PM PDT on Thursday, March IS, 2007
Graffiti is a public nuisance and a blight along Inland highways. California legislators should give local
prosecutors broader authority to charge frequent taggers.
Tough consequences would help suppress chronic vandalism. Staking out popular freeway overpasses
has helped police catch some vandals in the act. But law enforcement officials in Riverside and San
Bernardino counties who arrest taggers say that light penalties, such as $50 fines for misdemeanors, do
little to discourage repeat offenders.
AB 1628 by Sharon Runner, R-Lancaster, would let district attorneys file felony charges based on the
total amount of damage a vandal does. So instead of charging a prolific tagger with a dozen
misdemeanors, for example, local authorities could pursue felony charges that include fines of up to
$1,000 and possible jail time. The Legislature would do well to pass the bill.
Deterrence and robust enforcement are more cost-effective for taxpayers than cleaning up vandals' work
after the fact. Locally, Caltrans District 8 spent $401,000 in the 2005-06 fiscal year to scrape graffiti
from Riverside and San Bernardino county freeway soundwalls and signs. This fiscal year, the agency
has spent $324,000 to remove vandalism.
But graffiti's costs are not just fmancial: Tagging tarnishes the area's image. And recurring vandalism
along Highway 91 and interstates 10 and 215 can leave visitors with a poor impression of the Inland
region. As Riverside Mayor Ron Loveridge said in 2005: "We used to drive down Main Street and get a
sense of what towns and cities were all about. ... (Now), you drive the freeways."
http://www.pe.comllocalnews/opinionleditorials/storiesIPE _OpEd_Opinion _ H _ op _16 _ed _'" 3/16/2007
.: Print Version:.
'"
Page 1 of2
~
:;.;..
Editions of the North County Times Serving San Diego and Riverside Counties
Monday, March 19. 2007 Contact Us
~.....,.
.. ,om
CiO@..QC
Send Nows BIog. AN Modla SUbscribe Calendar _ Job
. _'nll G-'LII{lRl;I."",-
News Search
Home News
Subscribe
Web Search Classified Search Advertising Home Delivery Reader Services Traffic Stock,
Sports Business Opinion Entertainment Features Columnists Cor
Previous Issues Letters Obituaries Place An Ad Send Feet
LJ)rintP~g~..... I
Monday, March 19,2007
Last modified Thursday, March 15, 2007 10:07 PM PDT
Roses & raspberries
By: The Californian Opinion Staff -
A raspberry ---- the "Cease and Desist" award ---- to the University of Nevada-Reno for a
prickly sense of proprietorship over one of the most common sports mascot names in the
country. The university sent a letter to Great Oak High School in Temecula last year, asking
the school to quit using its Wolfpack logo featuring three snarling wolf heads, because it is
very similar to the university's single-snarling-wolf-head logo.
University officials are just trying to protect their trademark rights, says one representative of
the Collegiate Licensing Company, which is representing the university in the matter.
Oh, please. Are the images similar? Yes. But it's not like it's a duplicate, and it's not like Nevada picked a unique
team mascot like a desert tortoise, or the infamous banana slug of UC Santa Cruz. They chose one of the most
common team nicknames around after Wildcats and Eagles. Did they think they suddenly had a right to any and
all images associated with it, too?
Great Oak is hardly a threat to the University of Nevada's vast merchandising profits. It's not too late for the
university to reconsider this petty assault on common sense.
A rose ---- the "Seeing the Light" award ---- to the Lake Elsinore Public Safety Advisory Commission for
reconsidering a plan to tax either businesses or legitimate customers buying spray paint in order to pay for graffiti
removal. After giving consideration to just such a measure earlier this year, the city's Public Safety Advisory
Commission passed an ordinance Wednesday night that put the onus where it belonged: on the vandals who
use these legitimate products to deface public and private property.
The measure, which still has to be approved by the City Council, would increase financial penalties for vandals
and rewards for tips. While it would require businesses to keep records of who buys more than three cans of
spray paint, it wisely drops the idea of further taxing either buyers or businesses.
It's understandable that the city would want to try to recoup the growing costs of eradicating graffiti, which hit
$90,000 last year. But as long as spray paint and paint pens are legal and have legitimate uses, businesses that
sell them responsibly ---- that means keeping them locked and not selling them to minors ---- should not be
penalized for selling them. Nor should consumers have to pay extra because some people abuse them.
A raspberry ---- the "Stretching the Definition" award ---- to Riverside County for the somewhat tortured logic put
forth in justifying an emergency ban on billboards in the Mission Trail area of Wildomar. Nothing against the ban
itself ---- there are plenty of billboards trashing the landscape in Southwest County already ---- but the county
apparently got caught with its pants down when a billboard company applied to put one up where county officials
have been looking for two years at changing the zoning that now allows them.
http://www.nctimes.com/artic1es/2007 /03/16/opinionleditorialscaI/21_ 45_433_15_ 07.prt
3/19/2007
.: Print Version :.
"
Page 2 of2
Since such a change takes a while to put in place under normal procedures, the county decided it needed to
adopt an interim moratorium while it fixed the problem. But such short-term bans require a declaration of an
emergency that in tum requires a finding that the public "health, safety and welfare" is threatened by whatever is
being sought.
Billboards may well be eyesores, but unless one is about to fall over, it's hard to justify calling it threat to the
public health, safety or welfare. Such reasoning may seem harmless enough to many if the end is justifiable, but
every time government officials stretch the truth as a means to an end, the public trust in government becomes a
little more frayed.
If the county had wanted Mission Trail to be a billboard-free zone, it has had years to change the zoning. Its own
failure to do its job is no excuse for playing fast and loose with the rules.
http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2007 /03/16/opinionleditorialscal/21_ 45_433_15_ 07.prt
3/19/2007
ILETTERS1
I . .. I
I THE CAuroRNIAN
l-.
c-u
r
I
i SUNDAY, MARCH 18,2007
170 ~udos on
I graffiti law .
,
\
\
\
)OJ
i
I
i
I
I
Tina 1Yra
Wildomar
-----~
.: Print Version:.
Page 1 of2
Editions of the North County Times Serving San Diego and Riverside Counties
Thursday, March 22. 2007 Contact Us
...
~om
News Search
Home News
Subscribe
<I@iPO.QC
Send Nows Blags AN Modi. Subscribe Calendar _ Job
Web Search Classified Search Advertising Home Delivery Reader Services Traffic Stock,
Sports Business Opinion Entertainment Features Columnists Cor
Previous Issues Letters Obituaries Place An Ad Send Feec
~:, '1}1~~~~B!i'B01,~~ ~I
[.printPag~1
Thursday, March 22, 2007
Last modified Thursday, March 22, 2007 12:02 AM PDT
Board delays budget request for anti-gang unit
By: CHRIS BAGLEY - Staff Writer
LAKE ELSINORE -- Riverside County financial managers are looking for ways to beef up anti-
gang operations after the county's governing board put off a rare midyear request for more
funding.
District Attorney Rod Pacheco and Sheriff Bob Doyle have asked the county's Board of
Supervisors for $344,000 they say is necessary to obtain software and equipment and hire
deputies for the remaining three months of the fiscal year ending June 30.
A divided board put off the request until mid-April, with two supervisors objecting to what they called a piecemeal
approach.
Pacheco and Doyle said they're making the request because the county's gang task force has understaffed units
in Lake Elsinore and Jurupa Valley. Those two teams have four sheriffs deputies each, compared with six
deputies each in other units throughout the county, authorities said.
"The work, unfortunately, is not done," Pacheco tOld the board. "Quite frankly, those teams are currently unsafe."
Bill Luna, finance director for the county's executive office, said he plans to meet with Doyle or deputies in
coming weeks to discuss the possibility of covering part or all of the request.
Doyle and Pacheco's predecessor, Grover Trask, launched the program early last year with support from cities
and their police departments.
Supervisors Bob Buster, whose district includes Lake Elsinore and parts of Riverside, and Roy Wilson, who
represents Palm Springs and points east, said piecemeal hiring might lead to additional arrests of gang members
and perhaps even convictions, but would prove ineffectual without new jail space for convicts.
Buster said he found it "disturbing" that law enforcement leaders hadn't notified him of difficulties in Lake Elsinore
before Tuesday's meeting.
Lake Elsinore Mayor Bob Magee said he's still waiting for Pacheco to brief the City Council on the task force's
activities, a condition that the city set in agreeing to provide extra funding for anti-gang operations in its area.
Magee said he agrees with the idea of hiring more deputies and investigators, but won't support it until he gets
more details.
The county recently declared its top construction priority to be a new jail. The board should hold off on Pacheco's
and Doyle's request until June, when it begins to make spending decisions for the coming fiscal year, which
begins in July, Buster and Wilson said.
http://www.nctimes.comlarticles/2007 /03/22/news/californian/4 _01_003_21_07 .prt
3/22/2007
.: Print Version:.
Page 2 of2
'We can arrest every gang member we can find, but if we can't keep them in prison, we're going to have to throw
them back on the street," Wilson said. .
Plans now call for a $255 million jail to be built somewhere within a few miles of Highway 60, providing space for
some 1,200 new inmates by 2012 and an additional 600 by 2014.
Pacheco and Doyle also requested $1.1 million a year so that the gang task force can hire eight new people and
provide them with vehicles and other support equipment. The new hires would include four investigators and an
analyst for the district attorney's office; it would provide two deputies and an analyst for the Sheriffs Department,
according to a memo Pacheco and Doyle submitted to supervisors.
The immediate $344,000 request would allow the two departments to fill some of those positions and provide
additional equipment, including patrol cars and computer hardware that would run a state-level database of gang
members, dubbed "CALGANG." The counties of San Diego, Los Angeles and San Bernardino have such nodes
to run CALGANG, but Riverside does not, authorities said. The two new analysts would monitor the database for
local gang activity.
Supervisors Jeff Stone, whose district includes most of Southwest Riverside County, and Marion Ashley, whose
district includes Moreno Valley and Banning, said they supported the immediate spending. Supervisor John
Tavaglione was absent.
"Let's not say we're not going to fund this because it came at the wrong budget time," Stone said Tuesday. "This
is a small price to pay for the added benefit from these positions."
Luna, Doyle and Pacheco could return to discuss the matter with supervisors again next week. Luna said he
expects to discuss Doyle's and Pacheco's request with them in the weeks ahead in hopes of finding some sort of
compromise.
County officials said they also hope to relieve strain on the gang task force by persuading police departments in
Desert Hot Springs and Palm Springs to reassign officers to it. Those two departments have withdrawn officers
from the task force to patrol the streets of their own cities.
A decision by supervisors could come April 10 or April 17, when all five plan to be in town. By then, any interim
hirings would cover only the 10 or 11 weeks before the next fiscal year begins.
'When we come back in mid-April, we're six weeks away from 'budget hearings," Luna said.
-- Contact staff writer Chris Bagley at (951) 676-4315, Ext. 2615, or cbagley@californian.com.
http://www.nctimes.comlarticlesI2007/03/22/news/californianl4 _01_003_21_07 .prt
3/2212007
.: Print Version:.
Page 1 of 1
Editions of the North County Times Serving San Diego and Riverside Counties
Thursday. March 29. 2007 Contact Us
News Search
Home News
Subscribe
,om s.n~ ! ~I' S!bo ct, ~ ~
Web Search Classified Search . Advertising Home Delivery Reader Services Traffic Stockl
Sports Business Opinion Entertainment Features Columnists Cor
Previous Issues Letters Obituaries Place An Ad Send Feec
[print Page]
Thursday, March 29, 2007
Last modified Wednesday, March 28, 200711:23 PM PDT
Board OKs anti-gang staff
By: CHRIS BAGLEY - Staff Writer
LAKE ELSINORE ---- Riverside County's governing board gave law enforcers a go-ahead to
beef up an anti-gang task force in two short-staffed areas, while directing the sheriff and the
local district attorney to cover the short-term costs.
The 4-0 vote by the Board of Supervisors on Tuesday morning allows the Sheriff's
Department to hire one deputy each in Jurupa Valley and Lake Elsinore. Four deputies now
serve in each of those two branches of the task force.
The vote also clears the hiring of two investigators in the district attorney's office and an analyst in each of the
two agencies. Sheriff Bob Doyle and District Attorney Rod Pacheco had requested those six positions and two
others, and the funds to cover all eight through June 30, when the current fiscal year ends.
The two agency leaders, who are elected directly by voters, had asked supervisors for $344,000 to cover the
eight positions and a range of computer hardware, software and other equipment. But the mid-year request
didn't come to a vote, with a divided board appearing unlikely to muster the four-fifths majority needed to
authorize it. Supervisors said Tuesday that they expect Pacheco and Doyle to cover the spending with funds
they have already received.
Supervisors Roy Wilson and Bob Buster objected to what they called "piecemeal" funding. The county is now
trying to fund construction of a new prison to accommodate a growing population of convicts. Arresting and
prosecuting gang members is of little value unless they can be jailed, the two supervisors said.
John Tavaglione, who missed last week's meeting, seemed sympathetic to their concerns. He praised the
"compromise" Tuesday as preserving a policy of reviewing all budget requests together, in June.
"We have that policy for a purpose, so we can balance all the needs of a big county," Tavaglione said. "We have
always had needs and continued to support needs in ... all our public safety agencies."
-- Contact staff writer Chris Bagley at (951) 676-4315, Ext. 2615, or cbagley@californian.com.
http://www.nctimes.com/articIes/2007 /03/29/news/califomian/lake _ elsinore/18 _52_533_2... 3/29/2007
StQIY Printed From The Friday Flyer
Page I of2
a,THE FRIDAV FLVER
.
March 16. 2007
School Daze: Gang task force
By Jeanie Corral
Reporter/Columnist
news@goldingpublications.com
Gangs. The mere mention of the word can bring feelings of stress, fear,
misunderstanding and anger to most parents of school age children.
Do we have gangs in our midst? At school? In the community? And, if
we do, how can we counteract their influence?
A recent parent workshop on gang awareness in the schools points out
that in the Lake Elsinore Unified School District there are indeed street gangs that are alive
and well.
According to Riverside County's Lt. Bob Peoples of the gang task force, in recent months
there were some 660 officers who came to do sweeps in the four counties of Orange,
Riverside, Los Angeles and San Diego that netted 47 offenders.
Parents and local educators watched, listened and asked questions about what can be done
to protect children from the effects of gang life styles that are so prominently glamorized by
video games, movies and other popular culture icons.
Bob told parents that they "are the eyes and ears" for the community at large and if they
suspect their children are flirting with the idea of becoming gang members, communication
and quick action can mean the difference between life and death, literally.
"Gang members end up in one of two ways: incarcerated or dead," he states.
Local gangs in the area such as the Elsinore Young Classics, which began as a car club and
has evolved as the most active and violent gang, or the Vatos Locos (Crazy Bats) have been
around for more than 25 years. Other gangs such as the Four Corners Hustlers and the
Yarborough Park Crips are still relatively new in terms of time.
The OCP (Out Causing Panic) group has had more than 60 members arrested and more
than 500 identified members in the area.
Many people who see the graffiti on walls, buildings or billboards often have no idea what is
being expressed. Often people feel graffiti is simply an offshoot of those who are disenchanted
with life; but according to the task force, all graffiti has messages that warn other gangs
about territories or directly threaten harm. Many graffiti artists can demonstrate proficiency in
their use of color and drawing skills but the overall message of graffiti is that a gang is trying
to come into an area and wants to intimidate the residents.
Gangs come In all shapes, sizes and age levels. They are not the exclusive purview of ethnic
groups and are usually born out of cultural poverty. There are white supremacy gangs, gangs
of mixed ethnic backgrounds, prison gangs and street gangs. But all gangs adhere to a
criminal culture that puts allegiance to them first, above religion, family relationships,
friendship and most assuredly the law.
Colors and clothing often denote a gang attitude, and those unaware of what such colors or
clothing mean to gang members can be in for trouble.
According to the gang suppression task force, parents must be involved directly with their
children in such a way that they can prevent youngsters from being lulled into a sense that a
gang "isn't such a bad thing." Those who become gang members are never released without
great pain and ongoing fear for the lives of their loved ones. Too often, youngsters trying to
get out of gang situations are found dead.
http://www.thefridayflyer.com!story yrint_ friendly. php ?storyid=63 89&storypath= .IFF - 20... 3/16/2007
Story Printed From The Friday Flyer
, ~
Page 2 of2
"All gang members are basic cowards, because they never do anything alone. They roam
about in packs, like wolves and other predators," says Peoples, "Fear of retaliation is a big
factor. "
What can parents do to assist their children? Along with frank discussions about gangs and
how to practically avoid them, Peoples suggests students talk to the SDOs (school district
officers) who are available at most school sites. It is important to learn about any potential for
harm ahead of time so that officers can take preventative measures to protect the innocent
when they give information about suspected gang members or activity.
For detailed information, contact the school district at (951) 253-7000.
http://www.thefridayflyer.com/story --print_ friendly.php?storyid=6389&storypath=./FF -20.,. 3/16/2007
..
.
,,~
Marlene Paltza
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Marlene Paltza
Friday, March 16,200711 :06 AM
Marlene Paltza
Caltrans Moves to Cut Speed Limit on Highway 74
09:16 AM PDT on Friday, March 16, 2007
By SEAN NEALONThe Press-Enterprise
Responding to community concerns, Caltrans officials want to lower the speed limit on Highway 74
between Perris and Lake Elsinore.
The speed limit was increased from 55 mph to 65 mph, as mandated by state law, in August when
the 8.5-mile section of highway was widened to four lanes, Caltrans spokeswoman Shelli Lombardo
said.
Now, Caltrans is proposing to lower the speed limit to 55 mph for one-mile stretches east from the
Lake Elsinore city line and west from the Perris city line. The limit also would decrease to 60 mph in a
6.5-mile stretch between those two 55-mph sections, Lombardo said.
There is no tirneline for a decision because further research needs to be done, she said.
Business owners, residents and churchgoers on Highway 74 are pleased.
Mario Hernandez, who owns Hernandez Canterra-Tile, said he hopes he no longer will have fear
going to his mailbox or have to put on his turn signal long before he makes a turn. Members of
nearby Good Hope Missionary Baptist Church hope they won't experience a repeat of Jan. 30.
(PHOTO: Story continues below Kurt Miller / The Press-Enterprise Vernon James, a deacon at
Good Hope Missionary Baptist Church, was killed while crossing Highway 74 in January. Church
members who support lowering the speed limit along the highway include, from left, Willie Walker,
Bobbie Jo Welch, Betty Williams, and Henry Williams Jr. )
That's when a church deacon, 79-year-old Vernon James, was killed on his morning walk while
crossing the highway in front of his home in Meadowbrook, an unincorporated community between
Perris and Lake Elsinore. At least three vehicles -- none of which stopped -- struck James.
Deadly Drive
Talk of widening and straightening Highway 74 between Perris and Lake Elsinore dates to 1989. The
stretch runs between 1-215 and I-IS, where businesses and homes are scattered among rolling hills
and rock outcroppings.
1
1
Safety fueled the discussions.
Between 1988 and 1998, 55 people were killed and 1,148 injured in traffic accidents on that stretch,
according to numbers provided by the California Highway Patrol.
In the late 1990s, residents began holding rallies to call attention to the dangers of the two-lane
roadway marked by a series of sharp turns that became known as "Blood Alley."
In August, the $80 million, four-year, road-widening project ended. It doubled the width of the
highway, added a center turn lane, turnouts and intersection improvements. It also increased the
speed limit to 65 mph.
Since then, there have been 59 traffic accidents, including five in which someone was killed, CHP
spokesman Ron Thatcher said.
(PHOTO: Story continues below )
Residential Support
Those numbers aren't surprising to business owners and residents on Highway 74.
Garry Grant, who with his wife, Thelma, led the community-driven effort to widen Highway 74,
supports lowering the speed limit.
He also wants to see additional traffic lights, especially because of traffic from the rapid commercial
and residential development in Perris and Lake Elsinore.
Hernandez, the shop owner, said a lower speed limit would give trucks leaving his business and
neighboring businesses more time to enter the highway.
Bobbie Jo Welch also supports lowering the speed limit.
She lives on Mountain A venue and attends Good Hope Missionary Baptist Church down the street.
The church is at the corner of Mountain and Highway 74, across the street from Hernandez Canterra-
Tile.
Welch said lowering the speed limit would make it safer for adults and children who have to walk to
get the bus.
Fellow church member and deacon Henry Williams Jr. said he believes lowering the speed limit will
help people who walk along the highway, such as James, the church deacon who was killed in
January.
With few traffic lights and crosswalks, it's difficult for elderly people like James to cross the street, he
2
;.
~
~
said.
"They used to call it 'Blood Alley: " Williams Jr. said. "When he got hit and killed, the name came
back."
Reach Sean Nealon at 951-375-3730 or snealon@PE.com
Slowing Traffic
Caltrans is proposing lowering the speed limit on Highway 74 between Perris and Lake Elsinore, less
than a year after the limit was increased to 65 mph. The proposed changes are:
Lower speed limit to 55 mph for a one-mile stretch heading west out of Perris and a one-mile stretch
heading east out of Lake Elsinore.
Lower limit to 60 mph in the 6.5-mile section between the proposed 55-mph zones.
3
I!'lland communities battle graffiti I Inland News IPE.com I Southern California News I Ne... Page I of3
r- ~
/ I
PE~'~~~;IlIlf",'r
. ,
]'I'OIN"" '
", ._'e; ,,'" '_ 'j, Z"'.' \' _ 11','1
nl ,an: l,;, fews,
Inland communities battle graffiti
W"~~I!STO.v :2'!!!!LI
~ Download stOl)'_Rodcast
09:35 AM PDT on Thursday, April 5, 2007
By SONJA BJELLAND
The Press-Enterprise
Inland govemments spend more than $2 million annually to cover, clean and tackle tagging and graffiti.
lndio and Riverside County agencies are among those that have gone high tech with global-positioning
systems and video cameras.
The cities of San Jacinto and Riverside can take the parents of offenders to court to reimburse the
municipalities for the cost of cleanup.
Story continues below
Silvia Flores / The Press-Enterprise
Alex Ramirez of Riverside Public Works Department
removes graffiti from a light pole on Cypress Avenue in
Riverside. High-tech GPS and video cameras are being used
http://www.pe.com/localnews/inland/stories/PE_News_Local_R~affiti05.c8fIfd.html
4/5/2007
Inland communities battle graffiti I Inland News I PE.com I Southern California News I Ne... Page 2 of3
in the fight against graffiti.
Other agencies are trying to put more police on patrol, and all Inland cities or communities paint over
graffiti or use high-pressure water to blast away the markings within hours in order to deter the
vandalism.
So far this year, graffiti incidents have increased in many locations, said Riverside police Detective
Cathy Nelson, who is on the Southern California Graffiti Task Force.
"A lot of our youth feel there aren't any consequences, and we need to change that," Nelson said.
Tagging and graffiti are becoming more commonplace for a variety ofreasons, including MySpace
chatter about new markings that encourage offenders, Nelson said.
Tagging refers to writing a name or moniker and is the work of tagging crews, typically not violent
groups. Graffiti is often more elaborate and even artistic than tagging and can be painted by vandals who
are not part of a gang or tagging crew.
Officials have yet to find a sure-fire way to thwart the problem, Nelson said.
"I always tell them (the violators) someday they'll be an adult, and they'll be victimized because they'll
be paying taxes for the cleanup," Nelson said.
In September, a IO-person Riverside city work force responded to 1,305 graffiti calls. In January, there
were 2,139 calls, said Siobhan Foster, public works director.
It costs the city almost $700,000 a year to water-blast or paint over all the tagging and graffiti.
A year ago, Indio noticed an increase in graffiti and the city decided painting over it wasn't enough, said
police spokesman Benjamin Guitron. Indio created a task force comprised of one sergeant, one officer
and three public works employees.
In addition, the city bought a $120,000 graffiti truck equipped with a global-positioning system, a
computer to match paint, a pressure washer and digital cameras. All the gadgets help document the
locations and types of vandalism left mostly by tagging crews, Guitron said.
Riverside County purchased two similar vans and has a place on its Web site where residents can report
graffiti.
Corona has recently been hit hard with the markings done more by tagging crews than gang members,
said Detective Bob Newman. The public works department plans to implement a system soon to track
patterns of graffiti, but taggers keep making it difficult, Newman said.
Grand Terrace plans to add a host of cameras already posted at City Hall and Rollins and Pico parks,
said Steve Berry, assistant city manager. Hemet uses cameras with an electronic voice that yells at
potential taggers and takes pictures of them. The city is also installing some digital cameras.
An anti-vandalism ordinance passed in San Jacinto in November allows the city to fine minors $1,000 if
they are caught in the act. It also prohibits all youths from having Sharpie pens, glass-etching tools or
http://www.pe.com/localnews/inlandlstoriesIPE_News_Local_R_graffiti05.c8f1fd.html
4/512007
. ' Inland communities battle graffiti I Inland News I PE.com I Southern California News I Ne... Page 3 of 3
cans of spray paint.
,
The ordinance also will allow San Jacinto to go after the parents civilly to recoup the costs of cleanup as
has already been done by the city of Riverside.
Riverside City Attorney Greg Priamos said he has filed about a dozen lawsuits against parents of
offenders, recouping about $30,000.
"It's proven to be the most effective means to prevent these taggers from doing this again," he said.
Riverside plans to file a lawsuit against the parents of two Norte Vista High School students whom
police said were caught tagging an apartment building in February and arrested on suspicion of
vandalism and conspiracy, according to Riverside police.
"It can get very expensive very fast," Priamos said.
Staff writers Julie Farren, Tammy McCoy, Sandra Baltazar-Martinez and Sarah Gordon contributed to
this report
Reach Sonja Bjelland at 951-368-9642 or Ifbjelland@PE.com
http://www.pe.comllocalnewslinlandJstoriesIPE_News_Local_R~affiti05.c8f1fd.html
4/5/2007
"1-
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
REPORT TO PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION
TO: CHAIRMAN AND COMMISSION MEMBERS
FROM: MARK DENNIS, INFORMATION/COMMUNICATIONS MANAGER
DATE: APRIL 11,2007
SUBJECT: ANTI-GANG TASK FORCE PRESENTATION (LEPD)
BACKGROUND
This is a presentation and briefing by the LEPD about the anti-gang unit to inform the PSAC of
current anti-gang efforts related to graffiti, vandalism and general public safety.
DISCUSSION
The LEPD has a dedicated unit assigned to local gang activity and intervention. Eight County
Regional Gang Task Forces are funded by the Sheriffs Department and the DA's Office. Lake
Elsinore and Perris Sheriff Station areas comprise Region 6. Region 6 began operation in August of
2006. The Management Team of the Region 6 Task Force is comprised of the head law enforcement
officials in Perris, Lake Elsinore, and the County (LEPD Chief, Perris PD Chief, DA's Office,
Probation Dept. and State Parole managers as well). The Region 6 Task Force services are a part of
the many benefits the Sheriffs Department provides to contract cities as well since they work in the
cities as well as in the county areas.
Sheriff Bob Doyle and District Attorney Rod Pacheco have recently been quoted in the media about
the need to increase the budget for the County's anti-gang task force; stating that anti-gang staffing
levels are below the desired level in Jurupa and in the City of Lake Elsinore (see attachment' A,'
clippings from The Californian and The Friday Flyer).
LEPD currently has two full-time Special Enforcement Team (Gang) Investigators serving within
the City. These two Investigators work very closely with the Region 6 Gang Task Force, which
is housed at the Lake Elsinore Station.
FISCAL IMPACT
The information presented this evening is for discussion only and no additional budget
recommendation is attached.
RECOMMENDATION
Information for PSAC discussion.
'GENOA ITEM NO.
PAGE
:l\
I OFL
.: Print Version:.
I'age 1 of 2
ATTACHMENT A
Editions of the North County Times Serving San Diego and Riverside Counties
Thursday, March 22, 2007 Contact Us
News Search
Home News
Subscribe
eo. . . Q C
__ IlIogt NV_. _be CoIone1ar, Homes Joll
Web Search Classified Search Advertising Home Delivery Reader Services Traffic Stock.
Sports Business Opinion , Entertainment Features Colu'mnists' Cor
Previous Issues Letters ,Obituaries Place An Ad Send Feec
, ~,aglilii,l
, Thursday, March 22, 2007
Last modified Thursday, March '22, 2007 12:02 AM PDT
Board delays budget request for anti-gang unit
By: CHRIS BAGLEY - Staff Writer
LAKE ELSINORE - Riverside County financial managers are looking for ways to beef up anti-
gang operations after the county's governing board put off a rare midyear request for more
funding,
District Attorney Rod Pacheco and Sheriff Bob Doyle have asked the county's Board of
Supervisors for $344,000 they say is necessary to obtain software and equipment and hire
deputies for the remaining three months of the fiscal yearending June 30.
('\iVided board put off the request until mid-April, with two s~pervisors Objecting'to what they called a p;ece~eal
approach.
I Pacheco and Doyle said they're making the request because the county's gang task force has understaffed units
in Lake Elsinore and Jurupa Valley. Those two teams have four sheriff's deputies each, compared with six
deputies each in other units throughout the county, authorities said:
"The work, unfortunately, is not done," Pacheco told the board. "Quite frankly, those teams are currently unsafe."
Bill Luna, finance director for the county's executive office, said he plans to meet with Doyle or deputies in
, coming weeks to discuss the possibility of covering part or all of the request.
Doyle and Pacheco's predecessor, Grover Trask, launched the program early last year with support from cities
and their police departments.
I
Supervisors Bob Buster, whose district includes Lake Elsinore and parts of Riverside, and Roy Wilson, who
represents Palm Springs and points east, said piecemeal hiring might lead to additional arrests of gang members
and perhaps even convictions, but would prove ineffectual without new jail space for convicts.
Buster said he found it "disturbing" that law enforcement leaders hadn't notified him of difficulties in Lake Elsinore
before Tuesday's meeting.
Lake Elsinore Mayor Bob Magee said he's still waiting for Pacheco to brief the City Council on the task force's
activities, a condition that the city set in agreeing to provide extra funding for anti-gang operations in its area.
Magee said he agrees with the idea of hiring more deputies and investigators, but won't support it until he gets
more details.
() county recently declared its top construction priority to be a new jail. The board should hold off on Pacheco's
and Doyle's request until June, when it begins to make spending decisions for the coming fiscal year, which
begins in July, Buster and Wilson said.
(
\
AGENDA ITEM NO. .;( /
http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2007/03/22/news/californian/4_:.o1_ 003_21_ 07.prt PAGE 2 OF S-'
StOry Printed From The Friday Flyer
Page 1 of2
n aTIlE FRIDAYFLUR
March 16, 2007
.','
School Daze: Gan'g task force
By Jeanie Corral
Reporter/Colunmist
news@goldingpublications,com
Gangs. The mere mention of the word can bring feelings of stress, fear,
misunderstanding and anger to most parents of school age children.
Do we have gangs in our midst? At school? In the community? And, if
we do, how can we counteract their influence?
A recent parent workshop on gang awareness in the schools points out
that in the Lake Elsinore Unified School District there are indeed street gangs that are alive
and well,
According to Riverside County's Lt. Bob Peoples of the gang task force, in recent months
there were some 660 officers who came to do sweeps in the four counties of Orange,
Riverside, Los Angeles and San Diego that netted 47 offenders.
Parents and l.ecal educators watched, listened and asked questions about what can be done
to protect children from the effects of gang life styles that are so prominently glamorized by
.' video games, movies and other popular culture icons.
(\, Bob told parents that they "are the eyes and ears" for the community at large and if they
suspect their children are flirting with the idea of becoming gang members, communication
and quick action can mean the difference between life and death, literally.
"Gang members end up in one of two ways: incarcerated or dead," he states.
Local gangs in the area such as the Elsinore Young Classics, which began as a car club and
has evolved as the most active and violent gang, or the Vatos Locos (Crazy Bats) have been
around for more than 25 years. Other gangs such as the Four Corners Hustlers and the
Yarborough Park Crips are still relatively new in terms of time.
The OCP (Out Causing Panic) group has had more than 60 members arrested and more
than 500 identified members in the area.
Many people who see the graffiti on walls, buildings or billboards often have no idea what is
being expressed. Often people feel graffiti is simply an offshoot of those who are disenchanted
with life; but according to the task force, all graffiti has messages that warn other gangs
about territories or directly threaten harm. Many graffiti artists can demonstrate proficiency In
their use of color and drawing skills but the overall message of graffiti Is that a gang is trying
to come into an area and wants to intimidate the residents.
Gangs come in all shapes, sizes and age levels. They are not the exclusive purview of ethnic
groups and are usually born out of cultural poverty. There are white supremacy gangs, gangs
of mixed ethnic backgrounds, prison gangs and street gangs. But all gangs adhere to a
criminal culture that puts allegiance to them first, above religion, family relationships,
friendship and most assuredly the law.
Colors and clothing often denote a gang attitude, and those unaware of what such colors or
clothing mean to gang members can be In for trouble.
According to the gang suppression task force, parents must be Involved directly with their
(r:hildrenln such a way that they can prevent youngsters from being lulled Into a sense that a
\,.. gang "isn't such a bad thing." Those who become gang members are never released without
great pain and ongoing fear for the lives of their loved ones. Too often, youngsters trying to
get out of gang situations are found dead. AGENDA ITEM NO. ,;v
. . PAGL'j OF--L
http://www.thefridayflyer.conllstory -prin(friendly.php?storyid=6389&storypath;",/FF -20... 3/16/2007
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
REPORT TO PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION
TO:
CHAIRMAN AND COMMISSION MEMBERS
FROM:
MARK E. DENNIS
INFORMATION & COMMUNICATIONS MANAGER
DATE:
APRIL 11, 2007
SUBJECT:
i
STATUS REPORT FOR SHORELINE ZONE IDENTIFICATION
I
SIGNAGE AND CHANNELING OF VISITORS TO CONTROLLED
ACCESS POINTS
BACKGROUND
On August 17, 2005, the City Council received the final "Lake Elsinore Shoreline Safety
Assessment" report from Tom Griffiths, aquatic safety expert. Council directed the PSAC and City
Staff to implement the key recommendations from the report. Subsequently, the PSAC and Staff
developed a "Shoreline Safety Implementation Plan", which included a tasklist and timeline to
implement the key objectives of the report.
Staff provided a PowerPoint Presentation to the PSAC in November 2006 on the status of the
"Shoreline Safety Implementation Plan"; therefore this status report will specifically highlight recent
accomplishments and new actions in the areas of (fask-I) Shoreline Zone Identification and (fask-5)
Channel Visitors to Controlled Access Points.
DISCUSSION
TASK-l. Shoreline Zone Identification:
Following receipt of authorization letters from all privately owned commercial boat launching
facilities open to the general public, a City contractor completed the installation of Shoreline Zone
Identification poles and signage in February 2007.
The Shoreline Zone Identification sign poles and safety signage have been installed at 16 of 19
originally designated locations per the Shoreline Zone Identification schematic. Poles and
identification signage have NOT been installed at the designated locations known as RS2, GS4 and
GS5 due to the reasons stated below.
The shoreline at the City's Campground (RS2) is currently closed. The entire shoreline is fenced and
posted "Closed, No Trespassing". Rehabilitation of the campground by Destination RV Resorts is
anticipated to get underway in the next few months and may take two years to complete. The
Shoreline Zone sign poles and signage will be installed as part of the construction.
AGENDA ITEM NO. 62 3
PAGE,..- L _OF....l...
PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION
APRIL 11, 2007
PAGE 2
Perret Park, previously designated as OS4, has been closed for several years; however the County of
Riverside is refurbishing the park, which should be open to the public sometime soon. City Staff has
encouraged the participation by the County in the City's Shoreline Safety Implementation Plan by
offering the shoreline identification sign poles and safety information signage free of charge. The
County has not responded to the offer.
Lakeland Marine, previously designated as OS5, is out of business and not open to the general
public; therefore City Staff is reluctant to install the shoreline zone identification signage at a private
residence.
TASK-5 Channel Visitors to Controlled Access Points:
To ensure communication of safety information to the general public the Shoreline Safety
Implementation Plan calls for channeling visitors to controlled access points passed posted safety
signage. For the Mid-Year FY'06-'07 Budget Review, City Staff prepared a recommendation and
budget for City Council's review and approval to make improvements to the City's main beach for
the purpose of executing Phase-II of the Shoreline Safety Implementation Plan (please see
attachment). City Council approved the funding for the project in February 2007.
To date, Staff has completed asphalt paving of Lakeshore Drive's road shoulder in front of the main
beach area and striped the parking spaces, bicycle lane and pedestrian walkway. Staff prepared plans
and specifications for the fencing required to reduce access to the beach to just five (5) locations. A
"Notice Inviting Public Bids" for industrial strength aluminum fencing was advertised in the local
newspaper on March 30th. The bid opening date for the fencing is April 12th. City Council is
scheduled to consider making the bid award for the purchase of the fencing at the April 24 th Council
meeting. If approved, Staff will place the order once a purchase order number is recei ved from the
Finance Department. Staff anticipates delivery ofthe fencing by June I st. Installation of the fencing
shall be completed by June 29th.
FISCAL IMPACT
None.
RECOMMENDATION
Recei ve and file status report.
PREPARED BY:
PAT KILROY, Director of LAKE AND AQUATIC RESOURCES
AGENDA ITEM NO. 0?"3
PAGE .;?, OF 8'"
T.__
.."'5caIWas/)
,"
Ii
.
~
"
.~ ~
~ c
t
Il
"
~1(
GTilndAve. S
WNE LOCATION ACTIVITY ZONE LOCA nON
~ Lake Department Headquarters IRssj Elsinore West Marina =a~
500 W. Lakeshore Drive 32700 Riverside Drive III
(951) 674-7730
ILSll Seaport Boat Launch a IG81] Crane Lakeside Park & Resort a=a~
500 W. Lakeshore Drive 15980 Grand Ave. .~
[LSZ) Elm Grove Beach =am [<18ZI Weekend Paradise a=a~
Lindsay St. at Lakeshore Drive 16006 Grand Ave. II~
[LS3] Lowell Street Fishing Beach ~ IGS3) Playland RV Park a=a~
At Lakeshorc Drive 16730 Grand Ave. .~
~ Davis Street Fishing Beach ~ IG841 Perret Park
At Lakeshore Drive 32938 Perret Blvd.
I1,SS) Whiskers Fishing Beach ~ [GSS] Lakeland Marine (Boat Repair)
Townsend Sl at Lakeshore Dr. 18010 Grand Ave.
IRS II Lake Park Motel & RV . [5511 Levee System entrance at III 111 a =
32000 Riverside Drive Pete Lehr Dr & Diamond Circle
[RS2] LERA Campground a=~ IS8z1 Levee System entrance at III 111 a =
32040 Riverside Drive 1ilI~ Pete Lehr Dr. & Diamond Circle
IRS3) The Outhouse a=~ [SS3) Levee System entrance at IIIl11a=
32310 Riverside Drive .~ Pete Lehr Dr. & Diamond Circle ~
IRS4] Roadrunner RV Park a=a. ISS4] Levee System entrance at 11111
32500 Riverside Drive Pete Lehr Dr,& Diamond Circle
AGENDA ITEM NO. ':<:3
PAGL3 OFL
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
MEMORANDUM
TO: Bob Brady, City Manager
FROM: Pat Kilroy, Director of Lake & Aquatic Resources
DATE: January 5, 2007
SUBJECT: Mid- Year Budget Request to Implement Shoreline Safety Plan and Phased
Improvements to the Main Beach.
Phase-II implementation of the Shoreline Safety Plan primarily consists of channeling visitors
to controlled access points to communicate important safety information posted at these
specified locations. This is especially imperative at the City's main beach along Lakeshore
Drive. There are two ways to approach this project. A long-term approach would complete
the improvements all at once per the City's CIP budget, about six years from now.
Alternatively, a phased approach would immediately construct certain improvements to satisfy
urgent needs, while developing detailed plans and a funding mechanism over a longer period
of time.
A long-term approach would require the creation of detailed plans and specifications for the
entire main beach area, followed by substantial funding to implement the project in its entirety.
This type of approach is included in the City's unfunded CIP budget estimated at $1,560,000
(Project ill No. U.LKE-OOOI). In addition, the long-term approach would also need to
consider the expansion of the Seaport Boat Launch from four to eight lanes, plus provide 100
parking spaces. In the future, this project may be eligible for grant funding by the California
Department of Boating & Waterways.
Alternatively, a phased approach would consist of phasing improvements over next 7 years,
with immediate construction of certain elements to improve safety, parking and beach
amenities in 2007. Attached is a budget and general layout to implement this phased approach.
This approach would exclude major improvements to drainage, landscaping and parking lot.
The source of funds for these suggested improvements in 2007 would be expended from the
Developer Impact Fees (DIP) under Fund #118 for Lake Side Facilities.
cc. Matt Pressey, Director of Administrative Services
I
AGENDA ITEM NO. ~3
PAGE i OFL
Implementation Budget
Shoreline Safety Plan & Phased Improvements to Main Beach
Item Descrintlon I Function I Costs
Roadwiiil, Walkwav& Fence Construction:
Mobilization Eauioment & suoolv mobilization $ 10,000
Demolition, clearinn & nrubbiriCI Remove bollards & trees. $ 4,000
Realian Irriaation Svstem Move sorinkler heads. $ 2,000
Grade road shoulder & walkway and compact
Gradina & Excavation base material. $ 5,000
Asnhalt navinn Pave road shoulder & walkwav $ 100,000
AC Planter & Parkinn Curbs Construct asphalt planter & install parking stops. $ 29,000
Landscanina Plants & plantina $ 20,000
Decorative Fencina Channel visitors to controlled access ooints. $ 60,000
Striping Stripe parking area and walkway. $ 4,500
subtotal - $ 234,500
Beach Imnrovements:
Sand Reolacement Cut 6" dirt & disoose, imoort river sand & smead. $ 60,000
6 Shade Structures with concrete nads. 12'x12' Alumawood oatio covers wI concrete Dad $ 45,000
6 Concrete Picnic Tables $ 5,500
6 BBOs $ 1,500
8 Fire Rinas $ 1,500
2 Charcoal Disnosal Trashcans $ 1,000
6 Concrete Benches $ 5,000
2 Vollevball Courts $ 4,000
subtotal I $ 123,500
Subtotal Construction Costs $ 358,000
ContirlcJenCV/..10"lo of Construction costs) $ 35,000
Non-Construction Costs:
Admin, Ennineerinn& Insnection $ 20,000
Environmental, Soil T estina, Survevina $ 15,000
Subtotal Non-Construction Costs $ 35,000
TOTAL PROJECT COSTS $ 428,000
AGENDA ITEM NO. ~.3
PAGE 5'" OF 3"
-
-=
CJ
a1
=
=
..
~
~
o
....
'"
....
=
CIl
a
CIl
~
t.o
.........
........:..:..:..: -':'::':'" ....,'
I ,.... :.:..:.....::....,...,.>.<.'...::\:
.... ,'....:.. '., ~ ...<.-.: :. :.:: : ,", ';'.:.
.... .... ". ........~ ...... . .. ....
''''/''',,,?,,.. . ....;;
"
"
'"
co
<>::::\:
......
....:..
::.:..
,I:<
%'""
"'J9'~
I
J
1]::1
---_..-.-
...--.p.....
-~_..__....
O'Iili...""Clo._
-
a;
.a '"
" ...
"
"
<'5
w
....
(.)
(/)
SII"IS ~U!~J"d
...
I-
o
Z
!SP!6110fJ6<JI/SiX3..
..
...
c
..
E
..
>
o
..
C:::::;;I
..' ~
~r'I~:
.E
~
<>
..
..
m
c
';;
:iE
C=:l
' ';
""
a;
.a
"
"
~
'"
'"
"
~
'x
!!:!.
00
<D
I~
- '"
OeD
N_
"
co
43
GENOA ITEM NO. Fr
PAGE {p 'OF_
1JIIJI1jIlmillllllM!liF IImW 0 IlIlIlll!Iil\I
I
I
I
.
,
i
I
r~r
.-i---j
,
Ii -:
'1-
! I
'1-::1-,
I, ,
i l ~
I --'-
:.-t1~--
- f
: -~--~ _\.=-~
.c
y
~
~
=
=
.;
:;?j
.s
~
....
=
~
El
~
e
~
]
"
.
~
~
~
~ .
J
"!
~ =
.~
~j
i~
H
H
~ .
~I
"
~
f-<
OJ
'2
OJ
.~
10-.
"
-
~
g
o
U
-, r
\
'~
, }:-
~i',f-., . ~/ ,il ;
, . ' I
, '~ ' , I
I ,I. I_
t::') /
, ! .
~;
- "
Eo<
C/
~
~
~
10-.
~
OJ
E
r:n
"
--g
..c:
r:n
"0
o
~
~
:;;:
]
"0
~
"
~
;>
o
a
~
gp
.~
"
~
~
.~
:;;:
~
~"'3
.0
~
AGENDA ITEM NO. .:13
PAGE I{ OFL
~
LAKE .5.LSi~
~ DIUAM t;(r~EME
City of Lake Elsinore
Lake and Aquatic Resources Department
NOTICE INVITING BIDS
FOR
PROJECT NO. 4280
INDUSTRIAL STRENGTH ALUMINUM FENCING
PUBLIC NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City of Lake Elsinore will receive
sealed bids up to 2:00 p.m. on Thursday, the 12th day of April, 2007, in the office of the
City Clerk, at which time said bids will be publicly opened and read. The office of the
City Clerk is located at 130 South Main Street, Lake Elsinore, CA 92530. Sealed bids
must arrive in the City Clerk's office prior to the scheduled bid opening.
Each bid shall be made on the Prooosal Form furnished in the Bid Packet and enclosed in
an envelope supplied by the bidder. The outside of the bidder's envelope shall bear the
bidder's name, address, title of the work ("ALUMINUM FENCING") and marked:
"SEALED BID, DO NOT OPEN UNTIL 2:00 P.M., April 12, 2007". It is the sole
responsibility of the bidder to ensure that his bid is received in proper time in the City
Clerk's Office at the address and time hereinabove set forth. Any bid received after the
scheduled closing time for receipt of bids shall be returned to the bidder unopened.
The Project consists of the purchase of specified goods by the City of Lake Elsinore and
referred to as:
INDUSTRIAL STRENGTH ALUMINUM FENCING
The Project includes the purchase of fence panels, posts, ball caps and hardware as
required by the Plans and Specifications. The goods are to be in accordance with the
Plans and Specifications on file in the Office of the Clerk of the City, and said Plans and
Specifications are by reference made part of this Notice.
Plans and Specifications may be examined at the front desk of the Building Division of
the City of Lake Elsinore, 130 South Main Street, Lake Elsinore, California. The Plans,
Specifications and all Contract Documents may be obtained at the front desk of the
Building Division of the City of Lake Elsinore for a non-refundable charge of ten dollars
($10.00) plus an additional fee of five dollars ($5.00) for postage and handling if mailing
is requested.
The City of Lake Elsinore reserves the right to reject any or all bids, to waive any
irregularities in a bid and to award the Contract as may best serve the interests of the
City. All proposals are binding for a period of thirty (30) days after they are opened and
may be retained by the City for examination and comparison.
Date:
,2007
Michelle Soto, Acting City Clerk
City of Lake Elsinore
Publish:
,2007
-1-
AGENDA rTEM NO.
PAGE
~3
<l OF-'-
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
REPORT TO PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION
TO: CHAIRMAN AND COMMISSION MEMBERS
FROM: MARK DENNIS, INFORMATION/COMMUNICATIONS MANAGER
DATE: APRIL 11,2007
SUBJECT: LAKE PATROL PRESENTATION (LEPD)
BACKGROUND
This is a presentation and briefing by the LEPD about the Lake Patrol to inform the PSAC of current
lake patrol staffing and operating duties.
DISCUSSION
A specially trained team of officers from the Riverside County Sheriffs Department functions as the
Lake Patrol on Lake Elsinore. Sergeant Michael Yates is the Lake Patrol supervisor.
Duties include enforcement of:
. California Boating Law
. City Ordinances
. Sport Fishing Regulations
. Health and Safety Regulations
The Lake Patrol also coordinates with the Lake Elsinore Marine Search & Rescue (LEMSAR),
which is a volunteer group dedicated to maintaining safety on the Lake. LEMSAR assists in
responding to disabled boaters, providing aid in emergencies and patrol on the water during peak
periods, such as weekends. VHF Marine Radio Stations #16 and #68 are used to access LEMSAR
and the Lake Patrol. Public calls to the Sheriff's Dispatch at 1-800-950-2444 can also be used to
relay emergency information to the Lake Patrol.
FISCAL IMPACT
The information presented this evening is for discussion only and no additional budget
recommendation is attached.
RECOMMENDATION
Information for PSAC discussion.
)GENDA ITEM NO. ).:l..
PAGE.I OF -I-
CITY OF LAKE ELSINORE
REPORT TO PUBLIC SAFETY ADVISORY COMMISSION
TO: CHAIRMAN AND COMMISSION MEMBERS
FROM: MARK DENNIS, INFORMATION/COMMUNICATIONS MANAGER
DATE: APRIL 11,2007
SUBJECT: PUBLIC OUTREACH SHEDULE: PSAC RECOMMENDED ACTIVITIES
BACKGROUND
The FY 2006-07 PSAC Outreach and Education projects that have been recommended by PSAC are
being actively scheduled for production and implementation. As the new FY 07-08 budget is being
developed, additional PSAC outreach activities will be added.
DISCUSSION
Public Outreach is a stated goal of the PSAC under Ordinance 1116. In the current fiscal year, which
ends June 30, the following outreach efforts (and encumbered funds) are scheduled:
I. Development of Graffiti Ordinance direct mailerlbrochure and business outreach program;
2. Graffiti Hotline implementation and publicity;
3. Development of Fireworks Ordinance direct mailerlbrochure and flyers;
4. Outdoor billboard and newspaper advertising campaign for Fireworks safety;
5. OUTLOOK "Public Safety" special issue;
6. Revision ofPSAC background brochure (draft attached);
7. Web page updates for all PSAC outreach programs, including Code Enforcement service
request form Web page.
Staffwill distribute a master schedule for implementing the above at the April meeting. PR budget
placeholders for PSAC recommended activities will be incorporated in the FY 2007-08 budget.
FISCAL IMPACT
Sufficient funding for advertising, printing and direct mail is available in the existing Public
Information operating budget for FY 2006-07 (from advertising, postage and professional services
accounts). No additional budget appropriation is needed in FY 06-07. The Fiscal Year 2007-08
operating budget will be updated to include additional funding for PSAC outreach expenditures.
RECOMMENDATION
Receive and File.
AGENDA ITEM NO.
PAGE
1i
I OFL
I-..
&&..
~
Q
~
o
~
"-'
:::E
"-'
'"
x
u.J
:::E
........... ~ u
(/) a ::i
~ cQ
~tr~~~. j',~
~ ~V~~ r(;'''''j~
oSZ
1: cc
u~
C GI
~
0 ..
'v; - " ~
QI ,!!) 0 <11 <11
..
'" E >- .. c ..
'"
.- E III 0 <11 <11
0 "tl Q. U <11
0 .. ~
<11 ..
Z U GI '" Vl
>- C '" ~
'~ :l C
tn ~ "tl E GI .. 'iij
o GI ~ C .. ~
c '~ 3: <11 d. ::2:
.s:: GI GI U
.- ~
... " "tl .. ~ 0 <11 .s::
0 3: 3: ..
QI <( c 0 ~ ~
QI 0 '" -0 0 0
>- '" c
.. v ~ z
:: -l!! GI 'v;
.. c ijJ M
'" :l 00
'" Vl >- <11 ~
.- .!:! .. ~ ..III:
- GI .. '"
..c :0 > c -'
::s :l GI 0
0.. '" E
Q. <11 'Q)
.s:: OJ
l- E
_n_.___"
z
o
?2 ~
o -
V') ~
;> ~
o 0
";""'<;::t~,.,;;;".".,.,~,.,...... ,.,';,'
r;:(#I"\ ,. 0' "",.. ., , '
.'f'.;J.? "", ../;..::;~ . ,::.':.,," .
~
~
~
11/
....
<11 ~
C c 06
0 u
.!:! '''' c <(
'" 0 V) 0
:0 E 01 0- , co g
c E ~ en
" " 01 ~
:l ~ '" 0 ~ N
-E ~ <'J <li " 0 "'"
Q. .. -E ~ ~ '" CJ
c 'E .., " <li == <C
<11 .. x " ~ ,-
.s:: .c '" " c: , V> E ~ CL
.. U <11 " 'Vi c: < c: 0 ::2
<( :l Q; 'Vi ,- ~
0 :l <'J (Q:.=; '0
Vl '" , Q; :; '" <C '"
.. e- M "
0.. 0 <11 -'" "' u Q <5
0 C .. ~ "'" '" ..c: ,,' Z ~
<11 ~ "" ~
~ -E ~ ~ .... ~ ~ :J (; w
3: Q. 0 '!:! 0 CJ
0 <11 .,; '* ;;; '" ;: VI ,!;: <C
<11 .. <11 ~ ;: 0-'"
~ 'v; .. '" a. ;: cow
'" :l '" " - "
.c ,!:! c: ,- iU ""
'" ~ c 0 '" ~ '"
0'1 E :0 ..c: !i' 'Vi ...J
C :l 0- W .0
.'" ~ 0'1 Q. "
<11 :l C :;;:
<11 0
::2: .. .'"
<11
'v; <11
:;: E
"
<11 t:i
QJ ~ <0-
<11 0 ~
<11 0'1
~ 0'1 0
.s:: :;: <11
.. '"
OJ .. .. <11
'" ~ ..III:
'" 0 ..E ~
OJ ..
.s:: c '" '"
.. E ..
" 0 '"
III OJ .'" ~ <11
J.. " 'v; <11 '"
..
QI c c ~ c
C . <11 '" '" 0
c: .. ~ OJ 'v;
0 X .. >- '"
. <:J OJ <11 ~ 'E
.- c: ~ *8 ..... '" .s:: :l
III <:J ..... 0 '" .. E
III ~ 0\ '0 0\ 0 0 .s:: 0'1 0
.- 0 \5 0 N 0 N C LL 0
E 'is 0 0 III ...... c:: ...... 'u .;:: on U
N N t: 0 0
\5 ...... QJ ...... M 0 M C :l E 0'1
E 0 '-' 0 ::J ...... M ...... :l " ~ C
C M S: M ~ '" "tl ...... C '" 0 '" <11 'c
...... ...... al C '" :i2 u E ..
. '" I I
0 0 '" .. C ::J I .. >- ~ ~ 'iij
u .. I ~ I :c ..... III Vl 0 Vl .. <11 '" E
'i 0 0 <11
'<I' lll'<l' 0 GI 0 Z 0 0 .. >- QJ
'c 0 III 0
U GI 0 N .;: N QJ U ~ ~
0 ~ N GI
J: 0 :.: N III ...... GI ...... -" ...... .s:: <( ::J OJ
c:C N ..... ~ Vl -E .s::
c ...... >-~ . N fti , ~ ...... I- 0.. ..
VI ~ III...... .. ...... > ..... ..... .
0 ...... llC ..... Q N
Q. llC .....
<11
'-'
C '"
'" Q. <(
" ?:- 'u
<0- ~ Vl
0 0 o .- .
'" c 0
'" u .- :l 0 '"
E ~ '-' ~::2: N
~ '" ~ " 'c
<11 C <( <11 <11 C ~
.. - >- ~ .c '" g
" ~ '" .. 0 E
'" ~C6
OJ 0 <11 -l!! c
.. 'v; :l
C .S '" .. u
::r: Vl ijJ Z c
'0 '" <11 <11
:l u <11 >- .s::
Q. ~ .c :0 ..III: .!:! E ..
Q. '" '" 0 .. "-
'" :l -' C 0
<: .. 0.. 3
<11 .- ~ <11 '0 '"
~ '" c
.. .s:: 'u Q. '"
<11 V u ~ .. Q. .Q -'
'" :l "- C <( .. 0\
Z " N 0 :l u
'" 0 C <11 C
~ - c ~ C '" .'"
<11 0 <11 U 0
C Z u .. 0 >.. 'Vi <11 <11
,...; 0 on ~ U Q. .- .. '" :0 <11
0 <.I'l 'v; ~ <( '" ~ 0 'E '" ::2:
0 '" ~ u.J .s:: ,- u
N ~ 'E > Vl u E .,; E c
>- c.. E " 0. <11
~ 0 .s:: 0 Q.
~ E ~ <11 .. 0 Q.
~ u.J ::J .s:: '~ 0 ::!. '" 0
0 -E CJ I- U U
:l f- u
--,
V)
~
-
~
::>
a
z
o
-
V)
V)
-
~
~
o
u
~
o
V)
-
>
Q
-<
~
~
~
--<
C/)
u
-
.....J
i:Q
::>
A-<
'"
QI
u '"
~ ....
:J U
o QI
~ '0'
en 0.. ~
c ,0
"0 '" '"
c E .~
:J '" U
- ~ QI
~ 01.<::
C1J e +J
.so.~
o"'C~
~ QI '"
o .... "0
In 12 OJ
.... QI QI
C ~ C
~ >......
01.... C
~~QJQ;
QI '" E ~
QI '" 0
III U ,Q. c
>..:.:: :3 'V;
-.00--
QJ::JQ)w
.::: 0."0 QI
tJ 10... C ~
<( J2 ro -l
J:
:>.
....
~
'"
Vl
E .~
0::0
~ :J
-"-
C ~
o
',t:j 'Qj
"'.<::
E ....
~ 0
o ....
Oc~
r-_",
",OQl
~.-t= .~
~-6..5
C
1.1.10"0
Vl u C
'" '"
~.<::~
........ '" c
"'::OQl
c... "0
2 'Vi
1.1.1 '" QI
:t w ~
1-<
QI
"0-....
cOO
'" \0 >
'" '<t ~
QJ QJ N 'i::
> '';: 0
o :::::l C '-.
.0"00",
t'Oro't3E
QJ c QJ ra
.sOVlO
0:-2 O'l.....
..... "'C C ti
"o"o"oQI
.~ ~ ~ E
-0.:J
E QI X '"
~ QI a)
.~ >. >. ~ 'u
c"'.ooc
oE",u:J
'Vi ..... .~ (ij 0
'E ;:: .~ 0. U
l:: ~ .- .- '"
c: .o.~.....
l:: vi'._ C .-
oQ)~::lU
U .'" 0 "" QI
'S: ""'.<::
Q)'-~Q)"'"
~~~-€o
'"
'",
~ o.~
.~ 1! 5
QI .... E
Vl vi' E
"'010
~ .~ u
Q) ~ "'C
~ OJ C
QI E '"
E u C
L.LJ ]5 .g
"0 :J '"
~ 0. E
01 ~
C c J2
Q) 'Vi C
E :J ....
QI '" c
~ ro 'i::
J2 g ~ 1:"
c 'Vi ~ u
w VI .- rc
QI -QI '" QI
~ .0 ~
.... 0 QJ .....
8a:~g
QI
c:
QI
'"
0"0
.... C
==v, rc
:0 t .....
QI QI QI
"0 .... C
C e '-
'" 0. 2:!
'" 0 C
QI ....
~ In C
:::,.... t ro
.... 0 c
c tt: '"
QI QI ....
"0", C
c i't:: ';;j
QI '" E
c.....
~ : .~ -g
c c::o '"
.- QI:J QI
~ Eo.....
..... C') OJ :B
u ::J ~ lo...
<t: to ..... U
iii U
QI
.<::
....
c
o
QI
01
'"
0.
Vl
"
I.O.l
CO
~
::>
Z
I.O.l
Z
o
:t
0.-
1:
I.O.l
i-lo
-<
Vl
U
.....
...J
CO
::>
c...
~
C
o
III
<II
'u
C
<II
C'l
..
<II
E
<II
;;;
u
=ij
<II
E
-.
<II
..
~
<II
u
~
o~
Q.C\
~
:J
0.
C
C
QI
N
.'"
'u
QI
C
C
o
..
,2
<II
....
'Vi
.0
QI
~
'"
>-
....
o
01
C
'0
'S:
o
~
0.
"0
C""
'" u
, '"
g'.o
.- "0
..>t. QI
U QI
~-
.... '"
..... .~
.f: c
'" :J
"C.E
E E
o 0
U U
g'",
0'\" :s2'~ >..
..J:;QJttlUCi.~""":=
~ >.u'<::c:l!!.f:::O~~
.- ....1o...1--t:............::Jl'O:J
Va; of'IJ ~.....t9a.V10
.!:! <II E .~ ~ ~ .... 0 :.: C .~ U
..c 0 > c ~ '''i: ::: 'u 0 ::0 >.
:0 ... "'C 0::: c ~ C ::J .~-
:::IO~ ~"Oo.gOvi'.20'U
a. ... ..... Q) 'Vi '+:; OJ VI 0') OJ
QI'^~ ~-5iZV'l~:JV'lc...c:
~c'" "':.:Qlc:~"':J.-....
"' .2 .- VI ..c u ~ ~ .~ ~ Qj ..c:
.- E '!::... u '" C l:: '" .- "0 u
wid .w:::l:.: 1;1 '" 0 E ...."0 .- 1:
U 0"'0. .oQlcuE~"O:e~
... c .5 :J I "U QJ 0 to 5 0 '-
!II'I '" C1I Q.. Q) '- ...c: u V'I '" U QJ
....,. t:: E .~ Q):;; 0 ..... ~ .~ ~ "'0 >
.. ~o",>.",>.,,;::co
", '><E.g c~''=~U:lC'''~
o\~ ~ Cl. ~.~ ~ ~ '8. g:~ g ~ e
,~~!;~~:, ~ 1, ~ i ~ ~ I .~ I t l !
_" .... v.."v ".... UNO '" U u '" 0..<::
c
o
~
u
....
~ QI
~o
'" ~
~'iii
"0"-
o <II
0""
.<::j
, ~
. 0 0.
~ ~ C
0.01",
Vl .- ::J
QI 0
Z:r:
, ,
~.",
C :J
<II~O
~QJO
<II <II M
E~~
cp cL v
g .s ~
5u~
..: .~
o.w..
<II
C C
III 0
!i::~
'I:
<II
~
U'l
-.
<II
,!:!
'0 E
Q. ni
~ 00
o ~
C :J
";;; 0
W.<::
<II ~
~iE
jo
vi'
ro",1ja.QJ
cc'-:Jo~C
O '" 0 >
'jij OJ ~ c: ::>
..... ',p Vi '" 'Vi 0
.~~aJ.1::.wt:~
ro 'c .~ ~ Q) s: QJ
Ero'-R).::t:.o.1::.
"O~~~joo
~OQ)-cvi"QJ"'C
..... ~.... 0 c: -:5 c
:J .- 0 0 0 ,'"
c.U.~..c'~ Q) C
.f: ~ ~ 0 'u~ ~ 0
w'Oo.......,p
"i6 .2 QI .<:: '" E '"
c ... ~ en VI E 'u
.g ~ j 'Qj <C ~
:.0-:5 vZ\n8 V)
"0 'S; .<:: a) Qj - <t:
to :> ..... ::J c 0 Vi
5 ~ .~ ~ ~ ~ ~
OOl"Oo::ClJE'<::
~.Q2"OE",~
~:6~~~6~
c:i
....
"'-
.f: 0
'" '"
O>QI
'" QI
.... >,
'-~.2
..E "'0 Co
"0 C E
~ 0 QI
~ u ...
..0 .~ Q)
o>E.s
c - 0
._ 0 ...
~ '" 0
'" <II '"
<II 01 ~
.<:: ~ QI
_ '" u
'V .<:: iE
'0 u 0
~ 0 ~
._ VI QJ
U c-
o '"
<C ',p VI ~
~ to .~ u'~
01-
QlClJ.oQl
..c = ::J ..c
1-100......
~
u
..
III
0.
III
is
III
!i::
'I:
<II
~
U'l
>-
..
C
::I
o
U
<II
'tl
'iii
..
<II
>
ii!
>.
....
c
~ :J
E 0
.U
o.QI
LrI"O
'- 'Vi
QI ~
~ QI
'" >
~a;
to .f:
u'<::
>-.~
~ ~
<II E
010
Qj~
E <II
QI ClJ
C:~
0(5
51-
+.:
u
III ~
.. 0
C <II N
8 U.;
C S ~
o"'o~
.::; "tJ ..VI N
llIe <<a Q; M
.. Iii C'l <i
...0 . ftI t--..
<(C'"
.5t:IlI"":
U <II :E ~ ';;j
<(..c >- .. E
'" O.'!:: I I
Q.Cl:V,,-w
'"
....
C
:J
o
U
ClJ
"0
'v;
~
QI
>
a.:
<II
"0
'Vi
....
:J
! ~ 0\
N e g
O......-r-
LrlOl'
0\ C ~
d=",
Om""':
~ u Vl
-r-~O\
U
<t:
"'~
c
0"i6
'0 "'E
C '"
:J ~
o ~
U,2
~"O
.- C
U '"
ClJ '"
.s 'Vi
o '"
.....0
'u
C
:J
o
U
'"
....
o
QI
.<::
....
o
....
'"
c c:
o 0
'.j:i ';:;
'" '"
"0 ~
C QI
QI"O
E 'Vi
E g
o u
u ~
~J2
1::
o
0.
<II
0:
~
~
:J
01
QI
~
ul
01
~
o
oj
~
o
c
'v;
QI
,
QI
""
'"
@
u
'"
'"
0.
.;
x
ClJ
'<t
~ 0 0
M ..... .....
..t .- .-
..... Vl Vl
"! <i <i
~ ..... .....
LrI "! "!
0\ ~ ~
.. LrI LrI
C 0\ 0\
QI -; ""
E > 'tl
<II 0 III
~ E 0
o <II ~
C a: ~
w "Z "0
<II := ..c
'tl III ..
o .. 0
U " l1.
'"
Qj ~ 'Vi
c:n n::s 'i::
'" C U
fij .Q "'C
:2 ~ ~
~o ~
o C. ~
>,"0
'0 t. ~
c _ '"
:J '" 0.
0"'<11
U .!::! a:
~::o ~ ...'
.- ::J QJ C
Ua.~QJ
<II - '" E
-:5 l3 .!:!! QJ
....oog>
'" -
'Vi "'C -:5 c
VI c .- ro
<t: '" ~ ~
..:
.....
u..
<r:
&
~
~~
~~
~
...1lI
1l..'l:3
~~
Q ~I
" ::1
't z u.l
c:eSl
~ W D-
,t:
]~
t;;6m
8 ~
QJ ',p
.<:: u
....<t:
<II
.... '"
'" 'c
:J <II
"i6 N
> ',p
QI 0
"0 '"
C
'" 01
~ C
QJ ',p
"0 '"
'v; QJ
C U
0_
U 0
c:i
l "t""'
i/
it'
:,
r--~
\("
.:
I'
,
I:,
f
o